- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SPyD, a multiresolution diffusion framework for kilometer-scale climate emulation. It decomposes atmospheric fields into orthogonal Laplacian wavelet bands on a spherical grid, with channel-dependent noise schedules and a shared diffusion clock. The framework supports both single-stage and multistage super-resolution. Experiments on ICON simulations show improvements over cBottle-SR in CRPS, precipitation extremes, and spatial structure, with additional ensemble calibration and full-pipeline evaluations.
Critical strengths
The use of a shared diffusion framework across resolution bands is an interesting approach to climate downscaling. The channel-dependent noise schedules are particularly relevant because atmospheric variables have very different spatial variability and distributions. The spherical wavelet construction also makes the approach suitable for global applications. The evaluation is reasonably comprehensive, covering 12 atmospheric variables, extreme precipitation, spectral properties, CRPS, and ensemble calibration. Single-stage SPyD improves CRPS over cBottle-SR across all 12 channels, with statistically significant improvements on eight. The precipitation extremes are particularly encouraging, with the 99.999th percentile reproduced within approximately 1.6% of the ICON reference. The matched computational-cost comparison further strengthens the results.
Critical weaknesses
Although the framework is motivated by consistent multiresolution generation, the multistage model performs worse than the single-stage model on several important metrics. In particular, the 99.999th precipitation percentile is underestimated by approximately 16%, and the full generative pipeline produces 20–22% spurious convective cells. The authors acknowledge this issue, which is appreciated, but it limits the practical advantage of the proposed multistage formulation. Exact composition of the resolution bands does not necessarily guarantee accurate generation across stages.
Questions for authors
-
The multistage model introduces substantial spurious precipitation under generated conditioning. Is this mainly caused by the mismatch between training and generated conditioning, or by errors accumulated across the resolution stages?
-
How sensitive are the results to the channel-dependent noise calibration? Have the authors compared against a common noise schedule across channels?
-
The single-stage model performs better than the multistage model in several cases. What would be the main practical motivation for choosing the multistage configuration, apart from supporting intermediate resolutions?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer oCx3 (Part 2/3)
Q1. Is the spurious precipitation caused by the training/generated conditioning mismatch, or by errors accumulated across stages?
The spurious precipitation comes from the mismatch between the conditions the fine stage is trained on and the generated inputs it receives, not from errors accumulating across stages. Under generated conditioning, the intermediate stage's output has a low spurious-cell rate (0.62%), and the fine stage alone raises it to 20–22% (Sec. 4.7). If errors were accumulating across stages, the rate would already be elevated after the intermediate stage. The increase appears only when the fine stage receives inputs unlike those it was trained on.
This is exactly the gap that SPyD's matched noisy conditioning is designed to close. To quantify the effect, we retrained the single-stage model without it, conditioning on clean coarse fields as a standard cascade does. Under generated coarse inputs, this variant loses 14–17% of the fine-scale power that SPyD retains (temperature 0.83× [0.81, 0.84], precipitation 0.86× [0.84, 0.88], 95% paired bootstrap). Matching the conditioning noise is therefore the lever that controls robustness to generated inputs. We also measured the spurious-cell rate directly for the revised multi-stage model, using the same 16 generated coarse samples for all models. Its fine stage no longer increases the rate (0.7× the rate of its intermediate output, against about 35× for the published model), and its final rate matches the single-stage model's (ratio 1.06 [0.99, 1.14], 95% paired bootstrap).
In both the published and the revised multi-stage models, the fine stage is trained on intermediate bands computed from ICON, with matched noise. A natural extension is to train it on outputs of the intermediate stage itself, so that its training and deployment inputs coincide; the shared diffusion clock makes this well-defined because it specifies the noise level at the handoff. This requires generating intermediate-stage samples for the full training set, and we leave it to future work.
Q2. How sensitive are the results to the channel-dependent noise calibration? Have the authors compared against a common schedule across channels?
We appreciate this question, and we ran exactly this comparison. In SPyD, each channel and band has its own noise rate, which sets how quickly noise overwhelms that band as diffusion time increases. The rates are calibrated from the measured band statistics of each channel (Sec. 3.3), so that channels with very different variability lose their signal at comparable points in the diffusion. A common schedule replaces these with one rate shared by all channels, as in image diffusion models. We retrained the single-stage model with one shared rate for all 12 channels, set to the largest calibrated value and keeping everything else identical. We then compared CRPS per channel on the held-out months. If calibration matters, the shared-rate model should be worse on the channels whose statistics differ most from the rest.
That is what we find. With a shared rate, CRPS is significantly worse for precipitation (+1.3% [0.6, 2.1]) and SST (+2.1% [1.2, 3.1]), the heavy-tailed and front-dominated channels, and under generated coarse inputs it also loses 9% of fine-scale temperature power. On smooth, large-scale channels such as pressure and winds, a shared rate performs comparably. The result does confirm your intuition that calibration matters most where atmospheric variables differ most in variability and distribution. It also removes the need to hand-tune a rate per channel. We will add this comparison to the paper.
Response to Reviewer oCx3 (Part 3/3)
Q3. What is the main practical motivation for the multi-stage configuration, apart from supporting intermediate resolutions?
Beyond intermediate resolutions, the multi-stage configuration has three practical motivations, at only 8–17% additional inference cost (Sec. 4.1). First, it matches how kilometer-scale data are produced and shared. Simulations are released as one store per HEALPix level [1], and coarse and intermediate levels are far more widely available than the finest one. A fine stage can therefore downscale existing intermediate-resolution products directly, which a model trained for one fixed resolution jump cannot use. Second, the intermediate stage trains and samples on 16× fewer pixels. Third, because the bands compose exactly, errors can be attributed to a single stage; this is how we located and fixed the multi-stage gap during this rebuttal. Exact composition also lets us test each stage in isolation. Given the true HPX256 band of the Figure-2 state as input, the fine stage alone reproduces the typhoon's central pressure within 1 hPa of ICON (912 vs. 911 hPa) and has 2.2–2.9× lower CRPS than every model conditioned on HPX64 alone. The fine stage is therefore already accurate, and further gains will come from the intermediate stage, which the multi-stage framework allows to be trained and improved independently of the fine stage. With the revised model, the multi-stage configuration is now also competitive in accuracy (Table A).
It is also well suited to characterizing extreme weather such as tropical cyclones. In response to Reviewer uFm2, we added storm-scale scores for the cases in Figure 2 and for every strong tropical cyclone (below 985 hPa) in the held-out states; we refer to that response for the protocol. On the Figure-2 typhoon (8-member ensembles), the revised multi-stage model has the central pressure closest to ICON of all models, closer than the single-stage model (917 hPa; ICON 911, single-stage 921, cBottle-SR 938) and keeps the eye clear (eye-to-eyewall rain ratio 0.13, against 0.60 for cBottle-SR). Across the 11 strong held-out cyclones, its radial rain profile is closer to ICON than cBottle-SR's in 10, a significant difference (median −0.75 [−3.30, −0.22] mm/hr). The fractions skill score of its precipitation pattern is the highest of all models in the tropical-cyclone, Maritime Continent and ITCZ regimes (e.g. ITCZ 0.66, against 0.58 for single-stage and 0.37 for cBottle-SR).
We hope our responses have addressed the reviewer's concerns. If any concern remains, please let us know, and we will be happy to respond. Otherwise, we would be grateful if the reviewer would consider whether the new results warrant a more positive assessment.
References
[1] Segura, Hans, et al. "nextGEMS: entering the era of kilometer-scale Earth system modeling." Geoscientific Model Development 18.20 (2025): 7735-7761.
[2] Ho, Jonathan, et al. "Cascaded diffusion models for high fidelity image generation." Journal of Machine Learning Research 23.47 (2022): 1-33.
Response to Reviewer oCx3 (Part 1/3)
We thank the reviewer for the positive and thoughtful evaluation, and for finding no substantive concerns about the soundness of the paper. We appreciate the recognition that a shared diffusion framework across resolution bands is "an interesting approach to climate downscaling", that the channel-dependent noise schedules are "particularly relevant because atmospheric variables have very different spatial variability and distributions", and that the spherical wavelet construction makes the approach "suitable for global applications". We are also encouraged that the reviewer finds the evaluation "reasonably comprehensive", the precipitation extremes "particularly encouraging", and that "the matched computational-cost comparison further strengthens the results". Below, we address the concern about the multi-stage model and answer the three questions.
W1a. The multi-stage model performs worse than the single-stage model on several important metrics.
The multi-stage design follows from how kilometer-scale climate data exist. Simulations are released as a hierarchy of resolutions, one store per HEALPix level [1], and many uses need the intermediate levels rather than only the finest one. The reviewer's concern prompted us to revisit the multi-stage model during the rebuttal, and the revised model is substantially better than the published one and now competitive with the single-stage model.
The published multi-stage model was trained with a much smaller budget than the single-stage model. Its fine stage was a short fine-tune of 17.5k steps, against 126k steps for the single-stage model (Appendix, "Hardware and training cost"). Because the bands compose exactly, we could also measure each stage's contribution separately. This showed that the precipitation gap entered at the intermediate stage, whose output carried only 0.69 of ICON's mesoscale precipitation power. The fine stage generates only scales finer than HPX256, so it cannot recover content missing from the band below. We therefore retrained the multi-stage model with the same training budget as the single-stage model. Its intermediate stage now generates natively at HPX256, and the handoff between stages uses the same wavelet projection as in training. Table A compares the published and revised multi-stage models on the paper's own metrics, with the published single-stage model for reference.
Table A. CRPS per channel (12 held-out months × 16 patches × 8 members; lower is better) and extreme precipitation percentiles (bias against ICON). Channel names as in Table 2; the published columns are copied from Tables 1 and 2 of the paper; bold marks the best of the three.
The revised model improves on the published multi-stage model where it was weakest. Precipitation CRPS drops by 22%, the cloud and radiation channels (cllvi, clivi, rlut, rsut, rsds) improve by 4–13%, and the deficit at the 99.999th precipitation percentile falls from −16% to −9.4%. Relative to the single-stage model, it has lower CRPS on 9 of 12 channels, with the largest gains on sst (−5.3%) and tas (−4.4%). It also has the lowest ensemble-mean RMSE among the generative models on 9 of 12 channels. The gap the reviewer identified was therefore a matter of how the published stages were trained, not a limit of the multi-resolution formulation.
W1b. Exact composition of the resolution bands does not necessarily guarantee accurate generation across stages.
Exact composition is a guarantee about the operators, and this is the scope of the claim in the paper. The coarse and generated bands sum exactly to the full field, without loss or overlap at the stage boundary, and the paper reports the measured operator residuals. How accurately each stage generates its band is a learning question, as in any cascade [2]. Exact composition is nevertheless what made the diagnosis above possible: because the bands are orthogonal and sum exactly, the deficit could be attributed to a single stage and fixed there. We will state this distinction explicitly in Section 3.5.