- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes KriDrag, a DBIE framework using spatially correlated displacement fields. It identifies the problem of conflicting movements in multi-point dragging and introduces Gaussian covariance to model the spatial influence of each drag point. It combines covariance-based weights with inverse-distance weighting to construct a smooth displacement field for latent warping. Experiments on DragBench and ReD-Bench, including the constructed multi-drag settings, demonstrate improved editing quality and efficiency.
Critical strengths
-
The paper has a clear motivation and is also well written. The method is easy to follow, and the experiments are comprehensive, including ablations, and analyses of different covariance kernels.
-
The use of Gaussian covariance to model the spatial influence of each drag point is reasonable. Combining it with inverse-distance weighting helps produce smoother displacement fields and reduce interference between multiple drags. Experiments prove its effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
The proposed method mainly introduces Gaussian-based spatial weighting into the displacement field, while reusing inverse-distance weighting and the existing latent warping pipeline. The technical contribution seems incremental, and the use of Gaussian Process modeling does not introduce a fundamentally different approach.
Questions for authors
-
How does KriDrag perform in extreme cases, such as when two nearby drag points have large displacements in opposite directions?
-
Why does the method model each drag point independently using a Gaussian Process, rather than jointly modeling the spatial relationships between multiple drag points?
2 comments
Rebuttal by Authors [2/2]
[Q2] Why model each drag point independently rather than jointly via a GP?
[Q2-1] Independent response construction with coupled composition
While each handle’s spatial response is evaluated independently, multi-handle spatial relationships are coupled when composing the final displacement field:
- Eq. (2) (Line 178) & Appendix B.2 (Eqs. S3–S5, Lines 850–859) show that independent evaluation yields and , so "the spatial influence decreases monotonically with the distance from the corresponding handle point" (Lines 858–859).
- Eqs. (3)–(4) (Lines 191, 205) couple all handles via normalized IDW weights , which allows nearby compatible drags to contribute jointly to the same region and bounds the composed field magnitude by .
- Lines 951–955 (Appendix C.4) describe the joint control: "Unlike our approach, which evaluates each handle's field independently, the joint variant solves for all Gaussian fields simultaneously to enforce a response of roughly 1 at each target handle and 0 at all others. All other configurations—including IDW composition, length scale (), inputs, and generation settings—remain identical." Enforcing zero response at other handles can suppress useful overlap between nearby handles.
[Q2-2] Paired experimental verification (Appendix C.4, Table S5, Lines 1088–1097)
Across all 97 DragBench and 91 ReD-Bench multi-handle cases (Table S5):
| Dataset (Table S5, Lines 1088–1097) | Method | MD ↓ | IF ↑ | DAI1 ↓ | DAI10 ↓ | DAI20 ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DragBench (97) | Ours (Independent) | 24.68 | 0.8940 | 0.1580 | 0.1438 | 0.1339 |
| DragBench (97) | Joint GP + IDW | 31.55 | 0.8978 | 0.2064 | 0.1760 | 0.1540 |
| ReD-Bench (91) | Ours (Independent) | 24.86 | 0.8602 | 0.1970 | 0.1660 | 0.1621 |
| ReD-Bench (91) | Joint GP + IDW | 35.33 | 0.8767 | 0.2365 | 0.2018 | 0.2079 |
As stated in Lines 955–957, "independent responses consistently achieve better editing accuracy (lower MD and DAI) on both benchmarks, whereas the joint variant yields only a bit higher image fidelity (IF)." Table S5 supports our design under this one-hot conditioned control and shared IDW composition, without ruling out other joint GP formulations.
Rebuttal by Authors [1/2]
We thank you for recognizing the clear motivation, smooth displacement modeling, and comprehensive evaluation of our work. Below we address your comments with exact references to the revised manuscript and Appendix.
[W1] Technical contribution
[W1-1] Controllable per-handle spatial response
We agree that Gaussian kernels, inverse-distance weighting (IDW), and the latent relocation pipeline build upon established work. Our specific contribution is constructing a controllable per-handle spatial response within this pipeline, as stated in the manuscript:
[W1-2] Controlled empirical evidence
Three controlled comparisons substantiate this spatial profile beyond uniform motion dampening:
[Q1] Performance in extreme cases (nearby handles with large opposing displacements)
[Q1-1] Direct answer on close-range opposing pulls and failure boundaries (Appendix C.7, Figure S5)
When two nearby handles request large opposing displacements, their local Gaussian responses overlap and partially cancel out, so KriDrag can under-edit. This boundary—along with texture stretching and rigid-object rotation—is explicitly analyzed in Appendix C.7:
[Q1-2] Evaluation across directional regimes when handles are separated (Section 4.4, Table 7 & Figure 7)
When handles have sufficient spatial separation, spatial attenuation effectively mitigates cross-drag interference across differing directions (Section 4.4, Lines 474–485 & Table 7, Lines 486–498):