- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents COMPASS, a 3D-aware image editing method. In particular, it represents each object to be edited, together with its desired edited state, using a pair of oriented 3D bounding boxes to specify the pose transformation. To distinguish multiple objects, the method introduces an object-ID embedding for each object and adds it to the image tokens associated with the corresponding object. To train the editing model, the authors also construct a synthetic dataset of paired 3D edits, allowing the model to learn diverse 7-DoF pose transformations.
Critical strengths
The paper introduces oriented 3D bounding boxes as a control representation for image editing. This representation provides the model with explicit 3D-aware editing control.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty. Several of the paper’s claimed contributions—including oriented 3D bounding boxes, object-ID embeddings, and the synthetic dataset pipeline—closely resemble mechanisms that have already been implemented in prior works.
- To the best of my knowledge, the oriented 3D bounding box was previously introduced in SceneDesigner[1] (NeurIPS 2025). In particular, SceneDesigner proposed a more expressive representation called a CNOCS map, which can also be viewed as a color-coded 3D bounding-box representation. Unlike COMPASS, which assigns a single color to each box face, a CNOCS map assigns a distinct color to every pixel according to its normalized 3D coordinate. From this perspective, the 3D representation used by COMPASS appears to be a simplified or degenerate version of the CNOCS map. Besides, the CNOCS map is neither properly discussed nor experimentally compared in the paper, which may prevent readers from accurately assessing the originality of the proposed representation.
- Object-ID embeddings have also been widely used in subject-driven image generation methods to distinguish tokens associated with different objects.
- Similarly, synthetic dataset pipelines for 3D-aware image editing have already been widely adopted in prior works, including OBJect-3DIT[2] and Free-Form Scene Editor[3]. The paper does not clearly explain how the COMPASS data generation pipeline differs from or improves upon these existing pipelines.
- The experiments do not sufficiently demonstrate the effectiveness and generalizability of the method.
- Most of the qualitative examples use synthetic images as source inputs, which is insufficient to establish generalization to real-world scenes. Although Figure 4 includes three real-world examples, their editing quality appears relatively poor, raising concerns about the practical performance of COMPASS on real images.
- The qualitative experiments also cover only a limited range of pose transformations. It is therefore unclear whether the method can handle more challenging inputs, larger rotations, or substantially more diverse 3D transformations.
[1] Qin, Zhenyuan, Xincheng Shuai, and Henghui Ding. "Scenedesigner: Controllable multi-object image generation with 9-dof pose manipulation."
[2] Michel, Oscar, et al. "Object 3dit: Language-guided 3d-aware image editing."
[3] Shuai, Xincheng, et al. "Free-form scene editor: Enabling multi-round object manipulation like in a 3d engine."
Questions for authors
- Novelty relative to prior 3D control representations and data pipelines.
- Please clarify the main differences between the proposed oriented 3D bounding-box representation and previous representations, particularly the CNOCS map introduced in SceneDesigner[1].
- Please also clarify how the proposed dataset pipeline differs from existing synthetic 3D-editing pipelines, such as those used in OBJect-3DIT[2] and Free-Form Scene Editor[3]. A clear comparison is necessary to establish the originality and novelty of the paper.
-
Role of the role embedding. What is the specific purpose of the role embedding? The source- and target- oriented 3D bounding boxes are already injected into the network at different positions, which appears to distinguish their roles. Moreover, the current ablation studies do not provide evidence that the role embedding independently improves performance. Please provide a separate ablation of the role embedding.
-
More experiments.
- Please compare CNOCS maps and the proposed oriented 3D bounding-box representation under the same backbone, training data, and evaluation protocol. Such an experiment would help establish whether the proposed representation offers an empirical advantage over the more fine-grained CNOCS representation.
- Please include substantially more real-world examples for both single-object and multi-object editing. These experiments should demonstrate the specific advantages of COMPASS over prior methods in realistic settings.
- Please evaluate the method on more challenging and diverse transformations, including full 360-degree rotations around different axes. This would clarify whether COMPASS supports broad pose diversity or is primarily effective within the relatively restricted transformation distribution used during training.
[1] Qin, Zhenyuan, Xincheng Shuai, and Henghui Ding. "Scenedesigner: Controllable multi-object image generation with 9-dof pose manipulation."
[2] Michel, Oscar, et al. "Object 3dit: Language-guided 3d-aware image editing."
[3] Shuai, Xincheng, et al. "Free-form scene editor: Enabling multi-round object manipulation like in a 3d engine."