- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies underwater hyperspectral image (HSI) restoration, aiming to recover both spatial details and spectral information from degraded underwater HSIs. The proposed UWHFormer estimates water-related states from the degraded input based on an underwater image formation model, and uses them to guide a Transformer-based restoration network, followed by a refinement step. The authors also collect a real paired dataset, with short-exposure observations as inputs and long-exposure captures as references, and compare the method with existing HSI denoising methods, together with ablations.
Critical strengths
Real paired data are scarce in this area. The authors collect such a dataset and plan to release it, which could benefit future research. 2. An intuitive design with consistent results
Guiding restoration with a physical model is intuitive, and the figures are clear. The method achieves the best PSNR, SAM, and ERGAS among the compared methods, with SSIM on par with HSDT (Table 1), and each module brings improvements in the ablation (Table 2).
Critical weaknesses
The role of the physics guidance could be better supported
The data may not directly verify compensation for water-induced degradation. The abstract lists wavelength-dependent attenuation, scattering, insufficient illumination, and sensor noise as underwater degradations (L014–016), and states that the method compensates for attenuation and scattering (L022–023). However, both inputs and references are captured underwater and differ only in exposure time (L245–246, L357–360), so the data mainly reflect insufficient illumination and noise (L358–359). Since attenuation and scattering are also present in the references, whether the method compensates for them cannot be directly assessed. The estimated physical states are not quantitatively validated. They are described as "physically interpretable" (L020, L092), while the paper also notes that they serve as latent guidance rather than calibrated physical measurements (L245–246). The ablation adds each module as a whole (Table 2), so it is difficult to tell whether the gains come from the physics-based design (e.g., the physical bias in PSA) or from the module itself (e.g., an additional spectral attention layer, which also increases computation; App. F). Since physics guidance is the central contribution of the paper, these points are important for assessing it. 2. The experimental evidence is somewhat limited
The comparison includes four general HSI denoising methods from 2020–2023 (L417–422), while more recent methods mentioned in the related work (L151–153) are not compared. The evaluation scale is limited. The test set contains 24 samples (L360–361). The claim of robustness to imaging-distance shifts (L097–099) is evaluated only on an additional 6.3 m subset with four scenes, and only against the degraded input rather than other methods (App. C). As a result, the current experiments do not yet fully support the claims on performance and generalization.
Questions for authors
Scope of the task. Since the references are also captured underwater, only with longer exposure, which degradations does the method mainly address? How should the claimed compensation for attenuation and scattering be understood? Role of the physics guidance. Could you add controlled ablations, for example PSA without the physical bias, or WCS replaced by a generic conditioning encoder of similar size? In addition, do the estimated states (e.g., transmission) change with imaging distance as expected, for instance being lower on the 6.3 m subset? Comparisons and robustness. Could you also report the baselines' results on the 6.3 m subset? If feasible, could you include more recent methods as well? Data and other clarifications. Could you describe the acquisition environment, e.g., a water tank or open water, the water type, and the illumination? How does the task setting differ from that of Li et al. (2024) (L185–186)? Why does the SSIM of the full model differ between Table 1 (0.860) and Table 2 (0.865)?