- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses continuous Gaussian-count budget control with limited additional storage and fast switching between budgets. The authors construct a set of nested, budget-adapted anchor models with persistent Gaussian identities. Intermediate budgets are decoded by interpolating shared members’ parameters between anchors and gradually activating newly introduced members through opacity gating. A residual atlas compresses the additional anchor states.
Critical strengths
The idea of connecting a small set of budget-adapted anchors through parameter interpolation is interesting and practically useful.
The ablation studies examine the contributions of budget-specific adaptation, shared-member interpolation, entering-member opacity gating, and progress calibration.
The method achieves strong rendering quality against the evaluated continuous-budget baselines, with measured storage overhead and budget-switching latency.
Critical weaknesses
I feel the novelty is limited, as the paper mainly trains multiple models and proposes a way to interpolate between them. But that is not a major issue for me. I am more concerned about the evaluation.
- Comparisons with closely related continuous and hierarchical LOD methods are incomplete.
1.1 I would particularly appreciate comparisons with CLoD-GS (Cheng et al., ICLR 2026, distinct from the CLOD-3DGS baseline already evaluated) and LapisGS.
- CLoD-GS: Continuous Level-of-Detail via 3D Gaussian Splatting. Official code: https://github.com/amap-cvlab/CLoD-GS
- LapisGS: Layered Progressive 3D Gaussian Splatting for Adaptive Streaming. Official code: https://github.com/nus-vv-streams/lapis-gs
1.2 Hierarchical methods such as Hierarchical 3DGS and Octree-GS would also provide informative comparisons. Although their native LOD selection is typically view-dependent rather than based on an exact global Gaussian-count budget, their LOD controls can be swept to obtain different rendering complexities. For example, adjusting the projected-footprint threshold in Hierarchical 3DGS changes the selected hierarchy levels and active Gaussian counts. Similarly, in Octree-GS, a negative bias can be added to the predicted LOD levels to lower the overall level of detail and gaussian count. I suggest comparing rendering quality against actual active Gaussian counts.
- A Hierarchical 3D Gaussian Representation for Real-Time Rendering of Very Large Datasets. Official code: https://github.com/graphdeco-inria/hierarchical-3d-gaussians
- Octree-GS: Towards Consistent Real-time Rendering with LOD-Structured 3D Gaussians. Official code: https://github.com/city-super/Octree-GS
- The independently optimized per-budget reference is limited to GNS. The GNS comparison is useful, but it leaves unclear how ParetoGS compares with other methods optimized for each budget, especially at low Gaussian counts. Additional baselines would help:
-
3DGS-MCMC: Supports a configurable maximum Gaussian count and can be trained separately at representative budgets. Official code: https://github.com/ubc-vision/3dgs-mcmc.
-
GS²: A relevant compact 3DGS method. Official code: https://github.com/BJTU-KD3D/GS-2.
If these baselines require retraining because checkpoints are unavailable for the 13 scenes used in this paper, please include comparisons on at least one or two representative scenes.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors address the comparisons discussed in the weaknesses above and provide additional experiments?
-
Have the authors tried an MLP-based 3DGS representation such as Scaffold-GS? These methods encode Gaussian attributes through compact latent features and decode Gaussians based on the view. One possible approach is to train models at several LOD levels and interpolate between the latent features of corresponding anchors. Could this offer better quality or a more compact representation than interpolating explicit Gaussian parameters? I would be interested in whether the authors have tested this approach and how it compares with ParetoGS.
ScaffoldGS: Lu, Tao, et al. "Scaffold-gs: Structured 3d gaussians for view-adaptive rendering." 2024 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2024.
Dear Area Chair and reviewers,
Thank you for your feedback on ParetoGS. The revision identifies ParetoGS as a prefix method with parameters that can change with the requested count. Figure 1 walks through anchor construction, encoding, and decoding, and the main additions and clarifications are marked in blue.