- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces MUNDO, a generative framework for temporal downscaling under two linear observation operators: subsampling (temporal interpolation) and block averaging (temporal disaggregation). The framework combines energy-score-based conditional generation with a null-space parameterization to enforce strict observation consistency. Its recursive variant factorizes temporal coarsening across successive resolution levels and learns the corresponding reverse conditional distributions. Empirical evaluations span the two-scale Lorenz-96 model, four simulated physical systems, and multivariate ERA5 reanalysis data. While the paper tackles a practically important problem—particularly regarding single-step generation and sampling efficiency compared to flow-based baselines—the current manuscript does not sufficiently differentiate its contributions from closely related work on hard-constrained generation and multiresolution distributional learning. Furthermore, several experimental comparisons confound the effects of recursion with variations in model capacity, training budget, conditioning information, and evaluation protocols. Consequently, these confounding factors limit the conclusions that can be drawn regarding both the framework's methodological novelty and the true benefits of its recursive formulation.
Critical strengths
-
Unified operator-consistent formulation with strong single-step efficiency: Formulating temporal interpolation and disaggregation under a common linear observation model () clearly highlights the variance deficit of deterministic regression and motivates conditional trajectory sampling. By combining energy-score distributional regression with an explicit range–null space decomposition, , MUNDO guarantees exact observation consistency () without iterative likelihood-gradient updates. This is consequential to my assessment because single-step MUNDO () already delivers strong accuracy and substantial sampling speedups relative to the evaluated iterative flow-matching baselines.
-
Systematic evaluation across dynamical regimes and informative component ablations: The empirical study spans a well-chosen hierarchy of dynamical systems—from two-scale Lorenz-96 with controllable chaoticity to four 2D PDEs across varying decorrelation horizons () and multivariate ERA5 reanalysis. Furthermore, the appendices transparently investigate critical design choices—including projection placement during training vs. sampling, spatial-coherence regularizers, cross-window conditioning, and end-to-end fine-tuning—while candidly acknowledging regimes where the recursive hierarchy underperforms direct single-step generation.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient positioning and differentiation against closely related literature: The manuscript does not adequately situate its architectural and methodological contributions relative to established work on hard-constrained downscaling, proper-scoring generative models, and atmospheric inverse problems:
- Prior hard-constrained and single-pass temporal downscalers: The introduction claims that no existing method guarantees exact observation consistency without an iterative solve. However, RainDisaggGAN [1] already achieves single-pass stochastic temporal disaggregation of precipitation with exact aggregate preservation via a temporal softmax-and-scaling layer. More broadly, Harder et al. [2] formulated additive hard-constraint layers whose algebraic form is identical to the block-average residual projection used in MUNDO. Meanwhile, HourGlass [5] (cited only briefly) already performs single-pass probabilistic temporal downscaling trained with fair CRPS and auxiliary penalties.
- Overlap with multiresolution proper-scoring frameworks: While the paper cites engression and Reverse Markov Learning [4], it omits EnScale / EnScale-t [3], which already integrates energy-score training, progressive multiresolution refinement, and autoregressive conditioning on preceding states at each resolution level. Consequently, the boundary between inherited components [2, 3, 4, 5] and genuinely new algorithmic contributions in MUNDO remains unclear, and the paper lacks discussion of how its task-specific training trades off against flexible zero-shot atmospheric inverse solvers such as WIND [6].
-
Framework design tensions, confounded experimental protocols, and paradoxical recursive results: Several inconsistencies in framework design and experimental control undermine the paper's core claims regarding the benefits of the recursive multiresolution construction ():
- Design tensions in projection placement, error accumulation, and non-linear constraints: First, single-step MUNDO trains on unprojected outputs and only projects at inference, because applying the null-space projection inside the training loss consistently degrades CRPS (Appendix A.3, Table 6), whereas recursive MUNDO trains on projected outputs. The paper does not explain why end-to-end null-space projection hurts optimization in . Second, rather than simplifying learning, level-wise factorized training suffers from severe exposure bias and high-frequency artifacts (e.g., Table 5 and Table 8 at ), requiring expensive end-to-end joint backpropagation through all networks with a different loss (spectral CRPS) to remain competitive. Third, linear affine projection onto ignores domain positivity and non-linear state coupling: for non-negative variables like ERA5 precipitation or coupled fields like density and in Gross-Pitaevskii, subtracting a block mean in can induce negative values or physical inconsistencies that cannot be naively clipped without violating .
- Unexplained degradation of recursion and confounded experimental controls: Empirically, single-step MUNDO () consistently beats recursive MUNDO () in CRPS across nearly all interpolation settings and most AutoSim disaggregation regimes. Where recursive MUNDO does show gains, the experimental design conflates recursion with: (i) 4x model capacity and 3.7x training compute on ERA5 ( vs. , Table 11); (ii) asymmetric conditioning and objectives, where only receives generated predecessor states () and Stage-2 spectral-CRPS fine-tuning, and where baseline access to neighboring coarse observations () is not clearly equalized; (iii) mismatched evaluation targets on Lorenz-96 (Appendix B.1), where causal-chain recursive disaggregation is scored on / contiguous chain windows () while and baselines are scored on separated windows (); and (iv) missing single-pass baselines (e.g., an HourGlass-style model or hard-constrained cGAN) using the exact same backbone and final projection .
References:
[1] Scher, S., & Peßenteiner, S. (2021). Technical Note: Temporal disaggregation of spatial rainfall fields with generative adversarial networks. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 25(6), 3207–3225.
[2] Harder, P., et al. (2023). Hard-constrained deep learning for climate downscaling. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 24(365), 1–40.
[3] Schillinger, M., Samarin, M., Shen, X., Knutti, R., & Meinshausen, N. (2026). EnScale: Temporally-consistent multivariate generative downscaling via proper scoring rules. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems, 18(8)
[4] Shen, X., Meinshausen, N., & Zhang, T. (2025). Reverse Markov learning: Multi-step generative models for complex distributions. arXiv
[5] Ingstad, M. S., et al. (2026). HourGlass: A probabilistic data-driven temporal downscaler for global and regional weather forecasting. arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.11457.
[6] Aich, M., Fürst, A., Sestak, F., Ruiz-Gonzalez, C., Boers, N., & Brandstetter, J. (2026). WIND: Weather inverse diffusion for zero-shot atmospheric modeling. In Proceedings of the 43rd International Conference on Machine Learning.
Questions for authors
- Beyond combining established additive/null-space constraints with reverse Markov energy-score learning , what is the core methodological innovation of MUNDO?
- Why does recursive MUNDO () underperform single-step MUNDO () in CRPS across most interpolation and AutoSim settings, and why does projecting inside the training loss degrade (Table 6) while being used for ?
- Do the recursive gains on ERA5 and AutoSim persist when total parameter count, training budget, spectral-CRPS fine-tuning, and generated predecessor context are strictly matched with ?
- Were all baselines given the exact same neighboring coarse observations () and static/calendar inputs as MUNDO, and can the Lorenz-96 disaggregation methods be evaluated on identical test windows and ensemble sizes (with post-projection applied to baselines)?
3 comments
We address here the remaining points: recursive gains and experimental controls (Q3), baseline inputs and evaluation protocol (Q4), and positivity.
Recursive gains and experimental controls (Q3). Single-step MUNDO often achieves lower CRPS than recursive MUNDO on interpolation and AutoSim disaggregation. The hierarchy mainly improves calibration and temporal structure, which CRPS alone does not measure. Its gain is largest on ERA5, the benchmark with the most coupled variables (seven fields; Table 3).
- Capacity. On Lorenz-96 and AutoSim, both MUNDO variants and both flow-based baselines share the same backbone and are matched in parameter count (Appendix C.4, Table 13).
- On ERA5, the recursive model has about 4$\times$ more parameters (230M across four levels). Matching it with a single network would require 46-61 GiB peak VRAM at batch size 2 on an 80-GB H100, and exceed memory at batch size 4, the batch size of all our ERA5 runs. We therefore did not run these variants, and the ERA5 comparison does not isolate recursion at matched capacity.
- The hierarchy does offer a memory advantage. Each level generates only the degrees of freedom between two successive resolutions and is trained independently, so only one network has to fit in memory at a time. Total capacity can thus grow at a fixed memory budget, at the cost of evaluations per sample.
- At matched capacity (57.4M parameters), single-step MUNDO already outperforms the flow-based baselines on ERA5. Its CRPS is 21% lower than FlowDPS under disaggregation and 33% lower than flow matching under interpolation (Table 3).
- Fine-tuning, loss and predecessor context. End-to-end fine-tuning is optional and used only when validation diagnostics indicate error propagation across levels (Section 3.5).
- The ERA5 recursive model uses neither this fine-tuning nor generated predecessor context (Table 13), so neither explains its ERA5 gains.
- On AutoSim, replacing true with generated predecessor context changes CRPS by about 2% or less, except for advection-diffusion at (Table 10).
- The method does not require a specific loss either. On Gross-Pitaevskii disaggregation at , CRPS stays within 1.4% across the three loss configurations (0.0788 to 0.0799; Table 6).
- Single-pass constrained control. Single-step MUNDO provides this control. It uses the same backbone and final projection, and differs from a HourGlass-style model in its training objective and in imposing consistency exactly. We did not run a hard-constrained cGAN: the softmax constraint of RainDisaggGAN applies only to the aggregate of a non-negative variable, so it covers neither interpolation nor signed fields such as the wind components.
Baseline inputs and evaluation protocol (Q4). The reviewer asks whether the baselines receive the same inputs as MUNDO, and whether the Lorenz-96 methods can be evaluated on identical windows with projected baselines. Yes on both counts (Section 4.1, Appendix C.3):
- All learned generative methods receive the hour, day of year, and four static fields. SimVP, following its original design, receives only the observation-derived input video.
- For disaggregation, MUNDO and both flow-based baselines also receive the aggregates of adjacent windows.
- On AutoSim and ERA5, learned baselines were already projected onto the constraint set after sampling. We now apply the same projection on Lorenz-96.
- On Lorenz-96, all methods are now evaluated on the same 25 chains (Appendix C.1).
Positivity. The reviewer is right that linear aggregate constraints do not guarantee non-negativity, and this affects all methods. The share of negative precipitation pixel-hours is 17% for Denton-Cholette, 20% for flow matching, 24% for single-step MUNDO, and 28% for recursive MUNDO.
We address this by projecting precipitation onto the intersection of the aggregate constraint and the non-negative orthant, (Appendix B.3). This projection has a closed-form blockwise solution up to a scalar threshold found by bisection, with negligible sampling cost. Applied to all methods, it removes negative values while preserving exact daily means. For MUNDO, it also improves precipitation scores under disaggregation: CRPS drops by 5% for the recursive model and 4% for the single-step model, and the finest spectral band ratio and of the recursive model move close to one. Its spread-skill ratio decreases, since part of the spread came from negative values.
All ERA5 precipitation results in the revision use this projection, and Table 16 (Appendix D.3.1) compares every method before and after. Alternatively, a parameterization could enforce positivity directly and is left for future work. For coupled fields such as density and in Gross-Pitaevskii, we claim consistency with the observation operator, not preservation of physical invariants.
Thank you for the thorough response. I will reconsider my score.
We thank the reviewer for the thorough review. We address novelty and positioning (Q1), projection (Q2), recursive gains and experimental controls (Q3), baseline inputs and evaluation protocol (Q4), and positivity. Due to the character limit, our response is split across two comments.
Novelty and positioning (Q1). MUNDO builds on engression and reverse Markov learning, and extends them to temporal downscaling through four contributions: (i) a null-space parameterization under a general linear observation operator (Eq. 9), which gives exact consistency with the observation in one network evaluation per draw, for interpolation and disaggregation alike (Eq. 4); (ii) a multiresolution factorization of that operator (Eq. 10) in which each level is exactly consistent with its parent, so that consistency propagates along the chain; (iii) end-to-end fine-tuning of the levels on their own generated inputs; and (iv) a spatial-coherence term complementing the energy score. The revised introduction lists them. What we propose is this framework as a whole, kept unchanged across three backbones and six systems (Table 1).
Our novelty claim concerns methods that generate samples satisfying the observation exactly, under both temporal observation operators, without an iterative solve. The closest works are discussed in Section 2 and Appendix A.2, and compared in Table 5:
Projection (Q2). Recursive levels are parameterized in the null space by construction. Each network predicts only the free values at its level, and children are assembled to match their parent exactly (i.e., the network adds a residual that the coarsening maps to zero, e.g., residuals that sum to zero around the parent mean value under disaggregation). There is therefore no separate projection step, and projected samples are used directly in the training objective.
For single-step MUNDO, projecting during training or only at sampling yields the same population optimum under finite first moments and realizability (Appendix B.3). With finite-capacity networks, the objective does affect the learned distribution. On AutoSim disaggregation at N=32, projecting inside the training loss increases CRPS on all four systems, with mixed effects on calibration and little change in temporal structure (Table 7). We therefore project only at sampling time for single-step MUNDO.