- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a robust principal component analysis method. The approach is predicated on the idea that a shared structure is preserved across varying levels of corruption. Furthermore, the experimental validation is inadequate, featuring a limited number of baseline methods and datasets.
Critical strengths
-
This method is a training-free algorithm that requires no additional training data or complex parameter learning processes.
-
This study not only proposes an algorithm but also provides theoretical analysis, mathematically proving that its coefficient correction step can effectively maintain the target rank bound and satisfy the neighborhood norm bound.
Critical weaknesses
1.The paper's premise is based on preserving shared structures at different corruption levels, but the paper does not prove this premise at all. This fundamentally calls into question the validity of the proposed method.
2.The experiments are limited and lack ablation studies, making it impossible to verify the utility of the individual design components. Furthermore, the authors state that the experimental data are drawn from "prior experimental records," and the data presented in Table 1 are questionable; these factors further undermine the credibility of the paper.
Questions for authors
1.The author should provide a clearer explanation of the source of the experimental data. Given that the number of decimal places varies across the values presented in the tables, it is unclear whether these values were measured under different conditions.
2.Could the authors provide verification for the core premise?
3.The experiments are limited and lack ablation studies, making it impossible to verify the utility of the individual design components.
3 comments
I appreciate the authors' clarifications and additional experiments. However, concerns remain regarding the reliability of the original experimental results and the inconsistent improvements across corruption levels. These issues still limit my confidence in the conclusions, so I will maintain my original rating of 2.
Follow-up to Reviewer qrE7 on Result Reliability and Corruption Levels
Thank you for clarifying what still limits your confidence in our conclusions.
Reliability of the results. The submitted MIAT-RPCA row at combined the best PSNR and SSIM from different experimental batches. Reporting them as a single benchmark row was an error, and we have withdrawn the associated ranking. Revised Table 1 reports fresh matched runs of Algorithm 1 at its default settings. All four metrics use the same reconstructions within each run. The supplement provides the per-frame scores and solver seeds, and Appendix B shows how to recompute the mean PSNR from the frame-level errors.
Differences across corruption levels. In those retinal runs, MIAT and correction-off CUR reached 15.74 and 14.11 dB at , and 14.14 and 25.02 dB at . On all 100 DIV2K validation photographs, we held the algorithm settings fixed across corruption levels. Averaged over two synthetic corruption families, the gain over correction-off CUR was 0.08 dB at and 1.75 dB at , with a positive two-family average on 99 of 100 photographs at the higher level (Appendix J). One explanation is that interpolation can help a poor estimate recover signal from informative neighbors. The same mixing can disturb a column that CUR already estimates well. The revised results support a conditional gain over the CUR backbone in these severe synthetic corruption settings.
If the replacement results and this more specific claim improve your confidence in the contribution, we would be grateful if you would reconsider your overall rating.
Response to Reviewer qrE7
Thank you for asking how the values in Table 1 were obtained and what evidence supports the shared-structure premise. We addressed the reporting error and tested two distinct questions: whether damaged observations retain information about their neighbors, and whether using those neighbors improves recovery.
Q1. Source and precision of Table 1
In the submitted MIAT-RPCA row at ρ = 0.5, the best PSNR (24.76 dB) and best SSIM (0.91) came from different experimental batches. Presenting these entries as one benchmark row was our error. We withdraw that ranking. Revised Table 1 (p. 5) reports matched runs of Algorithm 1 with the prescribed thresholds and correction at every iteration. All four metrics come from the same unrounded RGB reconstructions in each run. For each metric we average the six frames in its damage group, then the five paired solver seeds. Deterministic IALM runs once per input. Decimal precision is fixed within each metric column for display. Per-frame records are in matched/raw/retina/, and Appendix B gives a worked example.
Q2. Do observations at different damage levels retain identifiable shared structure?
We directly checked the neighbors chosen at the first iteration on the eight held-out natural images in natural_images/. Each image provided distinct, overlapping views of six regions. For a query crop with nominal corruption 0.5, we looked at its selected neighbors from the 0.3 group and asked how often they came from the same original region. The solver saw neither the region labels nor the damage labels. Each region contributed four of the 24 milder crops, so a uniformly sampled milder neighbor has a 16.7% chance of coming from the query's region.
With positive pixel corruption plus blocks, 26.5% of these cross-damage neighbors came from the same region, above chance on all eight images. With salt-and-pepper corruption, the corresponding fraction was 21.5%, above chance on seven of eight. These are first-iteration, post hoc diagnostics on the existing test inputs, averaged over the paired solver seeds and corruption draws and then over images. They show that observed coefficients can identify shared local content across damage levels in this overlapping-view setting. Per-image results and the diagnostic script are in cross_damage/.
Finding related neighbors and improving the final estimate are separate empirical questions. Under positive corruption plus blocks, full MIAT recovered the severe group at 18.09 dB versus 15.21 dB for validation-selected fixed averaging, a gain on all eight images. Under salt and pepper the corresponding values were 17.27 and 18.09 dB. Thus detectable cross-damage structure alone does not determine which weighting rule recovers the signal best. Proposition 1 establishes the rank and norm properties of one update. We use these experiments to assess the shared-structure premise empirically.
Q3. Which components account for the gain?
In a separate rank-by-size experiment we held the CUR backbone, sampling draws, threshold schedule, temperature and iteration budget fixed. Across 36 matrices with recurring but nonidentical templates, the mean relative error on the more severely damaged columns was 0.415 with correction off, 0.365 with attenuation alone, 0.272 with fixed mixing, 0.249 with interpolation alone and 0.239 with full MIAT (lower is better). Interpolation accounts for most of the improvement. The coupled update reduced error relative to correction off on all 36 matrices and had the lowest CUR mean in five of six rank-size settings. Attenuation alone led in the remaining setting. All settings are in rank_size/. In an earlier eight-pair rank-three control, stronger clustering improved the full update relative to correction off in every pair, yet fixed mixing still had lower mean error in the clustered condition (0.230 vs. 0.249).
On the three fresh retinal corruption draws (Table 2, p. 6), the shared-temperature comparison at ρ = 0.5 gave 13.96 dB with correction off, 14.81 with attenuation alone, 15.35 with interpolation alone, 16.27 with fixed mixing and 17.47 with full MIAT. At ρ = 0.3, correction off reached 24.72 dB versus 13.89 for full MIAT. Together these comparisons locate the benefit in the more damaged observations of the tested settings and quantify what each component adds.