- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
HGA3D speeds up 3D generation by selectively updating latent tokens during denoising and reducing decoding queries based on surface curvature. It requires no additional training and reports roughly 1.5× speedups on TripoSG and Hunyuan3D-2.0, with some loss in geometric quality.
Critical strengths
- The method requires no additional training and works on two different 3D generation backbones.
- It achieves about 1.5× overall speedups while keeping most geometric metrics close to the original models.
Critical weaknesses
- The pruning ratios and refresh schedules used for RAS and SADA are not reported, making the comparisons difficult to assess.
- Some key settings are missing, including the pruning start and end steps and the SDF thresholds. The text and Algorithm 1 also describe different anchor removal rules.
- Pruning occurs within the first 10 denoising steps, but the reliability of surface anchors at this early stage is not evaluated.
- Experiments are limited to TripoSG and Hunyuan3D-2.0. Performance on newer models with more tokens and finer geometry such as ultrashape remains unclear.
Questions for authors
- Does the hierarchical decoding baseline in Table 2 include FlashVDM’s Adaptive KV Selection?
- During sparse denoising steps, are skipped tokens removed from self-attention entirely, or are their cached keys and values retained?
- When does surface-based token pruning start, and how do you avoid unreliable anchor selection early in denoising?
- The text describes "anchors that consistently deviate from the surface over consecutive timesteps are identified as redundant and subsequently removed", but Algorithm 1 removes invalid anchors immediately. Which is used in the experiments?
- Can you evaluate HGA3D on a newer model with more tokens, such as UltraShape, to test whether the speedup holds while preserving finer geometric details?
2 comments
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and clarifications. Your responses have addressed my main concerns, and I have increased my score accordingly.
Thank you for the clarifications and the additional experiments on UltraShape-1.0. These results help address my concern about applicability to models with larger token counts.
However, the qualitative results currently presented in the paper are too limited to adequately assess the claimed preservation of geometric fidelity. More visual evidence is needed to complement the aggregate metrics.
Could you provide additional qualitative comparisons on Hunyuan3D-2.0 and UltraShape-1.0, showing the input image, vanilla output, and HGA3D output under matched settings and viewpoints? Comparisons with the tuned RAS and SADA baselines would also be helpful.
Please include a broader range of examples with close-up views of thin structures, sharp edges, and fine geometric details, so that readers can better assess the quality–speed trade-off.