acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

ControlGS: Factorized Control for Continual 3D Gaussian Splatting

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Continual 3D Gaussian splatting reconstruction updates a model from new images while preserving unchanged content and earlier states.Existing methods apply a uniform end-to-end procedure across different types of scene evolution, without adequately accounting for their distinct effects on scene content and Gaussian model capacity.Such a rigid paradigm is prone to modifying irrelevant attributes, causing unexpected structural changes, and gradually undermining historical recovery as the Gaussian representation evolves.In this paper, we propose ControlGS, which determines which attributes of each Gaussian may change and by how much, where Gaussian capacity may be adjusted, and how each update is recorded and reversed for historical replay.In the attribute update control stage, image differences are combined with visibility, depth, and camera registration to estimate the type and reliability of each change. The estimated change type and uncertainty determine which geometric or appearance attributes may be optimized and by how much, while unrelated attributes are protected from optimizer-state drift.In the structure update control stage, the same evidence localizes the regions affected by scene changes. ControlGS then balances local rendering evidence against model complexity to decide whether Gaussian capacity in each region should change, preventing unreliable differences from triggering structural updates.In the historical replay control stage, every Gaussian receives a stable UID independent of its tensor-row position. Before each update, ControlGS stores the affected pre-update states by UID and records Gaussian births, deaths, and parent-child relations. Full-model updates additionally trigger a complete pre-update snapshot. To recover a target version, ControlGS starts from the current state or the nearest later snapshot and reverses the subsequent records, restoring the corresponding parameters and topology despite intervening structural changes and row reordering.Extensive experiments demonstrate that ControlGS outperforms state-of-the-art methods in reconstruction quality while maintaining real-time rendering. Additional tests verify that irrelevant parameters remain fixed and earlier states are reliably recovered.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Continual Learning, 3D Gaussian Splatting, Continual 3D Reconstruction, Neural Scene Representation, Topology Adaptation, Historical State Recovery.

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 9%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.50 over 4 reviews, above 9% of the others.
Reviewer_Y2YBOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

ControlGS decomposes continual Gaussian splatting into attribute update control, structure update control, and historical recovery. It combines change-dependent parameter permissions, evidence-guided topology edits, and persistent-ID-based history records to update evolving scenes while preserving unchanged content and earlier states.

Critical strengths

The separation of attribute, topology, and history management is practically motivated. The framework also addresses concrete implementation issues, including Adam-induced drift in frozen parameters and historical recovery after Gaussian reordering, with focused checks targeting these failure modes.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main experiments do not validate the proposed controls. Section 4 states that the ten-scene experiments open all Gaussian attributes and use standard 3DGS growth, rather than the proposed attribute restrictions and structure-update policy. Table 3 also allows different update paths across rows, preventing meaningful attribution of improvements to either module. The focused checks in Table 5 verify specific implementation behaviors but do not resolve this experimental gap.

  2. The methodological advance is insufficiently established. GaussianUpdate already separates appearance and geometric updates, while CL-Splats supports local optimization and historical recovery. The additional benefits of ControlGS’s permissions, heuristic scores, and persistent-ID bookkeeping are not convincingly isolated. Key event scores and uncertainty estimates are insufficiently specified, and historical recovery is not adequately tested over long sequences of mixed structural edits.

  3. Figure 1 does not clearly communicate M1’s behavior. The four change categories are labeled, but their visual outcomes are difficult to distinguish. The figure does not show which attributes are updated or frozen, or how the resulting updates differ across categories. Explicit before-and-after examples and attribute-level annotations would make it more informative. “Orign” should also be corrected to “Origin.”

Questions for authors
  1. Why does the main evaluation bypass the proposed M1/M2 policies, and which components actually produce the reported gains? 2.What substantive capability does ControlGS add beyond GaussianUpdate’s staged updates and CL-Splats’ local optimization and history recovery?
  2. Could you provide matched-protocol ablations enabling M1 and M2 individually and jointly, with explicit update-path logs?
  3. Could you evaluate long sequences of additions, removals, splits, and merges, reporting state-recovery accuracy, total history storage, and recovery latency?
Reviewer_SoBLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates the problem of 3D Gaussian Splatting under continual state changes, specifically how to update an existing 3D scene when objects in images undergo changes while preserving unchanged regions and historical states. The authors propose ControlGS, a framework that explicitly decouples attribute updates, structural changes, and historical restoration. The continual updating process is decomposed into three control modules: M1, which determines which Gaussian attributes should be updated and to what extent; M2, which determines the splitting, removal, and merging of Gaussians; and M3, which performs historical-state restoration. The authors conduct experiments on ten scenes from WAT. The results show that ControlGS achieves relatively high-quality scene reconstruction in the comparative experiments.

Critical strengths

1.This paper decomposes continual 3DGS into attribute-update control, structural-update control, and historical-replay control, thereby providing a useful analytical framework. This decomposition reveals an important issue in existing updating strategies: changes in the attributes of existing Gaussians and topological changes in the Gaussian set should not be handled in a unified manner.

2.Persistent IDs are used to track the Gaussians, thereby avoiding identity confusion after structural editing and reordering and providing a clear mechanism for restoring historical states.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper’s description of the change-evidence module is clearly incomplete. Although the authors list RGB, depth, visibility, DINOv2 features, camera alignment, and object alignment as inputs, they do not clearly explain how these signals are converted into change types, change scores, and uncertainty estimates.

  2. The ablation experiments lack rigor. The existing experimental design does not reliably isolate and verify the independent contributions of the three core modules, M1, M2, and M3. Table 3 merely demonstrates the overall performance of ControlGS under two groups of control strategies; it cannot indicate how much benefit is contributed by attribute control or structural control itself.

  3. Equation (3) determines Gaussian splitting, removal, and merging through multiple manually specified weights, thresholds, and additional conditions. However, the paper does not evaluate how these parameters are selected or assess their sensitivity.

  4. The claims regarding historical restoration and efficiency require more sufficient evidence. The quality of historical images cannot demonstrate that the Gaussian parameters, active IDs, and parent–child relationships have all been correctly restored. The four dedicated checks also provide relatively limited coverage of these aspects.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the specific computational procedure for converting observations into change types, change scores, and uncertainty estimates? The paper states that the system combines RGB residuals, DINOv2 feature differences, depth differences, visibility, multi-view consistency, and camera- and object-alignment information to infer scene change types, change scores, and uncertainty. However, the paper does not clearly explain how these observational signals are fused or how they are specifically converted.Additionally,how are the scores and hyperparameters mentioned in Equation (3) determined?

  2. How should the numerical differences in LPIPS and the experimental scope be interpreted? From which runs do the values 0.1641 in Figure 2 and 0.162 in Table 3 originate? Do they use different configurations or evaluation procedures?

Reviewer_mCYLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes ControlGS, a framework for continual 3D Gaussian Splatting that separates scene updates into three controls: attribute update control, structure update control, and historical replay control. Change evidence and uncertainty guide which Gaussian attributes may change and whether Gaussians should be split, removed, or merged. Persistent Gaussian identifiers, pre-update records, and snapshots support the recovery of earlier states after structural changes. The paper reports reconstruction results on ten WAT scenes and targeted checks of attribute freezing and historical recovery.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses an important problem: updating a Gaussian scene representation as the scene changes while preserving unchanged content and recoverable historical states.
  2. Separating attribute updates, structural changes, and historical recovery is conceptually reasonable. In particular, distinguishing appearance changes from geometric changes could help avoid unnecessary geometry updates and Gaussian growth.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The evidence described in Section 3.2 is the foundation of the method, but its presentation is vague and incomplete, with essential methodological details missing. The sources and computation of individual evidence components are insufficiently explained. For example, it is unclear which depth and visibility cues are derived from Gaussian rendering and which are obtained from external models. The uncertainty shown in Figure 1 is also neither clearly defined nor accompanied by an explanation of how it is computed.
  2. The experimental evaluation is incomplete. The method involves substantial hand-crafted design, particularly in Eq. (3), but lacks sufficient justification, targeted ablations of these design choices, and hyperparameter sensitivity analysis.
  3. Some descriptions raise concerns about whether they accurately reflect what the authors implemented and evaluated, such as the Paths used in the experiments.
Questions for authors
  1. How does each evidence component affect the updates, and what is their relative importance? How are the uncertainty estimates computed? Would removing particular components substantially affect reconstruction quality? What decision thresholds are used in attribute updates?
  2. The method relies on multiple priors that are themselves subject to errors, such as depth-estimation errors and incorrect occlusion judgments. How are these priors obtained, and how does the method account for errors in these priors?
  3. How are camera poses estimated for the past and current states? How are the two states aligned, and how is sufficient alignment accuracy ensured?
  4. The method contains numerous hyperparameters. How are they selected, and how do they affect the method’s accuracy?
Reviewer_cKB4OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how to continually update a 3D Gaussian Splatting model as a scene changes while preserving unchanged content and enabling historical scene recovery. ControlGS combines image features, depth, visibility, and camera alignment to infer scene changes and guide model updates.

Its main contribution is a framework comprising three coordinated controls. M1 determines which Gaussian attributes may change and assigns update weights. M2 uses observational evidence to govern Gaussian splitting, merging, and removal. M3 uses persistent UIDs, pre-update records, and full snapshots to recover historical states after structural changes. The paper also addresses implementation issues such as momentum-induced parameter drift and identity mismatches after tensor reordering.

Validation includes image-quality comparisons across ten WAT scenes, qualitative examples, update-strategy comparisons, historical-quality and storage comparisons, and four constructed software checks. Although the reported results are promising, the main experiments use full attribute optimization and standard 3DGS growth, while the comparisons in Table 3 do not sufficiently control experimental conditions. Consequently, the individual performance contributions of M1 and M2 remain unestablished. Long-term recovery correctness and storage efficiency also require more systematic validation.

Critical strengths

1.Clear problem decomposition with practical relevance.

The paper decomposes continual 3DGS updating into attribute control, structure control, and historical recovery. These components address which parameters may change, when Gaussians should be added, removed, or merged, and how previous states can be recovered, providing a clear framework for maintaining evolving 3D scenes.

2.Attention to implementation correctness beyond image quality metrics.

The paper addresses parameter drift caused by Adam momentum and identity mismatches caused by Gaussian deletion and row reordering. Parameter restoration, optimizer-state handling, and persistent UID records are useful design choices for improving the reliability of local updates and historical recovery.

Critical weaknesses

1. The experimental comparisons do not establish the effectiveness of the proposed controls.

The main experiments across ten scenes optimize all Gaussian attributes and use standard 3DGS growth, rather than directly evaluating the proposed selective attribute and structural controls. Table 3 also fails to isolate individual module contributions: the paper does not establish that the other modules and experimental conditions remain fixed, and acknowledges that update paths may differ across rows. Consequently, the reported improvements cannot be reliably attributed to M1 or M2.

2. Insufficient methodological detail and validation limit reproducibility and confidence in the claims.

The computation of change types, change scores, and uncertainty estimates is inadequately specified. M2 relies on numerous hand-set coefficients and thresholds without sufficient sensitivity analysis. Historical recovery is supported mainly by rendered images and a few constructed checks, without systematic verification of Gaussian parameters, active UIDs, and parent–child relationships over long sequences. Storage comparisons lack complete accounting and scalability analysis, while the real-time rendering claim lacks FPS measurements and hardware specifications.

Questions for authors

1.Does each row in Table 3 replace only the target module?

When evaluating M1, are M2 and M3 held fixed? Likewise, when evaluating M2, are M1 and M3 held fixed? Please provide the configuration for each row, including the update scope, structural update strategy, training budget, history storage scheme, and random seed, to clarify whether performance differences can be attributed to the target module.

2. How are scene changes and control scores computed?

Please specify how change types, change scores, and the different uncertainty estimates are obtained. How are the inputs to M2 normalized, and how are its coefficients and thresholds selected? Are these settings kept consistent across scenes?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.