acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

MIAT-RPCA: Training-Free Robust PCA via Manifold-Inspired Interpolation and Adaptive Truncation

Abstract

Thresholding-based robust principal component analysis (RPCA) separates sparse corruption from low-rank structure. In basic CUR updates, this process does not explicitly exploit local coefficient neighborhoods to refine corrupted observations. Yet observations affected by different corruption levels may retain shared structure that can support mutual refinement. Using this information requires considering both reconstruction inconsistency and neighborhood agreement. Motivated by this observation, we propose Manifold-Inspired Interpolation and Adaptive Truncation for RPCA (MIAT-RPCA), a training-free method that incorporates neighborhood information into sampled CUR recovery. Cosine similarities define local neighborhoods in coefficient space. A quantile-normalized residual score controls interpolation strength, allowing columns with greater reconstruction inconsistency to draw more heavily on neighboring coefficients. A complementary attenuation gate combines this score with neighborhood confidence, applying stronger suppression when inconsistency is high and neighborhood agreement is low. Both operations precede reconstruction and keep the corrected coefficients within their original span. We establish that the correction preserves the target rank bound and satisfies a neighborhood norm bound, characterize the gates' monotonic responses, and analyze the computational cost per iteration. All neighborhood weights and gates are computed from the current observation, with a prescribed threshold schedule and no training data or parameter learning.

Primary area:
optimization
Keywords:
robust principal component analysis, CUR decomposition, manifold-inspired interpolation, adaptive truncation, image restoration, background separation.

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 4 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_qrE7OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a robust principal component analysis method. The approach is predicated on the idea that a shared structure is preserved across varying levels of corruption. Furthermore, the experimental validation is inadequate, featuring a limited number of baseline methods and datasets.

Critical strengths
  1. This method is a training-free algorithm that requires no additional training data or complex parameter learning processes.

  2. This study not only proposes an algorithm but also provides theoretical analysis, mathematically proving that its coefficient correction step can effectively maintain the target rank bound and satisfy the neighborhood norm bound.

Critical weaknesses

1.The paper's premise is based on preserving shared structures at different corruption levels, but the paper does not prove this premise at all. This fundamentally calls into question the validity of the proposed method.

2.The experiments are limited and lack ablation studies, making it impossible to verify the utility of the individual design components. Furthermore, the authors state that the experimental data are drawn from "prior experimental records," and the data presented in Table 1 are questionable; these factors further undermine the credibility of the paper.

Questions for authors

1.The author should provide a clearer explanation of the source of the experimental data. Given that the number of decimal places varies across the values presented in the tables, it is unclear whether these values were measured under different conditions.

2.Could the authors provide verification for the core premise?

3.The experiments are limited and lack ablation studies, making it impossible to verify the utility of the individual design components.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qrE7

Thank you for asking how the values in Table 1 were obtained and what evidence supports the shared-structure premise. We addressed the reporting error and tested two distinct questions: whether damaged observations retain information about their neighbors, and whether using those neighbors improves recovery.

Q1. Source and precision of Table 1

In the submitted MIAT-RPCA row at ρ = 0.5, the best PSNR (24.76 dB) and best SSIM (0.91) came from different experimental batches. Presenting these entries as one benchmark row was our error. We withdraw that ranking. Revised Table 1 (p. 5) reports matched runs of Algorithm 1 with the prescribed thresholds and correction at every iteration. All four metrics come from the same unrounded RGB reconstructions in each run. For each metric we average the six frames in its damage group, then the five paired solver seeds. Deterministic IALM runs once per input. Decimal precision is fixed within each metric column for display. Per-frame records are in matched/raw/retina/, and Appendix B gives a worked example.

Q2. Do observations at different damage levels retain identifiable shared structure?

We directly checked the neighbors chosen at the first iteration on the eight held-out natural images in natural_images/. Each image provided distinct, overlapping views of six regions. For a query crop with nominal corruption 0.5, we looked at its selected neighbors from the 0.3 group and asked how often they came from the same original region. The solver saw neither the region labels nor the damage labels. Each region contributed four of the 24 milder crops, so a uniformly sampled milder neighbor has a 16.7% chance of coming from the query's region.

With positive pixel corruption plus blocks, 26.5% of these cross-damage neighbors came from the same region, above chance on all eight images. With salt-and-pepper corruption, the corresponding fraction was 21.5%, above chance on seven of eight. These are first-iteration, post hoc diagnostics on the existing test inputs, averaged over the paired solver seeds and corruption draws and then over images. They show that observed coefficients can identify shared local content across damage levels in this overlapping-view setting. Per-image results and the diagnostic script are in cross_damage/.

Finding related neighbors and improving the final estimate are separate empirical questions. Under positive corruption plus blocks, full MIAT recovered the severe group at 18.09 dB versus 15.21 dB for validation-selected fixed averaging, a gain on all eight images. Under salt and pepper the corresponding values were 17.27 and 18.09 dB. Thus detectable cross-damage structure alone does not determine which weighting rule recovers the signal best. Proposition 1 establishes the rank and norm properties of one update. We use these experiments to assess the shared-structure premise empirically.

Q3. Which components account for the gain?

In a separate rank-by-size experiment we held the CUR backbone, sampling draws, threshold schedule, temperature and iteration budget fixed. Across 36 matrices with recurring but nonidentical templates, the mean relative error on the more severely damaged columns was 0.415 with correction off, 0.365 with attenuation alone, 0.272 with fixed mixing, 0.249 with interpolation alone and 0.239 with full MIAT (lower is better). Interpolation accounts for most of the improvement. The coupled update reduced error relative to correction off on all 36 matrices and had the lowest CUR mean in five of six rank-size settings. Attenuation alone led in the remaining setting. All settings are in rank_size/. In an earlier eight-pair rank-three control, stronger clustering improved the full update relative to correction off in every pair, yet fixed mixing still had lower mean error in the clustered condition (0.230 vs. 0.249).

On the three fresh retinal corruption draws (Table 2, p. 6), the shared-temperature comparison at ρ = 0.5 gave 13.96 dB with correction off, 14.81 with attenuation alone, 15.35 with interpolation alone, 16.27 with fixed mixing and 17.47 with full MIAT. At ρ = 0.3, correction off reached 24.72 dB versus 13.89 for full MIAT. Together these comparisons locate the benefit in the more damaged observations of the tested settings and quantify what each component adds.

I appreciate the authors' clarifications and additional experiments. However, concerns remain regarding the reliability of the original experimental results and the inconsistent improvements across corruption levels. These issues still limit my confidence in the conclusions, so I will maintain my original rating of 2.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up to Reviewer qrE7 on Result Reliability and Corruption Levels

Thank you for clarifying what still limits your confidence in our conclusions.

Reliability of the results. The submitted MIAT-RPCA row at ρ=0.5\rho=0.5 combined the best PSNR and SSIM from different experimental batches. Reporting them as a single benchmark row was an error, and we have withdrawn the associated ranking. Revised Table 1 reports fresh matched runs of Algorithm 1 at its default settings. All four metrics use the same reconstructions within each run. The supplement provides the per-frame scores and solver seeds, and Appendix B shows how to recompute the mean PSNR from the frame-level errors.

Differences across corruption levels. In those retinal runs, MIAT and correction-off CUR reached 15.74 and 14.11 dB at ρ=0.5\rho=0.5, and 14.14 and 25.02 dB at ρ=0.3\rho=0.3. On all 100 DIV2K validation photographs, we held the algorithm settings fixed across corruption levels. Averaged over two synthetic corruption families, the gain over correction-off CUR was 0.08 dB at ρ=0.3\rho=0.3 and 1.75 dB at ρ=0.5\rho=0.5, with a positive two-family average on 99 of 100 photographs at the higher level (Appendix J). One explanation is that interpolation can help a poor estimate recover signal from informative neighbors. The same mixing can disturb a column that CUR already estimates well. The revised results support a conditional gain over the CUR backbone in these severe synthetic corruption settings.

If the replacement results and this more specific claim improve your confidence in the contribution, we would be grateful if you would reconsider your overall rating.

Reviewer_1wpVOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper adds a coefficient-correction step to sampled-CUR robust PCA. For each column of the coefficient matrix, it computes three quantities: a residual score, a softmax-weighted average of the column's cosine nearest neighbours, and a neighbourhood confidence. It then mixes the column with its neighbour average, more strongly when the residual is high. It shrinks the column when the residual is high and the confidence is low.

Proposition 1 shows that one update keeps the reconstruction at rank at most r and satisfies a norm bound. The experiments are:

  • one retinal image, repeated with synthetic corruption at two levels;
  • qualitative video background separation;
  • one indoor sequence, with metrics and runtimes.
Critical strengths

The correction is simple, training-free and fully specified, and by construction it cannot increase the rank. The paper is also clear that it gives no recovery guarantee across iterations.

Critical weaknesses

The main concern is that the evaluation does not test the proposed correction. There is no comparison with plain sampled CUR (IRCUR, which the paper cites) under the same sampling and thresholds, and no interpolation-only or attenuation-only variant.

The restoration task also favours the method. It repeats a single image many times, so the clean matrix has rank at most three, and averaging over neighbouring columns is denoising by construction. Several further gaps remain:

  • The number of copies, the rank, the number of iterations and the baseline settings are not reported.
  • ScaledGD returns a blank image, which points to a misconfigured baseline.
  • The video results are qualitative only.
  • On the theory side, Proposition 1 follows directly from the update being a right-multiplication of Z and from convex mixing. It is useful bookkeeping rather than a substantive result.

A second concern is whether the indoor comparison in Table 2 is made on matched inputs. The MIAT-RPCA results for the indoor scene in Fig. 5 are shown in grayscale (input frames, L and S). The reference image and all baseline reconstructions in Fig. 6 are in color. Fig. 6 also has no MIAT-RPCA panel, so the methods cannot be compared visually on the same input. The traffic and shopping-mall examples in Fig. 4 are in color, so the grayscale choice appears specific to the indoor sequence.

Table 2 does not state the color mode used for each method, while Sec. 4.1 and Appendix B describe the metrics and the matrix arrangement in terms of RGB frames, with three channel columns per frame. If MIAT-RPCA was run on grayscale and the baselines on RGB, the metrics in Table 2 are not directly comparable. The runtime comparison (0.11 s vs 1.72-98.65 s for the baselines) would also be affected, since the RGB matrix has three times as many columns. Running all methods on the same input, and adding the MIAT-RPCA output to Fig. 6, would make this comparison fair.

Questions for authors
  1. Adding IRCUR with identical sampling and thresholds, plus interpolation-only and attenuation-only variants, would isolate the effect of the correction. Could these results be reported?
  2. Were MIAT-RPCA and the baselines in Table 2 run on the same input, grayscale or RGB? If not, could all methods be rerun on the same input, with the MIAT-RPCA output added to Fig. 6?
  3. What are r, H, the number of copies and the image resolution? How were the baselines configured, and why does ScaledGD fail?
  4. In Table 1 at rho=0.5, MIAT-RPCA has the same MSE, NRMSE and SSIM as LRPCA (0.011, 0.22, 0.91) but a PSNR of 24.76 against 19.61. Every other entry at this level is within 0.3 dB of its MSE-implied PSNR. A per-image MSE distribution would clarify this.
  5. For the timings in Table 2, what hardware and implementation were used, and did all methods use the same stopping rule?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1wpV

Thank you for identifying the discrepancy in Table 1 and asking whether the indoor comparison used matched inputs.

Q4. Table 1 and the research-integrity concern

Footnote 1 and the AI Use Statement identify earlier experimental records as the source of the submitted numbers. We omitted an important detail. For the MIAT-RPCA row at ρ = 0.5, we selected the best PSNR (24.76 dB) and best SSIM (0.91) from different batches. We cannot establish which runs supplied MSE (0.011) and NRMSE (0.22), how many runs were considered, or which configurations produced the selected entries. We take responsibility for presenting them together. We withdraw the Table 1 ranking attributed to Algorithm 1 and will replace the affected comparison with matched runs. We also withdraw the original indoor quality and speed rankings.

At unit data range, 0.011 converts to 19.59 dB, close to LRPCA's 19.61 dB. Averaging PSNR per frame can yield a different value, but the historical per-frame errors are unavailable to verify the 5.15 dB gap. In a new default-setting run (data seed 42, solver seed 101), all four metrics came from the same reconstructions. The six frame MSEs at ρ = 0.5 were 0.01762, 0.06960, 0.09134, 0.06145, 0.01859 and 0.03239. Their mean converts to 13.14 dB. The mean of the six frame PSNRs is 13.97 dB.

Q1. Matched CUR ablation

Disabling correction in our implementation gives the plain sampled-CUR control. All variants shared the same sampling draws, initialization, rank, threshold schedule and iteration budget. The full method searched all coefficient columns and applied correction at every iteration. At the default temperature (0.10), on the first retinal draw at ρ = 0.5, mean PSNR over five seeds was 15.74 dB for the full method, 15.49 for fixed mixing and 14.11 for the uncorrected backbone.

This motivated a post-submission check targeting ρ = 0.5. Each temperature-sensitive variant selected from {0.05, 0.10, 0.20} on two validation draws. Validation selected 0.05 for full MIAT-RPCA and 0.20 for interpolation and fixed mixing. We locked the choices before testing on three fresh corruption draws of the same image, with two paired solver seeds per draw. At ρ = 0.5, mean PSNR was 17.47 dB for full MIAT-RPCA, 16.12 for interpolation only, 15.93 for fixed mixing, 14.81 for attenuation only and 13.96 for the backbone. The full method also had the highest mean SSIM (0.244). Its PSNR gain over interpolation was positive on all three draws after averaging the two seeds. With temperature fixed at 0.05 for all variants that use it, the full method still led (17.47 vs. 16.27 dB for fixed mixing). At ρ = 0.3, the backbone outperformed the full method (24.72 vs. 13.89 dB).

Q2. RGB inputs and background recovery

We cannot verify the color mode for every original Table 2 entry. We reran five CUR variants and IALM on the same 100 HumanBody2 RGB frames (120 × 160) and RGB reference. Mean PSNR was 24.76 dB for full MIAT-RPCA, 24.65 for the backbone and 24.36 for IALM. We will include the matched RGB outputs for frame 717 in the revision.

On two additional disjoint 100-frame samples, we applied the same post-submission color adjustment to all methods, adding the spatial median of the input minus the estimated background in each channel. On pixels where input and reference luma differed by more than 0.10, mean absolute luma error was 0.067 for adjusted MIAT-RPCA and 0.139 for adjusted IALM. MIAT-RPCA had lower error on these changed pixels in both samples. Its error before color adjustment was 0.074. The other adjusted CUR variants were close (0.0667–0.0674). IALM had lower whole-frame chromatic error (2.33 vs. 6.09) and higher SSIM (0.946 vs. 0.879).

Q3. Construction and ScaledGD

The retinal reruns used 12 corrupted copies of one 705 × 705 RGB image, six per corruption level, giving clean rank at most three. CUR used r = 3, H = 20 iterations, K = 10 neighbors and an initial threshold of 1.0 multiplied by 0.7 each iteration. Repetition favors averaging. On three natural-image crops at two impulse rates, the backbone had higher PSNR in all six settings. External IALM used λ = 1/√max(m,n) and reached 26.25 dB on the fresh retinal draws at ρ = 0.5. The original dark ScaledGD panel cannot distinguish a solver failure from a display or configuration issue. We will remove that panel and the comparison based on it.

Q5. Timing

On an Intel Core i7-12700H with four PyTorch CPU threads, we timed the solver call on matched RGB inputs, excluding loading and evaluation. MIAT-RPCA took 0.98 ± 0.11 s over five seeds (20 iterations, float32). IALM took 4.44 s in one float64 run, reaching a relative primal residual below 10⁻⁷ after 37 iterations. The stopping rules differed.

Thanks for the thorough response and for running the matched experiments. The openness about how the original Table 1 row was put together is also appreciated.

The new results answer most of the questions raised in the review. Unfortunately, they also change what the paper can claim.

The matched CUR ablation is the most useful addition. It shows that the correction beats the uncorrected backbone at rho=0.5 (17.47 vs 13.96 dB after temperature selection), and that the full method beats each partial variant. But the picture elsewhere is different. At rho=0.3 the backbone is far ahead (24.72 vs 13.89 dB), and it also wins in all six natural-image settings. A standard IALM reaches 26.25 dB on the same retinal draws at rho=0.5. So the correction seems to help mainly under heavy corruption in the repeated-image setup, which, as the response itself points out, favors averaging.

The indoor reruns tell a similar story. On matched RGB input, the full method, the backbone and IALM are within 0.4 dB of each other. The changed-pixel advantage over IALM is shared by every CUR variant, so it doesn't seem to come from the correction, and it relies on a color adjustment added after submission. IALM also does better on SSIM and on whole-frame color error.

On Table 1, the explanation clears up the PSNR/MSE mismatch. The rho=0.5 row combined values from different batches, and the response withdraws the Table 1 ranking along with the indoor quality and speed rankings, so those results are treated as withdrawn here. The new run gives 13.97 dB at rho=0.5, against the 24.76 dB in the paper.

The new timing (0.98 s vs 4.44 s for IALM) is much more modest than the original 0.11 s vs 57.28 s, and it still compares runs with different precision and stopping rules. It would also help to report how long the backbone alone takes, so the cost of the correction itself is visible.

Given all this, the rating stays the same. This isn't meant to discourage the work, and the matched ablation is a good starting point. A much more convincing version of the paper would:

  • focus on the heavy-corruption setting where the correction helps;
  • report the negative results at rho=0.3 and on natural images alongside the positive ones;
  • use several seeds and corruption draws;
  • compare against well-configured baselines under matched conditions.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up to Reviewer 1wpV: Correction under Heavy Corruption and Its Runtime Cost

Thank you for identifying which claims survive the matched comparisons. We agree that the retinal and indoor results cannot establish general restoration or speed superiority. We revised the main text to ask when column-specific correction helps a sampled CUR solver recover heavily damaged observations from related columns.

Does the gain require copies of one image? We tested the submitted update on 12 new simulated scenes, each with a rank-eight clean matrix of 96 distinct columns. For each clean matrix we crossed three independent corruption draws with three CUR sampling seeds. All CUR variants saw the same damaged matrix, sampled indices, rank and threshold schedule. We fixed the settings before these runs. We averaged the nine paired runs within each scene and used the 12 scene means to estimate uncertainty.

Our prespecified comparison was the severe group under positive corruption with blocks and moderate within-group similarity (λ = 0.5). Full MIAT reached 17.72 dB versus 15.06 for the backbone. The paired gain was 2.66 dB (95% scene-bootstrap interval 2.58–2.74), positive on all 12 scenes and all 108 paired runs. On the mild columns, MIAT reached 17.61 dB versus 21.09 for the backbone. Across all columns the backbone led, 18.08 vs. 17.67 dB. A constant shrinkage tuned on separate data reached 18.81 dB on the severe group. The gain over uncorrected CUR on severely damaged observations therefore extends from repeated images to matrices with distinct columns that share structure.

What does assigning a different correction to each column add? With stronger sharing (λ = 0.95) and the same positive corruption plus blocks, whole-matrix PSNR was 19.04 dB for full MIAT versus 18.00 for validation-selected fixed mixing using the same neighbors and weights. Randomly reassigning the computed gate pairs across columns at each iteration gave 18.31 dB. Both comparisons favored MIAT on all 12 scenes. This is where assigning the update column by column added value within CUR. With salt-and-pepper corruption and no imposed clustering, even the severe group favored the backbone (19.34 vs. 18.98 dB).

Scope of the image and video results. The backbone won all six original disjoint natural-image settings. On 18 further McMaster images with disjoint crops, MIAT gained 2.95 dB over the backbone on severe crops in mixed inputs (15.03 vs. 12.08), but the mild crops favored the backbone (18.74 vs. 15.70). Across all six severity/family conditions MIAT reached 15.39 dB, the backbone 15.63.

Your point about indoor attribution is correct. On the two additional RGB frame samples, before color adjustment the changed-pixel luminance MAE was 0.07366 for MIAT, 0.07412 for the backbone and 0.13902 for IALM. The advantage over IALM was already present in the raw CUR outputs, and the gap between MIAT and its backbone was just 0.00046. We therefore make no correction-specific foreground claim. The original Table 1 ranking and indoor quality and speed rankings remain withdrawn. The 13.97 dB retinal result is the default-temperature, single-draw, single-seed check. The 17.47 dB estimate uses a separately selected temperature, three fresh draws and two seeds per draw.

What does the correction itself cost? On the same 100 HumanBody2 RGB frames, we timed a bare backbone that skips residual scoring and all neighbor computations. Both arms ran 20 float32 iterations on four CPU threads. Across five paired seeds with four counterbalanced timings per seed, median solver times were 0.666 s for the backbone and 0.711 s for full MIAT. The median paired overhead was 43 ms per solve (6.5%). A separate timer inside the scoring and correction block recorded 27 ms over all 20 iterations. Both implementations reproduced their archived reconstructions for every seed. On the same input and threads, float32 IALM took 0.873 s at iteration 20 and 1.599 s to reach a relative primal residual below 1e−5 at iteration 28. Equal iteration counts give a common timing checkpoint, although the algorithms do different work per iteration.

Sections 4.2 and 4.4 put the mild and severe results side by side. Section 4.3 reports the backbone timing. Appendix I gives the controls, and the supplement includes all six simulated conditions, the individual draws and seeds, and the timing records in reviewer_1wpV/.

Reviewer_eZT6OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This work studies robust principal component analysis (RPCA) for image restoration and video background separation. The authors propose MIAT-RPCA, a training-free method that improves sampled CUR recovery by using information from neighborhood coefficient vectors. This method uses cosine similarity to find neighbors, reconstruction errors to control interpolation, and neighborhood confidence to reduce unreliable coefficients. In this paper, the authors provide a theoretical analysis of rank preservation and coefficient bounds. Experiments are reported on corrupted retinal images and several video scenes, with comparisons against existing RPCA methods.

Critical strengths

This paper has several strengths. First, the problem is meaningful, as recovering clean images and separating background information from corrupted observations are important tasks in computer vision. Second, using neighborhood information to improve reconstruction is reasonable. This method combines reconstruction errors with agreement among nearby coefficients, which may help when some observations are heavily corrupted. Third, this method does not require training data or pretrained models, making it potentially useful when training data is limited.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The novelty of the proposed method is not clear. The method appears to combine existing CUR recovery with neighborhood interpolation, residual-based weighting, and adaptive coefficient attenuation. These components are related to existing ideas in robust PCA and image restoration. In particular, this work does not explicitly model a data manifold. The authors should explain what is fundamentally new and how the proposed method differs from simple combinations of existing techniques.

  2. The experimental evidence for image restoration is not convincing. Although this paper reports quantitative results using MSE, PSNR, and SSIM, the proposed method does not consistently outperform the baselines in Table 1. The visual comparisons are also limited, especially for fine image details. The authors should provide more direct visual comparisons, additional quantitative experiments, and a more detailed runtime analysis.

  3. The parameter selection needs more explanation. The proposed method uses several hyperparameters, including neighborhood size, similarity temperature, interpolation weights, and attenuation strength. Although the authors provide default values, it is unclear how these values were selected and whether they work consistently across different datasets and corruption levels. The method is training-free, but this does not mean it is free from parameter tuning. A parameter sensitivity study would help demonstrate its robustness.

  4. The experimental datasets are limited. The image restoration experiments focus on retinal images with synthetic corruption. Appendix B also describes a repeated-image construction with rank at most three, which may simplify the recovery problem. This work does not provide sufficient evidence that the method generalizes to more diverse natural images or complex real-world corruption. Evaluations on broader image restoration datasets and more challenging settings would strengthen the paper.

Questions for authors
  1. The footnote in Section 4.1 states that the experimental results have not been verified for the current algorithm. Can the authors clarify which implementation produced these results?

  2. How much improvement comes from neighborhood interpolation, and how much comes from adaptive attenuation? Is it possible for a simple method using standard CUR with fixed neighbor averaging to achieve similar results?

  3. Why is the proposed method evaluated using a repeated-image construction with rank at most three? How does it perform on different real images, more complex image content, and other types of corruption?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer eZT6

Thank you for asking whether fixed neighbor averaging would suffice and whether the retinal result extends beyond copies of one image. We tested both questions on eight held-out natural images. On severely damaged crops with positive pixel corruption and added blocks, full MIAT-RPCA gained 2.88 dB over validation-selected fixed averaging, with a gain on every image. Under salt-and-pepper corruption, fixed averaging led by 0.82 dB.

Q1. Which implementation produced the reported results?

The submitted Table 1 drew on earlier experimental records. In its MIAT-RPCA row at ρ = 0.5, the reported best PSNR (24.76 dB) and best SSIM (0.91) came from different batches. Presenting them as one benchmark row was our error. We withdraw the original ranking. Revised Table 1 (p. 5) reports new runs of Algorithm 1 with the prescribed threshold schedule and coefficient correction at every iteration. All four metrics come from the same reconstructions within each run. The supplement includes the implementation, source hashes, settings and per-frame scores.

Q2. What does adaptive correction add to simple averaging?

At each CUR update, a column with a large reconstruction residual borrows more from its neighbors. When those neighbors agree, the method largely retains the mixed coefficient. When they disagree, the same residual increases attenuation. “Manifold-inspired” refers to local cosine neighborhoods in coefficient space. The method fits no explicit manifold.

To isolate the components, we reanalyzed the three fresh retinal corruption draws in Table 2 (p. 6), using the same temperature of 0.05 for all temperature-sensitive variants. At ρ = 0.5, mean PSNR was 13.96 dB with correction off, 14.81 with attenuation alone, 15.35 with interpolation alone, 16.27 with fixed mixing and 17.47 with the full correction. At ρ = 0.3, full MIAT gave 13.89 dB versus 24.72 with correction off. On this image, the benefit was specific to the more heavily damaged observations.

Q3. Does the benefit extend to different images and corruption types?

Repeating one retinal image gave us a clean reference of rank at most three and held anatomy fixed across corruption draws. It also supplied neighbors by construction. For the new test, we extracted 48 distinct, overlapping grayscale crops from six regions of each photograph or texture. All eight clean matrices had rank 48, and CUR used working rank 8. We restored crops with nominal corruption rates of 0.3 and 0.5 together. We selected settings on two separate validation images before testing. For each test image, we averaged over three corruption draws and two paired CUR seeds, then weighted the eight images equally.

Mean PSNR (dB) on severely damaged crops:

CorruptionCUR offSelected fixedUniform (β = 0.3)Full MIATIALM
Positive pixels + blocks11.0015.2116.2518.0919.33
Salt and pepper12.3718.0919.3317.2722.20

Across both corruption types, full MIAT exceeded the validation-selected fixed control by 1.03 dB (17.68 vs. 16.65). The prespecified uniform control at β = 0.3 reached 17.79 dB overall. Under positive corruption plus blocks, full MIAT exceeded both fixed controls in PSNR and improved mean SSIM from 0.157 for the selected control to 0.207. Even with the temperature transferred from the retinal experiment, full MIAT reached 17.25 dB under this corruption. Under salt and pepper, stronger uniform averaging worked better.

These results concern overlapping local views under synthetic corruption. In the earlier disjoint-tile experiment, uncorrected CUR led full MIAT in all six settings (Appendix B). The supplement provides every image-level result and a prespecified camera crop with the same detail zoom for all methods (natural_images/).

Parameter selection

On the two validation images, we selected the full method's temperature from {0.05, 0.10, 0.20}. Fixed-control candidates included correction off and either uniform or softmax averaging at mixing fractions of 0.1, 0.3, 0.5 or 1.0. Validation selected a temperature of 0.20 for full MIAT and uniform averaging at β = 0.1. We used these settings for both corruption types and all eight test images. Retaining the retinal temperature of 0.05 gave 16.17 dB overall, compared with 17.68 dB after validation. We held K = 10, the mixing bounds [0.1, 0.5] and the attenuation exponent 2 fixed. In a separate HumanBody2 check, varying these settings and temperature one at a time changed mean PSNR by −0.25 to +0.07 dB over three paired seeds.

Reviewer_FfGAOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes MIAT-RPCA, a training-free extension of sampled CUR-based robust PCA. It combines residual-guided neighborhood interpolation with confidence-modulated attenuation to refine coefficient representations. The paper establishes rank preservation and a neighborhood norm bound for a single correction step, and analyzes computational cost. The experimental section reports results on retinal image restoration and video background separation, with comparisons against several RPCA baselines.

Critical strengths

The proposed correction is simple and interpretable. It uses reconstruction residuals and neighborhood agreement to determine how observations should be refined, providing a plausible way to exploit shared structure without training. The structural analysis also confirms that the correction preserves the target rank bound.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The methodological contribution appears incremental, and its added value is not sufficiently demonstrated. The main addition is the coupling of neighborhood interpolation and adaptive attenuation within an existing CUR framework. However, the paper reports no ablation studies or controlled comparisons that isolate these components on the same CUR backbone. It therefore remains unclear how much each component contributes and whether their combination provides additional benefits. The rank and norm properties alone do not establish improved recovery.
  2. The evaluation lacks a systematic analysis across different problem settings. Although results are reported at two corruption levels, it remains unclear how recovery accuracy and runtime change with the underlying matrix rank and matrix size. Reporting variation across repeated runs would also help assess the stability of the observed gains.
Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors provide ablations on the same CUR backbone to clarify the contributions of interpolation, attenuation, and their combination?
  2. Could the authors examine performance across different underlying matrix ranks and matrix sizes, and report variability across repeated runs?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FfGA

Thank you for asking how much each correction contributes and whether the result persists as rank and size change. The clearest finding is on the more severely corrupted observations. On fresh retinal corruption draws the full update gained 3.51 dB over its own backbone in that subgroup. In a new rank-by-size simulation with recurring image structure, it reduced the corresponding recovery error on all 36 paired matrices.

Q1. Which component helps heavily corrupted observations?

Our starting point in the submitted paper was that observations at different damage levels can retain shared structure. The correction is designed to help most where the current estimate is unreliable. Algorithm 1 uses a column's reconstruction residual to decide how much to borrow from neighboring coefficients. A large residual gives neighbors more weight. If the neighbors also disagree, the update attenuates the mixed coefficient. These decisions are made at each iteration without knowing the true corruption rate.

Table 1 (p. 5) holds the sampling draws, rank, threshold schedule and iteration count fixed. At nominal ρ = 0.5, mean PSNR over five solver seeds was 14.11 dB with correction off, 14.59 with attenuation alone, 15.20 with interpolation alone, 15.49 with fixed mixing, and 15.74 with both adaptive components. Fixed mixing had slightly higher SSIM on this draw (0.220 vs. 0.217).

After selecting temperatures on two separate validation draws targeting ρ = 0.5, we tested three fresh corruption draws of the same retinal image. Full MIAT-RPCA reached 17.47 ± 0.87 dB, compared with 13.96 for correction off and 16.12 for the strongest CUR control, interpolation alone (Table 2, p. 6). SD is across draws after averaging two paired solver seeds per draw. When all temperature-sensitive variants shared t = 0.05, full MIAT reached 17.47 dB, fixed mixing 16.27 and interpolation alone 15.35. External IALM reached 26.25 dB. At ρ = 0.3, full MIAT gave 13.89 dB versus 24.72 with correction off. Even a low-residual column retains a minimum mixing weight of 0.1. On the default draw, interpolation alone already showed nearly the entire lower-corruption loss (14.05 vs. 14.14 dB for full MIAT). This is consistent with unnecessary mixing of cleaner estimates. It also identifies where a more selective correction could help.

Q2. What changes with rank and matrix size?

We fixed a factorial experiment before running it. Each clean matrix mixes r smooth templates into recurring, nonidentical columns. Within each template group, half the columns receive nominal 0.30 and half 0.50 entrywise corruption, plus positive blocks. All methods see the same mixed matrix. Only evaluation uses the subgroup labels. For each size and true rank we generated six independent matrices and paired two CUR solver seeds per matrix. We kept t = 0.05, the other published gate settings and the 20-iteration budget fixed. The primary measure was relative Frobenius error on the 0.50 subgroup (lower is better).

MatrixRankCorrection offFull MIAT ± SDFull time (s)
1024 × 4820.3820.211 ± 0.0160.091
1024 × 4840.4560.280 ± 0.0130.120
1024 × 4880.5680.348 ± 0.0570.124
4096 × 9620.3120.168 ± 0.0080.273
4096 × 9640.3420.180 ± 0.0060.257
4096 × 9680.4290.249 ± 0.0100.552

SD is across matrices after averaging solver seeds. Times cover the whole solver call on one i7-12700H CPU thread. At both sizes, severe-group error rose with rank. At rank 8, increasing the matrix size raised mean runtime from 0.124 to 0.552 s. Across the six equally weighted settings, severe-group error was 0.415 with correction off, 0.365 with attenuation alone, 0.272 with fixed mixing, 0.249 with interpolation alone and 0.239 with full MIAT, a 42% reduction versus correction off. Interpolation accounts for most of this gain. Full MIAT had the lowest CUR mean in five of six settings. At 1024 × 48 and rank 8, attenuation alone led (0.283 vs. 0.348).

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear Reviewers,

Please respond to the authors' rebuttal. Thank you.

Regards,

AC

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.