- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates hyperspectral imaging, Rather then employing shared scalar penalties to coordinate learned priors, the authors introduce directional positive-definite metric consensus, which enables direction-specific spectral–spatial prior allocation and admits a closed-form image update.
Critical strengths
-
This is an interesting task, different from traditional Cassi. The paper identifies specific challenges in hyperspectral imaging and highlights the limitations of existing methods.
-
The proposed positive-definite-metric-based framework for time-modulated hyperspectral imaging is conceptually novel and offers good interpretability.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient Validation of Functional Complementarity. The functional complementarity among the components within the TCSS module has not been adequately validated. The ablation study in Table 2 only demonstrates the cumulative performance gains obtained by progressively introducing additional components, but lacks a thorough analysis of their individual contributions and potential functional redundancy.
-
The effectiveness of the proposed directional metric design is not sufficiently supported by the experimental results. The paper emphasizes calibration-derived directional positive-definite metrics as its central contribution. However, Table A.8 shows that Generated-V performs worse than both Generated-Scalar and Shuffled-V in terms of mean SAM and MPSNR on unseen response sets. Particularly, Shuffled-V achieves better reconstruction performance despite disrupting the correspondence between singular-value features and spectral directions. These results raise questions about whether the performance improvements primarily originate from calibration-conditioned metric generation rather than the proposed direction-specific prior coordination. Further controlled experiments and direction-wise reconstruction error analysis would help establish the necessity and effectiveness of the directional metric design.
Questions for authors
-
In Table 3(a) and Table A.8, Generated-V does not consistently outperform Generated-Scalar. Could the authors clarify what specific advantages the proposed direction-dependent metric provides over the simpler calibration-conditioned scalar metric?
-
Validation of the proposed mechanism: The paper argues that directional metrics address nonuniform measurement sensitivity. Could the authors provide further evidence, such as reconstruction errors along different singular-vector directions, to demonstrate that the proposed method specifically improves reconstruction in low-sensitivity spectral directions?
-
Why is the font so small in the figures?? I can't see what you want to convey at all. This is not a qualified paper. Also, why aren't the network and visualization results using 1\linewidth? The difference is not visible at all. Also, please don't adjust the paper spacing and layout format arbitrarily.
-
Why is the unfolding comparison only presented in 5 stages, and what about the results of 7 and 9 stages? Such a comparison is not convincing, and it also lacks some SOTA method such as Mijun, Lade-DUN, etc