- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces Geometric Flow Matching for generating 3D triangle meshes. It uses conformal Willmore flow to smooth training meshes into simple base shapes and constructs deterministic trajectories for flow-matching supervision. A graph neural network learns to reverse these trajectories by predicting vertex movements. Experiments on hand and face meshes evaluate reconstruction accuracy and mesh quality.
Critical strengths
Strengths
- Meaningful motivation. The paper addresses an important challenge in direct mesh generation: vertex movements can produce inverted triangles, self-intersections, and folds. Geometry-aware trajectories offer a reasonable approach to improving mesh validity.
- Clear formulation and useful controlled comparisons. The integration of geometric flows into flow matching is presented clearly. Comparisons using the same network with different forward trajectories help isolate the effect of the proposed path design.
Critical weaknesses
Weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty. The main contribution combines an existing geometric flow with an established flow-matching framework and a conventional graph neural network.
- Limited generality. Hand and face models are trained separately, with fixed vertex counts and connectivity. The geometric-flow setup also assumes closed surfaces with sphere-like topology. These restrictions narrow the method’s applicability, and its effectiveness on more diverse categories and mesh structures remains unclear.
- Limited comparison with recent 3D generative methods. The comparisons with prior generative models largely focus on older methods and do not adequately position the proposed approach against recent 3d generations. Comparisons that account for differences in conditioning and mesh representation would help establish whether the method offers meaningful advantages in geometric quality, mesh validity, or efficiency. Furthermore, the demonstrations are limited to hands and faces, leaving its effectiveness on more diverse and complex shapes unclear.
Questions for authors
As weakness.
2 comments
The current implementation relies on fixed connectivity and vertex count, restricting the method's generality. Furthermore, it does not demonstrate clear superiority over current direct 3D mesh generation methods. For these reasons, I maintain my score.
Statement: I wrote this review myself.
We thank the reviewer for their evaluation and feedback. We address the three concerns below.
W1. Methodological novelty
Our main contribution is not a new geometric-flow solver or neural architecture, but a geometry-driven approach to constructing transport paths for flow matching on meshes. Rather than perturbing vertices independently, we use geometric evolution to define coherent intermediate shapes and corresponding base states. This allows the learning process to follow geometrically meaningful deformations rather than arbitrary vertex movements. Importantly, the framework is not restricted to conformal Willmore flow. Willmore flow provides one example of a geometric evolution that gradually simplifies complex surfaces toward a near-spherical state. Other suitable geometric flows could also be incorporated into the same framework, allowing transport trajectories to be designed using geometric principles rather than shape-specific deformation rules. We tested this directly: constructing training trajectories via straight-line interpolation between source and target produced severely self-intersecting intermediate meshes, before training was even possible. This observation confirms that geometric structure in the transport path, not just a deterministic source-target correspondence, is necessary.
W2. Generality and mesh topology
We acknowledge that our current implementation assumes fixed connectivity and vertex count within each dataset, and that the geometric-flow construction is applied to closed, sphere-topology meshes. The hand and face models are trained separately, and we do not claim that the trained models generalize directly across different mesh structures or topologies. However, the underlying geometric principle is not specific to hands or faces. Both datasets use curvature-driven evolution without requiring different category-specific deformation strategies. Extending the framework to other mesh categories, more complex topologies, and variable connectivity remains an important direction for future work.
W3. Comparisons with recent generative methods
Our experiments are designed to study the effect of transport construction by keeping the network architecture and training procedure fixed across baselines, using mesh samples drawn from the same underlying distribution. This allows us to focus on differences in transport construction without introducing differences in model capacity. We agree that comparisons with recent 3D generative methods under a shared evaluation protocol would provide a broader assessment. However, differences in mesh representations, conditioning, and generation tasks make direct numerical comparisons difficult. Accordingly, Table 4 is intended as contextual information rather than evidence of superiority over those methods.