W1. The benefit of the multi-resolution design is not sufficiently supported
- No task requires fine resolution: The evaluation horizons (28, 30, 42, and 168 days) are mostly multiples of 7 or 28, and day tokens are used only for two days in the 30-day horizon. The contributions claim that "clinically salient intervals can be synthesized at high resolution," but no method is presented for selecting clinically important intervals to generate at high resolution, and all performance results are obtained with greedy allocation, which favors the coarsest resolution. Demonstrating the benefit of multiple resolutions would require evaluations such as short horizons (e.g., 1, 3, or 10 days), the accuracy of event timing, and the ordering of events.
- Key baselines are missing: The most direct comparison for the core claim of "a single generative model over nested resolutions" is MoRGEN (Oufattole et al., 2026), which combines per-resolution models. It is missing from the baselines even though it has already been published at ICML 2026. In addition, the paper claims to be "achieving competitive performance on clinical tasks while using significantly less compute resources," but it does not compare against models that predict probabilities directly without rollout, such as the time-to-event model MOTOR (Steinberg et al., 2024) or task-specific supervised baselines. Because these models predict with a single forward pass and no generation, they are the strongest competitors in terms of efficiency. Without them, the efficiency–performance trade-off cannot be judged in its full context.
W2. The reduced vocabulary limits the generality of the conclusions
According to Appendix B, the vocabulary was reduced to 74–430 codes by keeping only the evaluated outcomes, admissions and discharges, five labs, death and birth codes, and age and demographic information. This setting raises two concerns. First, real-world EHRs contain thousands of codes or more, with much higher event density. It is unclear whether bin-level sum pooling and independent per-code sigmoids still work in such settings. Second, because the vocabulary was chosen in advance to match the evaluated outcomes, the key advantage of generative models, namely that endpoints need not be specified in advance, is diluted.
W3. Calibration consistently degrades at long horizons
At the 6-month horizon, the macro ECE of MuRGEHR is substantially worse than that of the event-stream model and ETHOS on all three datasets.
| 6-month macro ECE (↓) | month | event stream | ETHOS | MuRGEHR (100) | MuRGEHR (equal time) |
|---|
| MIMIC (Table A.10) | .038 | .021 | .042 | .059 | .059 |
| EHRSHOT (Table A.11) | .099 | .045 | .047 | .098 | .099 |
| Hospital A (Table A.12) | .024 | .025 | .017 | .062 | .062 |
In contrast, at 28 days the ECE of MuRGEHR is lower than or comparable to that of the event-stream model and ETHOS. This problem is difficult to attribute to sampling noise or to a general limitation of grid-based approaches, for two reasons. First, the ECE barely changes even in the equal wall-clock setting, where the number of trajectories is increased to 643–1098 (MIMIC .059→.059, EHRSHOT .098→.099, Hospital A .062→.062). This indicates a systematic bias in the probabilities output by the model rather than sampling variance. Second, among the single-resolution grid models, the week and day models are also poorly calibrated at 6 months, but on MIMIC and Hospital A, MuRGEHR is worse even than the month model with the same architecture (.059 vs. .038 and .062 vs. .024).
Since risk estimation is the main intended use, calibration is as important as AUROC, yet the main text does not discuss these results. One might argue that post-hoc recalibration can fix this, but recalibration requires labeled data for each endpoint. This conflicts with the motivation in the Introduction of estimating risk through rollouts alone without specifying endpoints in advance. The authors should analyze why calibration degrades at long horizons, for example with reliability diagrams, and clarify whether the probabilities are overestimated or underestimated.
References
- Oufattole, N., McDermott, M., and Stultz, C. MoRGen: Mixture-of-Resolutions Generative Forecasting for Irregularly Sampled Medical Time-Series Data. In International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML), 2026.
- Renc, P., Jia, Y., Samir, A. E., Was, J., Li, Q., Bates, D. W., and Sitek, A. Zero shot health trajectory prediction using transformer. npj Digital Medicine, 7(1), 2024.
- Steinberg, E., Fries, J. A., Xu, Y., and Shah, N. MOTOR: A time-to-event foundation model for structured medical records. In International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR), 2024.