acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Parametric Neural Lyapunov Verification with a Shared Partition

Abstract

▎ Independent verification characterizes the disturbance a neural Lyapunov certificate tolerates by rebuilding the branch-and-bound computation at every disturbance size and every candidate level. We show that on every state box the residual is affine in the disturbance size and in the decrease rate, with coefficients that depend on neither, so bounding those coefficients once gives a valid residual bound for every size and rate, and one adaptive partition of the state region serves the whole sweep. The same stored bounds, with validated points, bracket the smallest certificate level that survives a given disturbance size, from above and below and at every size in the interval rather than at the tested sizes alone, at a measured extra cost. On a power-system swing model and a Van der Pol oscillator the shared partition answers the same sequence of checks with 5.75 to 8.42 times fewer bound calls than independent verification. On seven released neural controllers for four plants, from two published pipelines, it uses 2.39 to 15.61 times fewer. In both comparisons it preserves every level the independent run certified. The same stored bounds answer decrease rates at or below the trained rate without a further bound call, and the advantage grew with the state dimension on a family of coupled oscillators. The partition is computation that branch-and-bound verification already performs, kept and reused instead of discarded with the answer.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
neural Lyapunov certificates, formal verification of neural networks, branch and bound, bound propagation, verification reuse, input-to-state stability, certified control, parametric specifications

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_tQTvOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces a parametric neural Lyapunov framework that verifies system stability across a continuous range of disturbance magnitudes. The method leverages the residual's affine dependence on these magnitudes to reuse cached bounds and a shared branch-and-bound partition, which significantly accelerates verification problems. Additionally, it computes certified upper and lower bounds for the Lyapunov threshold throughout the target interval. Evaluations on multiple dynamical systems and neural controllers show that this approach yields computational savings over verifying independently.

Critical strengths
  • The paper extends conventional fixed-disturbance verification to a continuous range of disturbance magnitudes, which provides certified upper and lower bounds on the Lyapunov threshold throughout that range. This would be a novel and useful formulation for neural Lyapunov verification.

  • The experiments include different dynamical systems and previously released neural controllers, with comparisons against independent verification and optimized CROWN baselines.

Critical weaknesses
  • The proposed parametric bound records and shared-partition algorithm build on established techniques in incremental verification and proof reuse. While the continuous threshold enclosure is an useful extension/formulation, the paper does not sufficiently establish what is technically novel compared with existing approaches.

  • The shared and independent CROWN approaches produce identical verification outcomes. Additional successful verification results are observed only with the weaker interval-bound backend. Furthermore, the primary benefit is reduced verification time across repeated specifications. Since neural Lyapunov verification is typically performed offline, the practical significance of these savings is not justified (e.g., verification runtime does not really matter), especially when CROWN (tighter bounds) does not certify additional specifications.

  • The experiments primarily consider low-dimensional systems and controllers from existing work (ICML 2024 and NeurIPS 2025). Recent verification work are missing from the evaluation, e.g., Clip-and-Verify (NeurIPS 2025), which also evaluates challenging Lyapunov stability properties on CartPole and Quadrotor benchmarks.

  • The proposed method relies on the verification residual being affine in the disturbance magnitude, e.g., W(omega)=omega W_1. This does not generally hold when parameters affect the system dynamics or when disturbance sets are not proportionally scaled.

Questions for authors
  • Q1: Can the approach be extended to nonlinear dependence on the disturbance magnitude? How would it extend to multiple disturbance magnitudes?

  • Q2: Is the assumption V(x) > x^\top Px essential to the verification framework, or only needed to translate certified Lyapunov levels into state-space bounds?

  • Q3: Can the shared partition be reused when the upper level c_max changes, or is a fixed c_max essential to the approach?

Reviewer_uzdaOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the robustness of neural Lyapunov certificates, verifying their validity over a range of disturbances. The key insight is that by formulating the disturbance as a scaled set, the residual bound can be represented as an affine function of the disturbance. This insight motivates the central contribution of this work, which is that statistics from disjoint branch-and-bound subtrees can be reused across problems, providing a bound on the behavior of the system. The authors evaluate the resulting algorithm on two-dimensional systems and show that their approach significantly reduces the number of bound calls during branch and bound.

Critical strengths
  • Addresses a real limitation. Verifiers typically discard information from the branch-and-bound tree, losing potentially useful statistics in the process. Finding a way to reuse that work across problems is a great idea.

  • Disturbance formulation. Writing the disturbance as a scaled set, so that the residual can be formulated as an affine function of the disturbance is a simple yet clever move.

Critical weaknesses
  • Paper is weakly motivated. The paper never motivates Lyapunov functions, what they are used for, or why a certified disturbance profile matters to a practitioner. The first line understates what a neural certificate is, since certificates such as barrier functions and contraction metrics are broader than “functions checked by a verifier.”

  • No clear problem statement or contributions. The problem is spread across several definitions rather than stated formally in one place. The contributions are given as a dense paragraph of numbers stripped of context.

  • Limited significance. While the disturbance formulation is clever, everything that follows from there is not. The theorems developed amount to bookkeeping, and the approach is hard to transfer to other, more interesting problem classes (like general disturbances or dynamic disturbances).

  • The paper is not self-contained. Most of the useful information in the paper is buried in 40+ pages of appendix material, and the paper is hard to parse without reading the dense appendix.

  • Weak experimental evaluation. The main results are on two-dimensional systems, on a class of problems known to be easy. Attempts to scale the idea beyond these simple benchmarks fail.

  • Unsatisfactory baselines. Most comparisons are against a small subset of prior work. There is no comparison to established gain-computation methods such as SOS or LP approaches, or to other state-of-the-art approaches.

  • The writing is quite unorthodox. The paper is written in a very unusual style, with dense clauses and language that is difficult to parse. While there are some useful ideas in the paper, the writing obscures them.

Questions for authors
  1. Why should a practitioner care about a certified disturbance profile rather than a verified region of attraction or a disturbance bound? Can you give a concrete use case where the full profile could be useful?

  2. Can you state the problem formally in one place, and list the contributions explicitly?

  3. How can the idea be extended beyond scaled disturbance sets? Does it apply to other certificate classes, such as barrier functions or contraction metrics?

  4. What prevents the method from scaling beyond four states?How would you address the scaling limitations?

  5. How does the method compare to established gain-computation methods, such as SOS or LP-based approaches? Why were α,β-CROWN, incremental verification methods and others not compared directly?

Reviewer_tmZMOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper considers the problem of parameterizing the verification of neural certificates such that profiles of disturbances can be computed more efficiently. The main idea is to re-use the branch-and-bound tree that the verification algorithm builds when it checks a single disturbance and level. Technically, this requires adaptively partitioning the state region.

Critical strengths

The idea is elegant and the paper contains an extensive experimental evaluation of it.

Verification of neural certificates is an important area of study.

Critical weaknesses

The experiments sections need better structure. What are the baselines exactly, and all algorithm variations? These are introduced in the running text or table captions, instead of up front. There are a lot of detailed results, but it remains unclear what the methods are that are compared, significantly reducing their value.

While the experimental results show speedups, they appear to be limited. Some reflection on the significance of the results would be appreciated.

Assumptions are only listed in the Appendix, instead of in the main text. Also I would have appreciated some discussion of the algorithmic choices (which leaf to split, for instance), to be included in the paper itself.

The conclusions section is rather low-level and reads more like a discussion of the experimental results. The reader is left wondering what the conclusions and future work of the paper are. The significance and potential impact of the work are unclear.

The readability of the paper can be significantly improved if very long sentences are broken up.

Questions for authors

What happens if the dissipation check returns “error”? What are the possible sources of errors?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.