- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The present paper proposes Metro-SSD, a trainable denoiser for plug-and-play image reconstruction. A network predicts aggregation weights from a reference image. These weights define a symmetric operator, and Metropolis normalization makes the operator stochastic without forming the full matrix. After warm-up, the reference and algorithm parameters are fixed. For quadratic data fidelity, the authors establish linear convergence under the stated assumptions for PnP-HQS and PnP-DRS. DRS uses an equal average of the denoiser and the identity operator. Experiments on deblurring, superresolution, and MRI show competitive reconstruction performance.
Critical strengths
-
The construction enforces symmetry and stochasticity by design. The convergence analysis establishes linear convergence under the stated assumptions once the reference and algorithm parameters are fixed. This provides an explicit convergence guarantee while allowing flexibility in the neural weight predictor.
-
The method gives competitive results across deblurring, superresolution, and MRI. Compared with NECTR, the average PSNR improves by 0.78 to 0.85 dB for deblurring and 0.58 dB for superresolution. These results support the practical value of the complete method.
Critical weaknesses
-
The claimed advantages over NECTR are not fully established. The paper suggests that NECTR requires positive semidefiniteness, but NECTR's convergence analysis already permits negative eigenvalues. After computing the degrees, NECTR can also accumulate the normalized operator output and its row sums in the same pass, using the same type of combined accumulation as Metro-SSD. The stated two-pass versus three-pass comparison therefore does not establish an inherent computational advantage.
-
The experiments do not isolate the contribution of Metropolis normalization. The implementation combines a DRUNet-based attention predictor, direct training of the normalized denoiser, and a modified warm-up procedure. The ablations examine warm-up choices, but do not compare the two normalizations with the same predictor, training, and reconstruction settings. Therefore, the gains over NECTR support the complete method, while it remains unclear how much of the improvement comes from the proposed normalization.
Questions for authors
-
What is the precise difference between the admissible denoiser classes of Metro-SSD and NECTR?
-
How do runtime and memory usage compare when both methods use the same fusion and caching strategy?
-
Can the authors compare the two normalizations with the predictor, training, and warm-up settings held fixed to clarify the source of the reconstruction gains?
-
For the channelwise implementation, how does the convergence analysis exclude nonzero images that are constant within each channel but produce zero measurements? Explain how the RGB and complex MRI representations satisfy the required condition.
3 comments
Thank you for the additional experiments and clarifications. The new ablations indicate that most gains over the original NECTR come from the predictor and direct training. With these choices matched, Metro-SSD and NECTR show similar reconstruction quality and runtime. The explanation of the multichannel condition is also helpful. However, the authors acknowledge that the normalization does not broaden the admissible denoiser class, and I still find the contribution beyond NECTR limited. I will maintain my assessment.
Thank you for considering the additional experiments and clarifications. The feedback helped us strengthen the comparisons with NECTR and clarify the sources of improvement in reconstruction.
(C1) Ablation of normalization and training. Appendix E.3.1 compares three variants using the same DRUNet-based attention predictor architecture, alongside NECTR-Proj with the original predictor:
NECTR-Proj versus NECTR-Attn evaluates the predictor change while retaining the normalization protocol. NECTR-Attn versus NECTR-Attn-Tr compares post-hoc and direct training while retaining NECTR normalization at reconstruction. NECTR-Attn-Tr versus Metro-SSD compares the two normalizations when each is used during both training and reconstruction.
The mean PSNR values below use the same test sets and task-level reconstruction settings within each row: PnP-HQS on CBSD10 and PnP-DRS on the first ten knee MRI test images for each reported setting. Appendix E.2 studies warm-up separately.
The attention predictor improves over NECTR-Proj in six settings and ties in the seventh. Direct NECTR training improves over post-hoc normalization by 0.27–0.85 dB across the five deblurring/SR settings and by 0.22 dB on multi-coil MRI, with a 0.06 dB decrease on single-coil MRI. Metro-SSD and NECTR-Attn-Tr remain within 0.13 dB across all seven settings.
These results clarify that the predictor and direct training contribute substantially to reconstruction quality. We believe the reconstruction gains come primarily from the new attention backbone and from using the same operator for denoising during training and for regularization during reconstruction.
(C2) Admissible denoisers and PSD. As clarified in (A1), NECTR admits negative eigenvalues. Our intended point was that its normalization preserves PSD when present, although PSD is neither guaranteed for the learned operator nor required for convergence. We will correct this discussion.
At the normalization level, both methods take a symmetric nonnegative matrix K with positive row sums and produce a symmetric nonnegative stochastic matrix W. Their maps have the same range but can produce different outputs from the same input K. Both return W=K when K is already stochastic. We therefore do not claim a broader admissible matrix class.
(C3) We thank the reviewer for suggesting this optimization. We implemented the fused accumulation for NECTR and repeated the comparison under matched caching policies. The two methods have essentially identical reconstruction costs: NECTR-Attn-Tr/Metro-SSD take 1.620/1.613 s for deblurring, 1.625/1.615 s for SR, and 39.83/39.82 s for MRI. Peak training and cache memory are comparable. We will revise the manuscript acordingly.
(C4) Channel constants and MRI. The required multichannel condition is kerA∩C={0}, where C is the space of channelwise constant images. For RGB deblurring and SR, both operators act channelwise, so this reduces to Ace=0 for every channel c. Applying the single-channel theorem to each block gives a full contraction factor maxcqc<1. For complex MRI, the proof extends using the Hermitian adjoint and complex Euclidean norm; retaining the real part preserves contractivity. Our response (A2) to Reviewer kY3z gives the detailed argument. We will incorporate these clarifications into the manuscript.
Summary