- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses low-bit-rate lossy hyperspectral image compression. A lightweight convolutional encoder with a sigmoid activation maps the input into a compact latent that is uniformly quantized to b bits. On the decoder side, reconstruction is formulated as an optimization problem with a quantization-consistency fidelity term and multi-prior regularization, and is unrolled into nine stages. Each stage alternates a quantization-consistency module, which re-encodes the current estimate, projects it onto the feasible quantization interval, and back-projects only the interval violation, with a multi-prior refinement network. Experiments on AVIRIS, WHU-Hi, and geographically unseen AVIRIS regions evaluate spatial and spectral reconstruction fidelity.
Critical strengths
-
Treating each quantized value as a feasible interval rather than a single target, and correcting only interval violations inside an unrolled decoder, is a principled way to exploit compression constraints during reconstruction, while keeping the onboard encoder very light. This is the paper's key idea, and it fits the airborne setting well.
-
The empirical gains are consistent across settings. QuHIC outperforms the strongest baseline, BTC-Net V2, on all five AVIRIS scenes at 32 bits; at 8 bits it improves the average PSNR by 1.04 dB with lower SAM; it remains better at every bit depth from 8 down to 4 bits, with the margin growing to 1.81 dB at 4 bits; and it also leads on WHU-Hi and the unseen regions.
Critical weaknesses
-
The independent contribution of QCM is not isolated. In Table 3, A0 is a back-projection-only baseline, and A1 adds the multi-stage unrolled decoder and QCM together, so the gain from decoder capacity cannot be separated from the gain from the interval constraint. Since QCM is the main conceptual contribution, an ablation on the full model is needed to support the central claim.
-
The comparison conditions are not fully matched. The decoder costs 876.53 GFLOPs, about 1.55 times BTC-Net V2 and 7.2 times CTCSN, while the margin over BTC-Net V2 is about 1 dB, so part of the gain may come from additional computation. In addition, bit rates are computed from the latent bit width rather than from the actual Huffman bitstream, and the cross-region and WHU-Hi results are reported only with 32-bit latents, so they do not directly test the low-bit-rate claim.
Questions for authors
-
On the full model, how does performance compare among (a) removing QCM, (b) back-projecting the residual to the codeword center, and (c) the proposed interval residual?
-
Could you report a comparison at matched decoding computation, or an ablation on the number of unrolling stages?
-
What are the actual Huffman bitstream sizes, including side information, for QuHIC and the baselines? Are cross-region results available at low bit depths?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer Cptx (2/3)
R2: Computational trade-off
W2 & Q2: Could you report a comparison at matched decoding computation, or an ablation on the number of unrolling stages?
Response: We appreciate your careful observation and helpful feedback. To clarify the trade-off, we have evaluated additional five- and seven-stage variants and separately profiled the encoder and decoder.
1.Reconstruction quality vs unrolling depth: We evaluate the five-, seven-, and nine-stage variants under the same 32-bit setting, keeping the encoder architecture and latent representation size unchanged.
Tab. 3. Complexity and reconstruction quality under the 32-bit setting.
| Model | Stages | Params (M) | FLOPs (G) | PSNR (dB) ↑ | RMSE ↓ | SAM (°) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BTC-Net V2 | - | 12.550 | 565.03 | 41.39 | 48.36 | 1.574 |
| QuHIC | 5 | 6.712 | 495.05 | 41.82 | 46.01 | 1.462 |
| QuHIC | 7 | 9.234 | 692.40 | 42.11 | 45.03 | 1.416 |
| QuHIC | 9 | 11.580 | 876.53 | 42.59 | 42.88 | 1.353 |
Compared with 32-bit BTC-Net V2, five-stage QuHIC uses 46.5% fewer parameters and 12.4% fewer FLOPs, while improving PSNR by 0.43 dB and achieving lower RMSE and SAM. The seven-stage variant reaches 42.11 dB with an intermediate computational cost, while the full nine-stage model achieves the highest reconstruction quality. These results provide alternatives for different reconstruction budgets.
2.Separate encoder and decoder costs: The encoder has the same complexity across all stage configurations: 0.204 M parameters and 1.674 G FLOPs. The decoder is provided below:
Tab. 4. Separate encoder and decoder network complexity.
| Stages | Encoder Params (M) | Decoder Params (M) | Encoder FLOPs (G) | Decoder FLOPs (G) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 0.204 | 6.508 | 1.674 | 493.375 |
| 7 | 0.204 | 9.030 | 1.674 | 690.724 |
| 9 | 0.204 | 11.376 | 1.674 | 874.853 |
Increasing the unrolling depth adds computation to the reconstruction decoder while leaving the encoding cost unchanged. This reflects our intended deployment design: lightweight neural encoding at the acquisition side and more intensive reconstruction at the ground side.
Manuscript revisions: We have added the five- and seven-stage 32-bit results to Table 1, with the corresponding discussion on p. 7 (Line 377) and p. 8 (Line 418). Their reconstruction visualizations are included in Figure 10, and the encoder–decoder complexity breakdown and corresponding analysis are provided in Table 7 and Appendix D.9 on p. 21 (Lines 1099–1104).
Response to Reviewer Cptx (3/3)
R3: Actual Huffman Bitstream
W2 & Q3: What are the actual Huffman bitstream sizes, including side information, for QuHIC and the baselines?
Response: We sincerely apologize for the unclear distinction between fixed-length and actual bitstream bitrates. We clarify the details below:
1.Full-bitstream bitrate: For QuHIC, we measure the complete bitstream size from the actual encoded files, including the Huffman-coded payload, side information required for decoding, and byte-alignment padding. For the HSI with dimensions , let denote the total size of the complete bitstream in bytes. The resulting bitrate is bpppb. Huffman coding losslessly recovers the quantized symbols and therefore does not alter the quantized representation supplied to the reconstruction network or the corresponding reconstruction metrics. The updated QuHIC results for the 8-, 7-, and 6-bit settings are listed below, together with the available 8-bit result of BTC-Net V2, which also supports low-bit quantization. The remaining baselines use 32-bit floating-point representations with an uncoded representation bitrate of 0.314 bpppb:
Tab. 5. Bitstream sizes and bitrates.
| Method | Quantization bit depth | Complete bitstream size (bytes) | Bitrate (bpppb) |
|---|---|---|---|
| QuHIC | 8 bit | 91803 | 0.065 |
| QuHIC | 7 bit | 79594 | 0.056 |
| QuHIC | 6 bit | 69242 | 0.049 |
| BTC-Net V2 | 8 bit | 90193 | 0.064 |
2.Role of the 32-bit setting and comparison protocol: The 32-bit setting retains the floating-point latent representation to compare reconstruction capabilities with other floating-point baselines without introducing low-bit uniform quantization. We therefore did not further evaluate the Huffman coding gains for floating-point byte streams. For the low-bit settings, we report the actual bitrate of the complete Huffman-coded bitstream. Thus, the 32-bit results characterize reconstruction performance with a high-precision representation, while the low-bit results evaluate practical compression efficiency.
3.Bitrate Comparison: We have additionally included rate–distortion curves comparing QuHIC with BTC-Net V2, which also supports low-bit quantization. As shown in Figure 5 of the revised manuscript, the curves indicate that QuHIC generally achieves higher PSNR and lower RMSE and SAM at the same bitrate, supporting its better rate–distortion performance.
Manuscript revisions: We have updated the bitrates and comparison statements in Table 1 and in Sec. 4.1 on p. 7 (Lines 373–377). We have added the bitrate computation in Appendix D.4 on p. 17 (Lines 916–917) and p. 18 (Lines 930–949), with the complete-bitstream bitrate formula in Eq. 22 on p. 18 (Lines 945–946). The rate–distortion curves have been added in Figure 5, with the corresponding discussion in Sec. 4.2 on p.8 (Line 481), and p. 9 (Lines 468–470).
R4: Low-bit evaluation on WHU-Hi and unseen AVIRIS
W2 & Q3: Are cross-region results available at low bit depths?
Response: We appreciate this helpful suggestion. We have extended the WHU-Hi and cross-region evaluations to 8-bit quantization, complementing the original 32-bit results.
Tab. 6. Comparison of 32-bit and 8-bit QuHIC.
| Dataset | Representation | PSNR (dB) ↑ | RMSE ↓ | SAM (°) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WHU-Hi | 32 bit | 31.81 | 0.226 | 4.466 |
| WHU-Hi | 8 bit | 31.69 | 0.223 | 4.303 |
| Unseen AVIRIS | 32 bit | 41.21 | 23.36 | 0.955 |
| Unseen AVIRIS | 8 bit | 40.80 | 23.96 | 1.011 |
Compared with the 32-bit setting, the 8-bit model shows PSNR decreases of 0.12 dB on WHU-Hi and 0.41 dB on unseen AVIRIS, while maintaining comparable RMSE and SAM. It also outperforms the competing 32-bit baselines in Table 2 across all three metrics on both datasets. These results support the effectiveness of QuHIC under low-bit quantization in these additional evaluations.
Manuscript revisions: We have updated Table 2 and p. 8 (Lines 422-423) with the 8-bit results and added corresponding visual comparisons in Figure 11, with the accompanying analysis in Appendix D.8 on p. 21 (Lines 1093–1095).
Response to Reviewer Cptx (1/3)
Thank you for your constructive review and for recognizing the motivation of interval-aware decoding and the reconstruction improvements. We have addressed all concerns below. Revisions in the manuscript addressing the questions below are highlighted in blue. For reference, the original submission with a nine-page main text is also provided in the supplementary material.
R1: QCM ablation and the contribution of interval-based correction
Response: We appreciate your constructive feedback and apologize for not addressing this point adequately in the original manuscript. We have conducted two sets of experiments: a comparison of three QCM settings and an additional ablation of the basic unrolling baseline. The details are provided below:
1.Comparison of three QCM settings: We conduct the comparison on the AVIRIS test set under 8-bit quantization, keeping the encoder and MPRN architectures, nine-stage unrolling structure, training data, and optimization settings unchanged. Only the QCM operation is varied:
Tab. 1. Comparison of three QCM settings under otherwise identical configurations.
Interval QCM improves PSNR by approximately 2.21 dB over no QCM and 0.54 dB over center-point QCM. The former demonstrates the contribution of residual correction within the complete multi-stage framework, while the latter further supports the benefit of using a quantization interval rather than a single center-point target. The rationale is that a quantization symbol specifies a feasible interval, rather than the exact value before quantization.
2.Basic unrolling baseline between A0 and A1: We introduce A0.5: a basic unrolling network without QCM between A0 and A1. This variant adds a basic multi-stage unrolling structure to A0, with all other configurations matched to the original A1.
Tab. 2. Ablation with the additional basic unrolling baseline A0.5.
Introducing the unrolling structure increases PSNR to 36.14 dB, and adding QCM further improves it to 37.55 dB. This intermediate baseline A0.5 clarifies the sources of the overall A0→A1 improvement.
Manuscript revisions: We have updated Table 3 to include A0.5 and the three QCM comparisons Q0–Q2. We have also moved the ablation visualization to the main text and added ablations of the three QCM settings, as shown in Figure 7. The corresponding analysis has been revised in Sec. 4.3 on p. 9 (Lines 477–481) and p. 10 (Lines 525–531), and in Appendix D.7 on p. 19 (Line 1024), p. 20 (Line 1079), and p. 21 (Lines 1088–1090).