- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies any-scenario person re-identification across RGB, NIR, and TIR images captured by aerial and ground cameras. It proposes Modality- and View-Aware Positional Residuals (MVPR), based on a shared CLIP visual encoder. The method includes two components. Modality-Aware Positional Residual Correction learns separate positional residuals for each modality and transformer layer. It adds the differences between consecutive residuals before each block to adjust token features. Text-Guided View Alignment uses learnable text anchors to supervise two forward passes, with the corrections disabled and enabled. For aerial images, these passes use aerial-view and ground-view targets, respectively. Ground images use ground-view targets in both passes. This guides aerial features toward a ground-view reference. The model is trained with identity classification, triplet, and text-guided losses. Experiments on WHU-MARS show improved performance across any-scenario, aerial-ground, and visible-infrared retrieval settings. Ablation studies further show the benefits of both components.
Critical strengths
1.The paper addresses a useful and challenging ReID problem involving both modality and viewpoint changes. A single model handles RGB, NIR, and TIR images from aerial and ground cameras, supporting retrieval across different combinations of these conditions.
2.The method has a clear design and reasonable. MPRC learns modality-specific positional corrections at different transformer layers, while TGVA provides explicit text targets for aerial-to-ground alignment. The two components have clear roles and work together within a shared visual encoder.
3.The reported results show consistent improvements in mAP and Rank-1 across the tested WHU-MARS settings.
Critical weaknesses
1.The motivation for using the ground view as the common reference needs further explanation. ReID requires features of the same person to support matching across views, but this goal does not by itself require one view to serve as the reference. The paper clearly defines the aerial-to-ground training targets but should better explain why this direction is helpful and what makes the ground view a suitable reference.
2.The added value of position-dependent corrections is not clearly isolated. Earlier methods such as TransReID and CMTR already use learnable embeddings to encode camera, view, or modality information. MPRC learns separate corrections for different layers and token positions. However, the paper does not compare it with a modality vector shared across positions at the same layers, using the same CLIP backbone and supervision. Table 6 tests sharing across modalities, which does not establish the benefit of position-dependent corrections.
3.This paper uses a static positional correction. MPRC shares the same residual parameters across all images of a modality. However, poses, viewpoints, and visible body regions can vary greatly within the same modality. So, I think whether using a image-based correction strategy will show a better performance?
Questions for authors
Please refers to the weaknesses.
A1: Thank you for your question. We chose ground views as the reference because they often show more details of a person’s appearance and are less affected by foreshortening. We compared ground and aerial targets in the forward pass with residuals enabled. In both settings, the pass with residuals disabled used the original-view target, and all other settings were fixed. As shown in Table A, using ground-view targets improves mAP by 1.13% and Rank-1 by 2.50% compared with using aerial-view targets. Table F in our response to Reviewer gevp also shows that paired supervision with original-view and ground-view targets improves retrieval compared with using ground-view targets in a single forward pass.
Table A: Ground versus aerial reference under paired supervision on WHU-MARS-1000.
A2: Thank you for your suggestion. We added a control with one correction vector per modality and layer, shared across token positions. This control uses the same CLIP backbone and paired text supervision as MPRC. As shown in Table B, learning separate corrections at each token position improves mAP by 0.28% and Rank-1 by 0.38% over this control. MPRC also outperforms the variant that applies modality-specific positional corrections only at the input.
Table B: Controls for the additional value of position-dependent correction.
A3: Thank you for your suggestion. We kept the supervision fixed and replaced static MPRC with an MLP that uses the CLS token to predict corrections for each token. As shown in Table C, static MPRC yields 0.31% higher mAP and 3.45% higher Rank-1 than the dynamic variant. These results favor sharing corrections across images of the same modality in this setting.
Table C: Image-dependent versus static correction.