- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CLAP extends part-prototype classifiers to weakly supervised object localization by aligning their spatial responses with foreground–background pseudo-masks learned through a C2AM-style contrastive objective. Background-exclusion and foreground-coverage losses supervise the collective responses of ground-truth-class prototypes. A fixed sum of max-pooled prototype responses replaces the learned classifier, while normalized spatial responses produce localization maps. The auxiliary mask head is discarded at inference.
The framework is instantiated with ProtoPNet and ProtoPool using DeiT-S and DINOv2-S backbones. Experiments show substantial localization improvements over prototype baselines, generally comparable classification accuracy, and competitive WSOL results on CUB and ILSVRC. Loss ablations demonstrate complementary benefits from background exclusion and foreground coverage.
Critical strengths
-
Substantial and consistently demonstrated localization improvements. CLAP markedly improves localization over ProtoPNet and ProtoPool across the evaluated datasets. The controlled loss ablation shows that background suppression and foreground coverage provide complementary benefits. This supports the practical usefulness of the proposed alignment mechanism.
-
A compact integration of prototype classification and localization. Both outputs are computed from class-associated prototype responses, and the auxiliary supervision head is removed at inference. This provides explicit traceability to prototype activations while retaining competitive localization performance, making the framework a useful extension of interpretable prototype classifiers.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central claim of faithful spatial correspondence is insufficiently validated. Classification sums raw max-pooled responses, whereas localization takes a spatial maximum over individually normalized response maps. Consequently, non-maximal regions can affect localization without directly contributing to the class logit, and weakly contributing prototypes can become prominent after normalization. Shared responses establish computational traceability, but do not by themselves establish that the full localization map faithfully represents classification evidence. Figure 4 illustrates the architecture rather than resolving this concern. This matters because such correspondence is the paper’s principal advantage over specialized WSOL methods.
-
The experiments do not sufficiently isolate the distinctive contribution of the proposed design. The ablation establishes the value of the alignment losses, but does not separate their effects from those of removing the learned classifier or assess whether comparable benefits arise with a conventional class-response head. The pseudo-mask generator’s own localization quality is also unreported. These omissions make it difficult to determine how much benefit comes specifically from prototype-based integration. Unclear ILSVRC threshold calibration further limits confidence in the comparisons.
Questions for authors
The following are clarification requests that could affect my assessment:
-
What data and procedure are used to select localization thresholds on ILSVRC and in Table 1? Please clarify whether evaluation images or their bounding boxes influence threshold selection, and whether compared methods use the same box-extraction procedure.
-
Is the claimed classification–localization correspondence intended to mean prototype-level computational traceability, or faithfulness of the entire spatial localization map? How does the latter interpretation account for non-maximal responses and the removal of response magnitude through per-prototype normalization?
-
Do you have controlled results for retaining the learned classifier while applying the alignment losses, and for directly localizing with the learned foreground pseudo-masks? These comparisons would materially affect my assessment of the necessity and added value of the proposed integration.