- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes AWSTC for hyperspectral image completion by combining gradient-domain low-rank tensor factorization, learned auxiliary mappings, and adaptive wavelet attention. Haar-initialized learnable analysis and synthesis filters, high-frequency thresholding, and subband attention generate channel-wise weights for the low-rank fitting term. The proposed variable updates are unfolded into a multi-stage network. Experiments on Indian Pines, Salinas, and Pavia University report strong recovery at several missing rates, with comparisons of attention modules, individual AWA components, and unfolding depth.
Critical strengths
-
The motivation for combining gradient-domain low-rank structure with frequency-aware attention is clear, and the AWA construction is specified beyond a generic attention block. The manuscript explicitly acknowledges that its learned filters need not be orthogonal or perfectly reconstructive, and that the CNN mappings are not claimed to be exact proximal operators of explicit regularizers.
-
The submission reports strong restoration results and includes meaningful attention controls. Table 4 compares several attention alternatives with the remaining components fixed, while Table 5 separately examines learned filters, thresholding, subband attention, and high-frequency fusion. These are useful positive observations, although their interpretation remains subject to the evaluation concern below.
Critical weaknesses
-
The factor updates do not follow from the stated weighted objective. Equations (14)–(15) weight residuals on the original spectral channels, but (B.6) removes those weights before deriving the unweighted Fourier-slice updates in (17)/(B.8)–(B.10). Nonuniform original-band weights generally produce a nondiagonal metric after the mode-3 DFT and couple Fourier slices; positivity alone does not remove them. A small rank-one, two-band example gives a fixed point of the stated unweighted updates with a nonzero gradient of the original weighted objective. Thus, the claimed derivation of these model-based stages is not established. This does not imply that AWA is absent from the network—(21) retains it—or that the learned architecture cannot work as a heuristic.
-
The supervised training and evaluation split is not established, and the stated Indian Pines dimensions make a disjoint same-scene crop protocol impossible. Section 4.1 gives a 145×145 original image, a 128×128 evaluation crop, and 32×32 training patches sampled from the original HSI with ground-truth supervision. Any such axis-aligned patch must overlap the evaluation crop by at least 15 pixels in each dimension. The submission does not specify another training source or an exclusion policy. This does not confirm what the actual implementation did, but the written protocol cannot support an interpretation as evaluation on spatially unseen content. Model/depth selection and learned-baseline training access also require clarification.
Questions for authors
-
How do (17)/(B.6)–(B.10) follow from the channel-weighted term in (14)? Please specify the domain of the weights and the implemented factor update. If the unweighted step is an intentional approximation, provide its relation to the objective and revise the derivation claim; if the forward update must change, please identify and update the affected results.
-
Please provide the training/validation/test sources and crop coordinates or exclusion rules for each dataset, especially explaining the 145/128/32 Indian Pines dimensions. Were clean values from the evaluated region used for supervised fitting? If this is intentional same-scene adaptation, please define that setting, establish comparable clean-data access for the baselines, and provide an evaluation consistent with the claimed task. Please also identify the independent data, if any, used to choose checkpoints and unfolding depth.
3 comments
Reply to Authors' Response
I appreciate the authors' efforts in providing a detailed reply and experiments. However, my concern still remains, especially in the independent evaluation: In my point of view: the reported scores somehow do not provide an independent estimate of performance after model selection. Specifically, the revised split addresses spatial overlap, but the authors confirm that both the checkpoint and the 11-stage depth were selected using ground-truth PSNR on the same region used to report test performance. I might incline to my current rate if these ambiguities cannot be resolved.
Thank you for clarifying this concern. We agree that spatial separation alone does not provide an independent performance estimate when the same region is used for checkpoint and depth selection. We have therefore added an evaluation on a previously unused region, reported in Section 4.6 and Table 7.
Independent evaluation protocol. On Pavia University at 50% missingness, we evaluate region B: rows 1–192 and columns 257–320 (one-based indexing), with size 192 × 64 × 103. This region does not overlap either the training region or the original model-selection region. It was not used for training, checkpoint selection, depth selection, or other parameter tuning.
Before evaluating region B, we fixed the previously selected 11-stage AWSTC and its Pavia University checkpoint, without retraining or further model selection. All ten methods were evaluated on the same region, corrupted input, and missing-data mask, using settings fixed before evaluation. No parameters or outputs were selected using region B’s ground truth. We reconstructed three non-overlapping 64 × 64 blocks and computed the metrics after concatenating them into the full region.
Results. AWSTC achieves 48.11 dB PSNR, 0.99 SSIM, 0.99 FSIM, and 21.43 ERGAS. Compared with CRNL, the strongest baseline in PSNR and ERGAS, AWSTC improves PSNR by 3.76 dB and reduces ERGAS by 25.2%. SSIM and FSIM are joint-best at the reported precision.
This experiment evaluates the already selected model on data excluded from both training and model selection, directly addressing the concern about an independent performance estimate. We explicitly distinguish the original region, which served model selection, from the new independent test region. The evidence is limited to this additional within-scene evaluation on Pavia University at 50% missingness; it does not make the earlier results independent of model selection or establish cross-scene generalization.
The protocol and results are highlighted in blue in the revised manuscript. We hope this additional evidence addresses your concern and would appreciate your reconsideration of the assessment.
We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and for recognizing our motivation and attention ablations. We clarify the factor updates, revised spatial partition, and model-selection protocol below.
1. Factor updates and the weighted objective
Our factor-update construction follows Mai et al., “Attention-Guided Low-Rank Tensor Completion” (AGTC), which formulates an attention-weighted factor subproblem in Eq. (16) and provides Fourier-slice pseudoinverse updates in Eqs. (17)–(18). We adapted this construction to directional-gradient tensor factorization.
In AWSTC, AWA weights are defined on the original spectral channels and broadcast spatially. The factor step performs unweighted least-squares fitting, while the gradient-tensor update explicitly incorporates AWA weights to adjust channel-wise fitting contributions. Together, these steps constitute the unfolding stage.
We recognize that the reviewer's question concerns exact minimization of the weighted subproblem, rather than the presence of attention. We therefore distinguish the construction's provenance from its optimization interpretation: the adopted factor step is an unweighted surrogate update, not an exact solution of the generally nonuniform channel-weighted subproblem. The AGTC reference establishes the source of this construction; it does not itself prove equivalence for arbitrary channel weights.
2. Revised spatially disjoint training/test partition
Thank you for identifying the spatial-overlap issue. The original sampling procedure allowed overlap between training patches and the evaluation region. We have corrected the partition and rerun the experiments using spatially non-overlapping training and test regions.
The revised protocol is specified in Section 4.1:
All spectral bands are retained. For Indian Pines, replacing the original 128 × 128 test crop with a 64 × 128 crop leaves a separate lower region accommodating 32 × 32 training patches, resolving the dimensional conflict identified by the reviewer.
Under this protocol, clean reference values from the test region are excluded from supervised parameter updates. The experiment evaluates restoration in spatially held-out regions within each scene, rather than cross-scene generalization. The revised partition is highlighted in blue in Section 4.1, and updated results appear in Tables 1–3 and the subsequent experimental analyses.
3. Checkpoint selection, unfolding depth, and baseline training data
The final checkpoint was selected as the training epoch with the highest PSNR on the designated test region. The depth of 11 stages was also selected according to PSNR on that region. No separate validation region was used for either choice.
Thus, although the test region was excluded from supervised parameter updates, its clean reference values were used for checkpoint and depth selection. The corrected spatial split removes direct overlap between training patches and test pixels, but does not eliminate this model-selection dependence.
AWSTC, AGTC, and the other learning-based methods in this comparison use the same training data, providing a common supervised training-data basis. This condition does not, by itself, imply identical checkpoint or hyperparameter selection procedures.
We appreciate the opportunity to clarify these distinctions and the scope of the reported results.