- Rating
- 3(+2)
- Confidence
- 3(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 2(+1)
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
The authors address the challenge that, although previous low-rank tensor models provide global references for noise removal, their compact representations may overlook some genuine signal components. To tackle this issue, they propose the ST-HALFNet model. This model employs learned shared tensor variations and a half-thresholding method to estimate sparse corruption, ultimately achieving effective image restoration. Comparative experiments were conducted on full-resolution CAVE and ICVL images to validate the effectiveness of the proposed model, along with several effective ablation analyses.
Critical strengths
(1) The authors appear to have proposed an effective low-rank tensor model that achieves superior performance on CAVE and ICVL images.
(2) The authors provide relatively sufficient comparison figures and experimental results, and the paper is generally well written and fluently expressed.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The authors report that the ST-HALFNet model achieves a 13.14 dB improvement over the current strongest baseline. Given that such a margin represents an extremely substantial gain within the existing baseline framework, yet the paper provides no mention of released code or any commitment to future open-source availability, I have serious doubts regarding the authenticity of the reported results, as the magnitude of this accuracy improvement appears to far exceed the pace typically observed in normal model iteration.
(2) The reference formatting in the paper is incorrect: normal citation linking between in-text citations and the REFERENCES section cannot be established, suggesting that the authors may have modified the template format themselves. It remains unclear whether this issue constitutes grounds for desk rejection. In addition, the formatting of figure and table citations in the paper is also incorrect.
(3) In Figure 1, the Reference image and the Restored image appear to exhibit no significant difference at the level of fine detail. Although the authors emphasize that the PSNR of the Reference image is only 43.26, whereas that of the Restored image reaches 51.81, my understanding of the PSNR metric suggests that once PSNR exceeds 40, the image is already very close to the original ground truth; further gains in accuracy may well be attributable to overfitting. It is also possible that information leakage is involved, and such improvements would carry no practical significance. As for Figure 2, the pipeline framework diagram appears to have been generated by AI. The authors should refine and revise the framework diagram on the basis of the AI-generated version rather than adopting it directly.
(4) The Introduction section is extremely poorly organized. On the one hand, the authors fail to clarify why previous methods encounter this problem; on the other hand, they do not articulate the core contributions of this paper.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the content of the Weakness section and provide detailed responses to each of the issues raised.
4 comments
Thank you for the authors’ careful and detailed response. I have also thoroughly examined the provided code. Although the corresponding pretrained weights were not released, the implementation is generally consistent with the descriptions in the paper, which alleviates some of my concerns regarding the reliability of the work.
Nevertheless, given the limited novelty of the proposed approach and the limitations of the experimental comparisons, I remain somewhat concerned that the paper may not yet meet the acceptance standard of ICLR. However, in light of the authors’ clarification and the consistency between the code and the paper, I will increase my score.
Thank you for examining the implementation and for reconsidering your assessment. We appreciate your finding that the code is consistent with the paper and that this addresses part of the reliability concern raised in the original review.
Released checkpoints. The two trained ST-HalfNet models used in the main restoration and transfer experiments were included in both the original supplementary ZIP and the revised source package:
pretrained/cave.pt: selected CAVE model used in Tables 1–3.pretrained/icvl.pt: selected ICVL model used in Tables 1–3.
The revised package additionally provides the learned representation states in pretrained/representation/{cave,icvl}.pt and the trained Table 4 controls in pretrained/controls/. It also includes the final configurations and the training and evaluation code for all learned comparison methods.
Novelty. We respectfully disagree with the assessment of limited novelty. ST-HalfNet changes the role of the low-rank model in tensor restoration: the estimated low-rank tensor is used as a compact reference for estimating sparse corruption, while the final image is recovered as . The restored image can therefore retain reliable signal outside the reference family. This formulation is realized through three linked advances: (i) joint learning of a shared orthogonal spectral transform and nonuniform slice ranks under a fixed total rank budget, with the globally optimal rank allocation for each fixed transform (Section 3, Proposition 1); (ii) prediction of the signal omitted by the reference before Half thresholding (Section 4); and (iii) an error analysis that separates missed corruption, prediction error, and shrinkage and gives sufficient conditions under which the restored output has lower error than every tensor in the learned low-rank family (Section 5). Together, these elements define a distinct restoration formulation supported by theory and controlled experiments.
The controls isolate these contributions. Rank allocation provides the largest representation gain. After each basis receives its own optimal ranks determined from the training images, transform optimization still improves CAVE restoration by 0.14–0.38 dB over the initial spectral basis and yields the lowest approximation error on both datasets (Tables 4 and 9). With the learned representation fixed, a separately trained Soft variant lowers mean PSNR by 3.36–6.93 dB relative to Half (Table 4). Table 3 holds the estimated reference, thresholds, and candidate support fixed, yet residual prediction raises ICVL restoration from 51.57 to 55.81 dB at 10% corruption. The results demonstrate distinct empirical roles for rank allocation, transform learning, residual prediction, and Half thresholding.
Experimental comparisons. The revised evaluation provides broad and targeted support for the paper's claims. It compares four optimization methods and four learned baselines on two full-resolution hyperspectral datasets; evaluates salt-and-pepper corruption at 10%, 30%, and 50%; applies the same validation criterion to every learned method; tests transfer to random-valued and sparse Gaussian corruption without retuning; and includes dedicated controls for basis choice, rank allocation, prediction using the best clean approximation, and spatially structured corruption. After the common model-selection procedure, ST-HalfNet retains the highest mean PSNR in every main restoration and transfer condition in Tables 1–2. If the reviewer has a particular baseline or experimental setting in mind that is not covered by these evaluations, we would appreciate a specific suggestion.
Thank you for the authors’ further clarification. I acknowledge the substantial experimental evidence and the effectiveness of the proposed method. However, I still have reservations about whether the method and its practical significance fully meet the standards of ICLR.
Under this year’s four-point scoring system, I found it difficult to decide between a score of 2 and 3. Nevertheless, in light of the authors’ careful and detailed response, as well as the extensive experiments and demonstrated model effectiveness, I have decided to raise my score to 3.
I would like to clarify that this decision is primarily based on the authors’ thorough response, the breadth of the experimental evaluation, and the empirical effectiveness of the model, rather than on a strong conviction regarding the method’s novelty or practical impact. I hope the authors can understand my final score and evaluation in the context of this year’s scoring scheme.
If the paper is unfortunately not accepted, I sincerely wish the authors success with their future submissions.
Response to Reviewer vwbj
Thank you for the review. We address the four weaknesses below, as requested in Question 1.
Weakness 1. Code and the 13.14 dB gain
The original submission already included source code and the CAVE/ICVL ST-HalfNet checkpoints in its supplementary ZIP, and the manuscript's Reproducibility statement identified the accompanying implementation. These materials were available for review at submission. We provide the revised code again in the supplementary attachment and in the anonymous repository. The README gives data preparation, training, evaluation, and figure-generation commands. The repository link is now also in the introduction and Reproducibility statement.
The reported 13.14 dB gain measures transfer to a different corruption distribution. Table 2 evaluates how the same restoration methods perform when the corruption distribution changes: models selected for salt-and-pepper restoration are applied directly to random-valued and sparse Gaussian corruption, with no further training, and optimization methods retain their solver settings. On ICVL at 10% random-valued corruption, ST-HalfNet achieves 54.90 dB compared with 41.76 dB for DFT-TRPCA, the strongest listed comparator. This gives the reported 13.14 dB difference.
This comparison measures generalization to a different corruption distribution, where methods can differ substantially in how much accuracy they retain. It does not compare successive versions of one model. Table 2 and Appendix E.1 give the absolute scores and conditions; Figure 3 shows recovered structures across the corruption distributions. The supplied implementation allows these comparisons to be checked directly.
Weakness 2. Citations and formatting
Clickable citations are controlled by the
hyperrefpackage and do not require changing the conference template. That package was not loaded in the original source. We have checked the conference and bibliography style files against the official files and confirmed that they are unchanged. Citations and cross-references resolve correctly, and hyperlinks are now enabled.Could the reviewer point to the specific figure or table reference that is incorrectly formatted? We have not found an unresolved or incorrectly numbered reference in our checks; a concrete example would help us identify and correct any remaining issue.
Weakness 3. Image accuracy and Figure 2
We would argue that further reconstruction accuracy remains meaningful above 40 dB. Figure 1 improves from 43.26 to 51.81 dB, while the enlarged regions and error maps in Figure 4 and Appendix E.2 show the recovered details and reduced errors. A small printed image may not reveal these differences clearly. Hyperspectral restoration also aims to preserve the measured signal across all bands, not only the appearance of a color display.
We rechecked the data splits and training and evaluation procedures and found no test-data leakage in these checks. Training and validation determine the learned parameters; ordinary restoration takes only the corrupted image as input. The supplementary code provides these procedures for inspection, as specified in Appendix C.1–C.4. A high test PSNR alone is not evidence of overfitting or leakage.
We used AI assistance and disclosed its use in the paper. Figure 2 has now been revised to show the main computation and actual intermediate images more clearly. The authors edited and checked the diagram.
Weakness 4. Motivation and contributions
We have rewritten the introduction to explain the problem and the two contributions explicitly. When a low-rank approximation is used as the restored image, genuine detail outside that representation is lost. Under sparse corruption, uncorrupted measurements can still contain details omitted by the low-rank reference. Treating the entire residual as corruption can therefore remove genuine signal. This explains why fitting a compact reference accurately is not sufficient for complete signal recovery.
The two contributions follow from this problem. Joint transform and rank learning improves the reference under a fixed budget, with optimal allocation for each fixed transform. Residual prediction and Half thresholding then estimate corruption while preserving the signal the reference omits. Section 1 now connects this motivation to the proposed computation in Figure 2. Table 3 isolates prediction at a fixed reference, Tables 4 and 9 separate the representation contributions, and Section 5 relates the components to restoration error.