- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a joint training-and-certification framework for learning-enabled control systems with unknown dynamics. The framework combines neural barrier function learning with reinforcement learning to synthesize control policies, followed by scenario-based statistical certification of multi-step safe invariant and reach-avoid sets. During training, a PID-Barrier mechanism adaptively adjusts the constraint multiplier based on empirical barrier violations to improve policy performance and safety. After training, the learned policy and barrier function are fixed, and a scalar scenario optimization problem is solved to establish set-level PAC guarantees. The authors claim an sample complexity, compared with the dependence of standard Monte Carlo bounds. Experiments on an inverted pendulum, a Van der Pol oscillator, and a 10-dimensional Hopfield system are presented to evaluate control performance, safety, and certification efficiency.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important research problem concerning safety and reach-avoid certification for learning-enabled systems with unknown dynamics, which is highly relevant to safe reinforcement learning and formal verification.
It presents a unified learning-and-certification framework that integrates policy learning, neural barrier functions, and statistical certification in a clear and well-organized manner. The separation of training and certification, together with the use of an independent certification dataset, is a reasonable design choice. Furthermore, the framework extends existing one-step PAC controlled invariance methods to multi-step invariance and reach-avoidance properties, broadening their applicability.
The experimental results are also promising, suggesting that PID-Barrier can improve the trade-off between control performance and safety, while potentially producing more certifiable policy-barrier pairs for reach-avoidance tasks.
Critical weaknesses
-The proposed framework mainly combines several established techniques, including neural barrier learning, PPO, PID-Lagrangian optimization, and scenario-based certification. While their integration may be practically useful, the manuscript does not sufficiently clarify the technical novelty of the individual components or explain why their combination constitutes a substantial methodological advance.
-Definition 1 introduces infinite-horizon safe invariance, whereas Definition 3 only considers a finite horizon. The distinction between finite-horizon PAC safety and classical invariant-set guarantees should be emphasized. Another concern is that the conditional guarantee can become vacuous when the certified set has a small measure. Since the authors acknowledge that computing this measure may be challenging, the manuscript should explain how meaningful, non-vacuous guarantees are established in practice.
-The paper emphasizes an sample complexity for scenario-based certification, compared with for Monte Carlo methods based on Hoeffding's inequality. However, these bounds may correspond to different statistical objectives. The dependence typically arises from estimating an unknown probability with additive accuracy, whereas one-sided violation-probability certification can also achieve dependence under appropriate conditions. Although the data-dependent nature of the certified sets makes the proposed scenario formulation different from certification of a fixed set, the comparison with Hoeffding-based Monte Carlo estimates alone does not fully establish a general sample-efficiency advantage. The authors should clarify whether the compared methods provide equivalent guarantees and consider stronger statistical certification baselines.
-Experimental evidence is insufficient to fully support the main claims. Although the experiments cover three benchmark systems, the evaluation remains relatively limited for a framework claiming improved scalability and certification efficiency. First, the certification results do not consistently demonstrate an advantage over existing barrier-learning methods. For example, in the inverted pendulum invariance task, MF-NBC and Lag-Barrier achieve larger certified volumes than the proposed method. This weakens the claim that PID-Barrier consistently improves certification quality. Second, the main certification comparison is concentrated on the inverted pendulum, while detailed results for the other systems are largely deferred to the appendix. More comprehensive certification results across all benchmarks would strengthen the evaluation.
Minor Comments:
i. The content in Lines 63–66 of the Introduction appears to overlap with the Abstract.
ii. The methodological novelty over Wu et al. (2026) remains unclear, particularly whether the main advancement is simply replacing convex optimization with neural learning and verification. The authors should clarify the technical contributions beyond this extension.
iii. The Notations paragraph in Line 114 would be more appropriately placed at the beginning of the Preliminaries section.
iv. In Remark 1, it is unclear why Monte Carlo techniques are suggested for probability estimation, as the proposed framework does not appear to adopt this approach.
v. The piecewise construction of the neural barrier function in Eq. (4) appears to be an important design choice, but its motivation and role in training are not sufficiently explained. The authors should elaborate on why this construction is necessary and how it benefits learning and certification, rather than focusing primarily on the relatively straightforward loss functions and dataset construction.
vi. In Line 349, “equation 11” should be changed to “equation (11)”.
vii. Figure 1 is too small and poorly scaled, making its contents difficult to read. The authors should adjust its size and proportions to improve readability.
viii. Could the authors provide the link to the anonymous repository mentioned in the Reproducibility Statement?
Overall, I believe this work has merit, and I would be inclined to raise my rating if the authors could more clearly articulate the technical novelty and provide more comprehensive experimental evaluations.
Questions for authors
-
What is the main theoretical novelty of the multi-step PAC certification compared with Wu et al. (2026)? Does extending one-step constraints to multi-step trajectories require fundamentally new scenario optimization arguments, or can the proposed guarantees be derived directly from existing results?
-
How does the proposed PID-Barrier update differ technically from combining existing neural barrier learning with PID-Lagrangian optimization? Can the authors provide additional ablations demonstrating the independent contributions of the P, I, and D components?
-
In Table 1, existing barrier-learning methods achieve larger certified volumes than PID-Barrier for the invariance task. What evidence supports the claim that PID-Barrier improves certification quality rather than primarily improving empirical control performance?
4 comments
Response 2
In contrast, applying an ordinary Clopper-Pearson bound to a candidate set selected using the same validation data does not automatically preserve its nominal confidence guarantee. Independent validation or an appropriate simultaneous inference procedure is needed to account for data-dependent selection. Our framework therefore provides an integrated approach to selection-aware PAC certification of a family of multi-step operating sets.
Finally, we emphasize that the primary contribution of our work is not a new statistical confidence bound, but a framework for PAC certification of multi-step safe invariant and reach-avoid sets for black-box systems under learned controllers. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to establish such guarantees within a learning-then-verification framework using trajectory-based scenario optimization. We will clarify these distinctions and include the Clopper-Pearson baseline in the revised manuscript to better demonstrate the statistical contributions of our framework.
Weakness 2: Finite-horizon versus infinite-horizon guarantees; non-vacuous probability bounds for small certified sets; rigorous computation of certified-set measures.
We thank the reviewer for this insightful question.
Definition 1 introduces classical safe invariant sets, which require trajectories starting in the set to remain there for all future time steps. Computing or certifying such sets is generally challenging and can be intractable, particularly for black-box systems with unknown dynamics. In contrast, Definition 3 establishes a finite-horizon PAC guarantee, bounding the proportion of initial states within the certified set from which trajectories remain in the set over the next steps. Thus, our guarantee concerns finite-horizon invariance and does not, by itself, imply classical infinite-horizon invariance. We will clarify this distinction in the revised manuscript and explicitly emphasize the finite-horizon nature of our certification.
Regarding the conditional probability lower bound, we acknowledge that can become non-positive when the certified set has a sufficiently small measure. Although the bound remains mathematically valid, it becomes uninformative in this case. In particular, it is positive whenever . Our framework provides several mechanisms to improve the usefulness of this guarantee. First, during policy and barrier learning, the volume regularization term encourages the neural barrier to produce larger candidate certified sets. Second, after training, our framework allows the certification threshold to be varied within its admissible range, yielding a family of certified sets with different sizes without retraining the learned networks. Third, increasing the certification sample size allows us to obtain a smaller violation parameter while maintaining the same confidence level, thereby improving the conditional probability lower bound. Furthermore, users can specify a desired minimum conditional satisfaction probability and require the certified sets to satisfy
\geq \epsilon,$$ or, equivalently, $$\mu_S(\widetilde S_\zeta) \geq \frac{\alpha}{1-\epsilon}.$$ This provides an explicit criterion for balancing the size of the certified region against the desired probability guarantee. This requirement can be incorporated into Definitions 3 and 4 by replacing the condition $\mu_S(\widetilde S_\zeta)>0$ with $$1-\frac{\alpha}{\mu_S(\widetilde S_\zeta)} \geq \epsilon.$$ Importantly, this modification does not require changing our scenario optimization procedure or its theoretical analysis, since Theorems 1 and 2 already establish the corresponding conditional probability bounds whenever the certified set has positive measure. It simply restricts attention to certified sets for which these bounds are sufficiently informative. Finally, as discussed in Remark 1, computing the exact measure of a neural-network-defined certified set can be challenging. Rigorous lower bounds on this measure can, in principle, be obtained using more advanced techniques, such as interval-arithmetic-based set analysis. However, developing or comparing such volume-computation methods is beyond the scope of this work. Our focus is on establishing PAC guarantees for multi-step safety and reach-avoid properties, rather than on the exact computation of certified-set measures.Response 3
Question 2: How does PID-Barrier differ from combining barrier learning with PID-Lagrangian optimization, and what do the P, I, and D ablations show?
We thank the reviewer for this insightful question. Our PID-Barrier method builds on the PID-Lagrangian principle but specializes its feedback mechanism to the joint learning of the control policy and neural barrier function. In this setting, the barrier condition provides the constraint signal guiding policy improvement. However, this signal is inherently non-stationary because both the policy and barrier networks evolve during training. Our motivation for introducing PID feedback is to adaptively regulate these evolving barrier violations and improve the quality and stability of the policy–barrier pairs subsequently used for certification.
Specifically, we apply PID feedback to the empirical barrier violation where is the PPO importance ratio. The multiplier is updated according to Here, the proportional term responds to the current barrier violation, the integral term accumulates persistent violations, and the derivative term responds to increases in the violation signal. The non-negative projection maintains the one-sided penalty associated with the barrier constraint. Thus, PID-Barrier uses the temporal evolution of the barrier violations to adapt the policy optimization pressure, rather than relying solely on the accumulated constraint violation in a conventional Lagrangian update.
To investigate the respective contributions of the PID components, Appendix I compares the P, PI, and PID-Barrier variants, together with the Lag-P baseline, in terms of return, control cost, and verification performance. The results show that the benefit of incorporating the integral and derivative feedback is particularly evident in the Van der Pol system. Its nonlinear dynamics induce substantial trajectory fluctuations, making policy updates more susceptible to short-term disturbances. PID-Barrier exhibits better return–cost behavior in this setting, with its adaptive multiplier helping the policy recover from short-term performance degradation. We further evaluate the resulting verification errors in both invariant and reach-avoid tasks, where PID-Barrier maintains stable results within the prescribed verification bounds.
These ablation results provide empirical evidence that the PID components can improve the adaptation of barrier-constraint feedback during joint policy–barrier learning, particularly in challenging nonlinear systems. We will clarify the methodological distinction from conventional PID-Lagrangian optimization and explain the ablation results more explicitly in the revised manuscript.
Response 4
Weakness 4 and Question 3: What evidence supports improved certification quality when existing barrier-learning methods obtain larger certified volumes?
We thank the reviewer for this insightful observation. We agree that certified-set volume is an important measure of certification performance. However, a larger certified set does not necessarily translate into better overall performance of the learned controller. Our training procedure seeks to balance task reward and barrier-condition satisfaction, while the volume regularization term encourages larger candidate certified sets. Accordingly, we evaluate the learned methods based on several complementary criteria, including task return, control cost, the validity of the resulting certificates, and the estimated measures of the certified sets. Our objective is to obtain controllers that achieve good task performance while admitting useful safety and reach-avoid certificates, rather than maximizing certified-set volume in isolation.
The inverted pendulum results illustrate this trade-off. For invariance, MF-NBC obtains a larger estimated certified-set measure than PID-Barrier (0.551 versus 0.461). However, PID-Barrier achieves substantially higher return (179.41 versus 100.47) and lower control cost (0.042 versus 0.250), while both methods yield valid certificates across all five seeds. Compared with Lag-Barrier, PID-Barrier achieves a slightly larger estimated certified-set measure (0.461 versus 0.458), together with higher return and lower cost. For reach-avoidance, although PID-Barrier produces a smaller estimated set measure than Lag-Barrier (0.405 versus 0.488), it achieves higher return (361.49 versus 348.37) and lower cost (0.040 versus 0.064), with valid certificates across all five seeds. In contrast, MF-NBC obtains a valid reach-avoid certificate in only one of the five seeds.
The Van der Pol results provide further evidence of the benefits of our approach. For invariance, PID-Barrier achieves a larger estimated certified-set measure than Lag-Barrier (0.624 versus 0.588), with valid certificates in all five seeds compared with four out of five for Lag-Barrier. It also achieves substantially higher return (189.79 versus 128.23) and lower control cost (0.024 versus 0.230). For reach-avoidance, PID-Barrier also obtains a substantially larger estimated certified-set measure (0.586 versus 0.365), with valid certificates in all five seeds for both methods. The corresponding certification slack is also more concentrated across random seeds. Although Lag-Barrier achieves slightly higher return and lower cost in this case, the results demonstrate a clear improvement in the size of the certified operating region while maintaining competitive control performance.
Overall, these results show that the advantage of PID-Barrier is not necessarily a larger certified set in every task, but a more favorable balance between control performance and certification outcomes. In particular, the Van der Pol results demonstrate that our learning procedure can improve both the certified-set measure and control performance, while the inverted pendulum results illustrate the trade-offs involved. We will make these distinctions more explicit and include the results across benchmarks in the revised main comparison.
Response 1
We thank the reviewer for these constructive comments. We will address all the minor comments in the revised manuscript, and add experiments on additional high-dimensional systems in the final version to better demonstrate the scalability of the proposed method.
Weaknesses 1 and 3, and Question 1. Technical contributions and sample efficiency.
We thank the reviewer for these important questions.
(1) Our contribution is a joint training-and-certification framework that establishes PAC multi-step safe invariant and reach-avoid sets for learned controllers in black-box systems. Within this framework, empirical barrier violations guide joint policy--barrier learning, and independent trajectory data are used to statistically certify the resulting learned controller. This connects policy learning with the construction of certified operating regions under unknown dynamics.
Relative to (Wu et al.(2026)), we extend the certification objective from the existence of a suitable input for one-step controlled invariance to the multi-step behavior of the actual learned controller, including safe target reaching. This requires relating trajectory-level barrier violations to the desired specifications. In particular, Theorems 1 and 2 establish how a calibrated slack determines the barrier level sets for which the corresponding finite-horizon property holds, up to a bounded measure of exceptional states. This construction also accommodates positive slack in the admissible range, allowing useful certificates even when the original barrier inequalities are imperfectly satisfied.
A further distinction lies in the underlying learning and certification paradigms. Wu et al. (2026) adopts a uniform-learning approach, whereas our work follows a learning-then-verification paradigm. Specifically, we first learn the policy and neural barrier and then use independent trajectory samples to statistically certify the multi-step safety and reach-avoid properties of the resulting learned controller. This separation allows us to establish PAC guarantees for the actual learned networks without requiring uniform guarantees over the entire function class. As a result, unlike Wu et al. (2026), our framework does not impose a convexity requirement on the learned functions used to characterize invariant and reach-avoid sets. It accommodates general, potentially nonconvex neural barrier functions, offering greater flexibility in representing the geometry of certified sets.
(2) Regarding sample efficiency, we agree that comparing our framework only with a simple Monte Carlo baseline does not sufficiently demonstrate its advantages relative to established statistical certification methods. We will therefore include an exact one-sided binomial certification baseline based on the Clopper–Pearson confidence bound.
For a fixed candidate set selected independently of the validation data, the exact one-sided Clopper-Pearson confidence bound provides a natural baseline. Suppose that k violations are observed among N independent validation trajectory. The corresponding upper confidence bound at confidence level 1−β is Beta−1(1−β;k+1,N−k). In the zero-failure regime k=0, this reduces to 1−β1/N. Consequently, certifying that the violation probability is at most α requires N≥−ln(1−α)ln(1/β)=O(1/α). for a fixed confidence level. Thus, we acknowledge that our O(1/α) sample-complexity dependence does not constitute an asymptotic improvement over exact binomial certification in the zero-failure regime. However, when violations are observed, the required sample size depends on their frequency and the desired accuracy. In the general nonzero-failure regime, where the violation probability must be estimated to an additive accuracy of order α, the usual concentration-based sample complexity is O(1/α2) for fixed confidence. The exact binomial bound can have different scaling in rare-event regimes, depending on the number of observed violations.
However, the comparison above concerns a fixed certification event and does not capture the main advantage of our framework, which lies in its treatment of data-dependent set selection. Specifically, our calibrated slack ξ∗ is obtained by solving a scenario optimization problem using the certification data. The scenario theorem then provides an out-of-sample probabilistic guarantee for this data-dependent solution, accounting for its dependence on the sampled trajectories. Under the assumptions of the scenario theorem, our resulting sample-complexity bound retains an O(1/α) dependence. Furthermore, Theorems 1 and 2 establish a deterministic connection between the calibrated slack and a family of barrier level sets. Consequently, a single certification procedure supports PAC guarantees for all admissible barrier thresholds, without requiring separate trajectory validation for each candidate set.