- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
- deformable 3d shape generation with ARAP constraints
- latent codes sampled from the current diffusion model determine where ARAP constraints are applied through the generation process
- generated shapes are scored by their deformations relative to the shape distributions from the respective training sets
- high-level seems the motivation is whether explicit ARAP constraints / supervision help to get better deformations.
Critical strengths
Interesting exploration; ARAP regularization for deformations has been around for a long time. Then 'neural' AI methods aimed to replace these by learnt deformation networks - there's a line of work that pushes towards that; this work combines these ideas in a sense that they include the ARAP constraints into the diffusion process of generative models.
Critical weaknesses
- The results are pretty weak: the datasets are relatively basic and it's not on par with cutting-edge methods
- The presentation needs polish; e.g., Fig. 3/4/5 -> resolution is too low / poor quality. This makes it impossible to evaluate the results - for a top-tier paper this is not enough. Fig. 1 also not super clear what is shown.
- I would love to see a video that shows the generation process, how the diffusion operates and have a side-by-side comparison to baselines in this regard.
Overall, I don't believe the paper is ready for publication in particular due to the presentation quality and lack of convincing results and/or their visualization.
Questions for authors
not at this point; the motivation is clear but I don't think the results are there.