- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses a key pain point in instruction‑guided image editing: existing methods often keep visual intervention boundaries implicit, leading to incomplete edits or undesired modifications to unchanged regions. The authors propose Minimal Sufficient Visual Intervention (MSVI), a three‑stage pipeline: (1) an VLM planner outputs a Structured Edit Specification (SES) with planning, perceiving, action and layout fields; (2) a regime‑adaptive compiler produces explicit visual intervention conditions Z, conditionally invoking SAM3 for spatial grounding; (3) a flow‑matching MMDiT editor generates edited images conditioned on Z. The authors build MSVI‑13K dataset with structured edit annotations. Extensive experiments on MSVI‑13K, Reason‑Edit and PIE‑Bench demonstrate competitive performance against strong baselines. Ablation studies validate each key component.
Critical strengths
S1: This work formalizes instruction‑based image editing problem as learning minimal sufficient visual intervention(MSVI). The proposed explicit paradigm, to some extent, mitigates two common problems: incomplete editing and unintended content corruption. S2: The SES structured representation, regime‑adaptive compilation with SAM3 grounding, and source‑copy suppression loss form a credible and coherent system. The MSVI‑13K dataset provides structured edit‑specification annotations, which can benefit follow‑up research for reasoning‑driven image editing. S3: Quantitative comparisons, qualitative visualization, cross‑benchmark generalization test and thorough ablation are solid. The paper also analyzes some representative failure cases and discusses limitations.
Critical weaknesses
W1: Planner and flow‑based editor are trained separately(not end-to-end). Inference errors from SES prediction and SAM3 will propagate to final output, as acknowledged by authors. There is no closed‑loop feedback mechanism to correct wrong intermediate outputs. W2: The pipeline introduces MLLM planner, SAM3 segmenter, VAE and MMDiT flow executor into the solution. It requires multiple external models and multi‑step inference, raising deployment overhead compared to end‑to‑end single‑model competitors. W3: The paper only evaluates open‑source academic baselines, without comparing against successful closed‑source commercial systems such as Seedream, GPT‑Image‑2.0 and Gemini. It remains unclear how the proposed MSVI stacks up against state‑of‑the‑art commercial editors under the same evaluation protocols.
Questions for authors
Q1: When SES prediction makes wrong regime prediction (e.g. predicting FOCAL for a HOLISTIC sample), how severe is the downstream generation degradation? Have you quantified this effect? Q2: Could you elaborate why source‑copy suppression loss (SCSL) brings such huge gain for edit sufficiency? Is there alternative simpler loss design to achieve similar effect? Q3: For real‑world deployment, do you have thoughts to simplify the multi‑component pipeline, e.g. distill the whole MSVI logic into a single end‑to‑end generative model?
5 comments
Reply to Reviewer 6hDk (part 2)
3. [Q3, W2]: What is MSVI’s end-to-end inference cost, and could the pipeline be distilled into a single model?
A: We appreciate the reviewer’s practical concern regarding deployment overhead and the suggestion to further simplify the pipeline. Component count alone does not necessarily determine deployment efficiency. We therefore evaluated the complete MSVI pipeline against BAGEL and Qwen-Image-Edit-2509, measuring end-to-end latency on an NVIDIA RTX PRO 6000 GPU at an image resolution of 512 × 512 pixels and a batch size of 4 for all methods. For MSVI, the reported latency covers the complete pipeline, including planning, intervention compilation, conditional grounding, and the 40-step flow-generation process.
| Method | Inference setting | Mean latency (s/image) ↓ |
|---|---|---|
| BAGEL | 50 steps; thinking off | 32.2 |
| Qwen-Image-Edit-2509 | 40 inference steps | 27.2 |
| MSVI (ours) | 40 flow steps | 12.3 |
Table C-2. End-to-end inference latency of MSVI and recent unified image-editing models. All methods are evaluated under the same hardware, image resolution, and batch size. Each value reports the mean latency over the complete inference pipeline.
As shown in Table C-2, MSVI achieves substantially lower end-to-end latency than BAGEL (12.3 vs. 32.2 s/image) and Qwen-Image-Edit-2509 (12.3 vs. 27.2 s/image), despite explicitly introducing planning and grounding stages. This indicates that the modular structure of MSVI does not necessarily translate into higher practical inference overhead.
We also appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion of distilling MSVI into a unified model. Combining pretrained language and generative models is an established approach for bridging multimodal reasoning and visual generation, as explored in LLMGA and WeGen. A natural future direction is to distill the MSVI pipeline into a single generative model, using SES and the compiled spatial supports as intermediate supervision in addition to the final editing targets. Such a student could internalize planning and grounding while reducing separate model calls at inference, further simplifying deployment without discarding the explicit intervention supervision introduced by MSVI.
4. [Q2]: Why does SCSL improve edit sufficiency, and could a simpler loss achieve a similar effect?
A: We thank the reviewer for this insightful question and the suggestion to explore simpler loss designs. For localized edits, the requested changes may occupy only a small portion of the image. With a finite training budget, a global objective can underemphasize these changes, resulting in conservative, source-like outputs that under-execute the instruction. SCSL counteracts this tendency by applying area-normalized target matching within the intervention support, while retaining full-image flow supervision. This increases the training emphasis on completing the requested transition. Table 3(c) of the main paper is consistent with this explanation: removing SCSL yields stronger source preservation but reduces ER-IF from 1.630 to 0.503. Regarding simpler alternatives, under our flow parameterization, SCSL is equivalent to a support-normalized velocity-matching term with a time weight (Eqs. (7) and (9)). A natural simplification is to use a time-independent weight on the regional flow-matching term. We appreciate this suggestion and will explore whether such alternatives can achieve a comparable balance between edit sufficiency and preservation in future work.
Reply to Reviewer 6hDk (part 3)
5. [W3]: How does MSVI compare with Seedream, GPT-Image-2, and Gemini under the same evaluation protocol?
A: We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion to include commercial image editors. We therefore extended the evaluation to Seedream 5.0 Lite, GPT-Image-2, and Gemini (Nano Banana 2), using the same source images, editing instructions, and quality-evaluation protocol.
The comparison reports both editing quality and observed end-to-end response latency. For commercial APIs, timing covers request submission through retrieval of the edited image and therefore includes communication and service overhead. We interpret these measurements as user-facing response times rather than hardware-matched estimates of model computation. Model versions, generation settings, and evaluation dates were kept fixed throughout the evaluation.
| Method | Deployment | Mean response latency (s/image) ↓ | Instruction success rate (%) ↑ | ER-IF ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-Image-2 | API | 45.0 | 92% | 1.799 |
| Gemini (Nano Banana 2) | API | 138.9 | 76% | 1.522 |
| Seedream 5.0 Lite | API | 33.6 | 77% | 1.544 |
| MSVI (ours) | Local | 12.3 | 84% | 1.630 |
Table C-3. Comparison with closed-source commercial image editors in terms of user-facing response latency and instruction-following performance.
As shown in Table C-3, MSVI achieves the lowest response latency (12.3 s/image) while outperforming Gemini and Seedream 5.0 Lite in both instruction success rate and ER-IF. Although GPT-Image-2 achieves the strongest editing accuracy, MSVI provides a competitive instruction-following performance with substantially lower end-to-end latency, demonstrating a favorable quality–efficiency trade-off.
If the reviewer has any further questions, we would be happy to discuss them.
Reply to Reviewer 6hDk (part 1)
We thank the reviewer for recognizing how structured edit specifications, regime-adaptive grounding, and source-copy suppression work together, and for noting the value of the cross-benchmark evaluation. We also appreciate the reviewer pointing out the risk of error propagation, the deployment overhead, and the lack of commercial baselines. We explain why the planner and editor are trained separately, report editing scores for correct and incorrect regime predictions, and compare inference latency and editing quality with other editors.
1. [W1]: Why are the planner and editor trained separately, and how can errors propagate without closed-loop feedback?
A: We agree that the reliability of intermediate predictions and the computational cost of the complete system are important for assessing practical image editing. MSVI provides fully automated inference from a source image and instruction to the edited output, while deliberately adopting stage-wise optimization (main paper Section 3.4). We first train the planner with direct SES supervision, and then train the executor using conditions compiled from annotated SES, with the planner and VAE frozen. This gives the executor a fixed supervised conditioning interface and prevents executor optimization from altering the learned specification predictor. Decoupled optimization of multimodal language and diffusion components also has precedent in LLMGA (Xia et al., 2024) and WeGen (Huang et al., 2025), although their specific training schedules differ. Our design is intended to reduce optimization coupling; it does not guarantee error-free SES prediction.
[1] Xia, Bin, et al. "Llmga: Multimodal large language model based generation assistant." European Conference on Computer Vision. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2024.
[2] Huang, Zhipeng, et al. "Wegen: A unified model for interactive multimodal generation as we chat." 2025 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2025.
2. [Q1, W1]: How much does editing performance degrade when the planner predicts the wrong regime?
A: To further investigate the effect of regime prediction errors, we divided the test samples into two subsets according to whether their predicted editing regimes matched the ground-truth labels. The corresponding downstream editing performance is reported in Table C-1.
As shown in Table C-1, incorrect regime predictions are associated with substantial performance degradation, reducing ER-IF from 1.807 to 1.301 and InvPres from 0.879 to 0.374. This highlights the importance of accurate regime selection for both instruction fulfillment and content preservation. Nevertheless, with 83.4% of predictions correctly classified, the planner achieves strong performance on the majority of test cases. These findings provide a more comprehensive assessment of the impact of planning errors on downstream editing.