acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

ParetoGS: High-Quality Continuous-Budget 3D Gaussian Splatting with Sparse Adapted Anchors

Abstract

Scalable 3D Gaussian Splatting allows one scene representation to serve different Gaussian-count budgets, yet its quality–budget curve may lag behind models optimized separately for each budget. Reducing the number of Gaussians changes both the selected members and the reconstruction tasks carried by the survivors; parameters inherited from a high-budget model may fit a low-budget representation poorly. We propose ParetoGS, which describes member changes and parameter evolution with a small set of adapted budget anchors and decodes intermediate budgets without separate optimization at every requested count. ParetoGS alternates pruning and fixed-member adaptation to build nested anchors with persistent identities, and encodes their parameter changes relative to the full model in a compact residual atlas. At decoding, it interpolates the states of shared members and gradually introduces the rendering contributions of new members, connecting sparse anchors into a continuous-budget representation. Across 13 scenes, ParetoGS attains better average PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS with fewer Gaussians than the compared prefix methods at 10% of each method's own full model. From a shared full model, it also outperforms FlexGS-imp at its trained 1%, 5%, and 10% budgets and NanoGS-imp at the 1% and 0.1% budgets. On Garden, its non-anchor quality approaches an empirical reference from independently optimized GNS models at higher retention ratios and exceeds it at some lower-budget points. Across 13 scenes, encoding reduces mean additional state from 390.018 to 85.653 MB with an average PSNR change of 0.012 dB.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
3D Gaussian Splatting, Scalable Scene Representation, Budget-Adaptive Rendering, Model Compression, Novel View Synthesis

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_8xhYOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses continuous Gaussian-count budget control with limited additional storage and fast switching between budgets. The authors construct a set of nested, budget-adapted anchor models with persistent Gaussian identities. Intermediate budgets are decoded by interpolating shared members’ parameters between anchors and gradually activating newly introduced members through opacity gating. A residual atlas compresses the additional anchor states.

Critical strengths

The idea of connecting a small set of budget-adapted anchors through parameter interpolation is interesting and practically useful.

The ablation studies examine the contributions of budget-specific adaptation, shared-member interpolation, entering-member opacity gating, and progress calibration.

The method achieves strong rendering quality against the evaluated continuous-budget baselines, with measured storage overhead and budget-switching latency.

Critical weaknesses

I feel the novelty is limited, as the paper mainly trains multiple models and proposes a way to interpolate between them. But that is not a major issue for me. I am more concerned about the evaluation.

  1. Comparisons with closely related continuous and hierarchical LOD methods are incomplete.

1.1 I would particularly appreciate comparisons with CLoD-GS (Cheng et al., ICLR 2026, distinct from the CLOD-3DGS baseline already evaluated) and LapisGS.

1.2 Hierarchical methods such as Hierarchical 3DGS and Octree-GS would also provide informative comparisons. Although their native LOD selection is typically view-dependent rather than based on an exact global Gaussian-count budget, their LOD controls can be swept to obtain different rendering complexities. For example, adjusting the projected-footprint threshold in Hierarchical 3DGS changes the selected hierarchy levels and active Gaussian counts. Similarly, in Octree-GS, a negative bias can be added to the predicted LOD levels to lower the overall level of detail and gaussian count. I suggest comparing rendering quality against actual active Gaussian counts.

  1. The independently optimized per-budget reference is limited to GNS. The GNS comparison is useful, but it leaves unclear how ParetoGS compares with other methods optimized for each budget, especially at low Gaussian counts. Additional baselines would help:

If these baselines require retraining because checkpoints are unavailable for the 13 scenes used in this paper, please include comparisons on at least one or two representative scenes.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors address the comparisons discussed in the weaknesses above and provide additional experiments?

  2. Have the authors tried an MLP-based 3DGS representation such as Scaffold-GS? These methods encode Gaussian attributes through compact latent features and decode Gaussians based on the view. One possible approach is to train models at several LOD levels and interpolate between the latent features of corresponding anchors. Could this offer better quality or a more compact representation than interpolating explicit Gaussian parameters? I would be interested in whether the authors have tested this approach and how it compares with ParetoGS.

ScaffoldGS: Lu, Tao, et al. "Scaffold-gs: Structured 3d gaussians for view-adaptive rendering." 2024 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2024.

Reviewer_2xaPOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ParetoGS, a method that reconstructs scenes with 3D Gaussian Splatting with a variable number of gaussian particles ("budget") that can be provided at inference ("Scalable 3DGS").

Instead of learning a set of gaussians ordered by importance and trimming them to the desired budget, ParetoGS optimizes different budgets-anchors. Starting from a pretrained full-budget 3DGS, gaussians are assigned to budget-anchors, and a per-anchor residual allows them to stray away from their full-budget parameters.

Critical strengths
  • Scalable 3DGS is an important and challenging setting.
  • The method is evaluated in depth, with qualitative, quantitative, and ablation results.
  • Budget-anchors represent a reasonable idea and are fairly new.
Critical weaknesses
  • The discussion of related works lists them with little explanation. This makes it challenging to position ParetoGS with regards to existing literature. Prefix methods serve as the main baselines and are mentioned throughout the paper, but are never explained and it is unclear what their main limitation is. Since ParetoGS also has an implicit order on Gaussians, it could also arguably be considered a prefix method.
  • The method is still quite unclear. The order of sections makes it needlessly complicated, and a method diagram would greatly help.
  • There is no strong reason for a given Gaussian to have the same purpose at different budgets, making the residual larger and interpolation meaningless.

Minor weaknesses:

  • The additional need for a residual makes the method memory-hungry, essentially copying the same 3DGS scenes at all requested budgets, which defeats the purpose of Scalable 3DGS. At least, this is clearly mentioned and evaluated to be a 17% increase in memory in section 4.5.
  • The paper has clear signs of LLM-writing, which is fine, but the authors should proof-read and adjust the content. This includes the excessive use of semicolons, making it hard to read. Also, in Figure 1, the caption includes the entire figure layout for no reason: "The five columns show CLOD3DGS, MGS, FlexGS-imp, NanoGS-imp, and ParetoGS; the rows show 30%, 10%, 5%, 1%, and 0.1%."
  • Anchors in the context of 3DGS often refer to Scaffold-GS style methods, so I find the term a bit confusing at first. Perhaps budget-anchors would be clearer.
Questions for authors
  • What is the reasoning behind independently optimizing each budget, rather than jointly?
  • Is there no need for regularization on the residual to align gaussians across budgets?
Reviewer_nCZ6OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ParetoGS for continuous-budget 3DGS. Starting from a trained full model, it constructs a sequence of nested, budget-specific anchors by iteratively pruning Gaussians with GNS to a lower target budget and fine-tuning the retained Gaussians before proceeding to the next budget. The anchor parameters are stored as quantized residuals relative to the full model. For a budget between two neighboring anchors, the method interpolates the parameters of shared Gaussians between their anchor states and adds Gaussians from the upper anchor, using their upper-anchor parameters in reverse pruning order.

Critical strengths
  • The paper provides qualitative and quantitative evidence that the same Gaussians benefit from different parameters at different budgets, which could explain the quality degradation of shared-parameter prefix methods at low budgets.

  • The pipeline is simple and built on existing components, and it outputs standard 3DGS models that are compatible with existing 3DGS rasterizers.

Critical weaknesses
  • Readability. The paper's readability needs substantial improvement.

    • The paper uses many unclear, metaphorical terms uncommon in the field, e.g., "contract", "membership", "survivors/entering members", and "residual atlas".
    • Many custom terms are also introduced without sufficient explanation or definition, making the paper difficult to read and follow.
    • The method section does not sufficiently described preliminaries (e.g., GNS), and lacks an overview of the pipeline.
    • Neither the introduction nor the method section includes figures illustrating the motivation or method.
  • Unclear technical contributions. It is difficult to separate the paper's own contributions from components adopted from prior work.

    • The paper does not clearly position itself relative to prior work or explain its differences. It also does not clearly state what problem it addresses or whether that problem actually exists.
    • While the paper tackles separate optimization for each target Gaussian budget, ParetoGS also performs budget-specific fine-tuning at selected Gaussian budgets (anchor states).
  • Unclear problem statement. The necessity of continuous Gaussian budget should be described more thoroughly.

    • The paper should clearly demonstrate why a continuous Gaussian budget is needed and what applications and impact it could have.
    • LoD-based 3DGS methods have clear practical uses, such as multi-resolution rendering of large-scale scenes. It is unclear what practical scenarios the proposed continuous-budget representation has or whether it can support such LoD applications.
  • Evaluations. Experimental protocols could be potentially unfair and evaluations are insufficient to clearly support the claims.

    • In its original setting, CLOD-3DGS is trained down to 100K Gaussians (Sec. 4.1), but it is evaluated at 1% and 0.1%, outside that training range. It is unclear whether CLOD-3DGS was retrained for these target budgets to ensure a fair comparison.
    • Most of the performance improvement appears to come from existing components, ImprovedGS and GNS pruning. The effect of continuous-budget interpolation between anchor states appears marginal.
    • It is unclear why ParetoGS trains substantially faster than the other baselines. The paper should also compare storage costs without quantization, since quantization can also be applied to the baselines.
    • The smoothness of transitions between budgets (e.g., popping or flickering when the budget changes during rendering) is not evaluated, despite being a key motivation for continuous decoding.
  • Missing baselines.

    • Several closely related methods are missing from the comparisons: CLoD-GS, LapisGS, and Differentiable Hierarchies, which are described as closely related in the related work.
Questions for authors
  • What practical scenario requires decoding at an arbitrary Gaussian count rather than switching among stored anchor models?
  • Can ParetoGS support spatially varying LoD (e.g., distance-based rendering of large-scale scenes), given that each Gaussian's parameters depend on the global budget?
  • How does ParetoGS compare with (a) GNS models independently optimized at each budget across all scenes and (b) simply using the nearest lower anchor for intermediate budgets?

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear Area Chair and reviewers,

Thank you for your feedback on ParetoGS. The revision identifies ParetoGS as a prefix method with parameters that can change with the requested count. Figure 1 walks through anchor construction, encoding, and decoding, and the main additions and clarifications are marked in blue.

  • Single-budget and spatial LoD baselines (8xhY). One asset per scene improves PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS over 30 independent 3DGS-MCMC runs at matched counts across Garden, Bonsai, and Train. It also improves those metrics at the three terminal counts of the public GS² pipeline, which omits the paper's image-space distribution optimization stage. We evaluated both LapisGS constructions on Garden and Bonsai. At the coarsest native training sizes on Bonsai, LapisGS has an advantage. The Garden comparisons with CLoD-GS, Hierarchical 3DGS, and Octree-GS report actual submitted counts from their native LoD controls (Appendix F, Tables 12–16).
  • Intermediate decoding and deployment (nCZ6). Table 9 compares exact decoding and dedicated GNS at ten intermediate counts per scene. At the four tested midpoints from 4.8% to 38.4% of Full, the gap to dedicated GNS is 0.050–0.175 dB in mean PSNR across 13 scenes. Across all 130 requests, exact decoding improves mean PSNR by 0.187 dB over serving the largest fitting anchor from the same asset. The benefit combines the higher count and changes to decoded parameters. At the same counts and with endpoints and gating held fixed, interpolating the shared fields adds 0.127 dB (Table 3). Section 4.6 and Appendix C report switch latency and the default cache costs. A discrete GNS library jointly matched in total storage and training updates remains an open comparison. Appendix B.2 and the supplementary videos show per-Gaussian distance LoD on Bicycle and Bonsai, where peak local RGB changes fall by 20.0% and 27.7% with additional Gaussians and frame time.
  • Successive optimization and training checkpoints (2xaP). Section 3 explains how pruning from a fitted parent changes the next stage's input. In eight low-count tests on Garden, Bonsai, and Train, this route improves all three metrics over direct GNS given equal updates or at least as much time (Appendix F.1). Appendix F.4 compares MGS, which jointly trains prefixes with shared states on the same backend. Jointly fitting the same members and budget-specific states remains an open comparison. Appendix C.1 describes the training checkpoints saved to disk and reports their Gaussian row count.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.