- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a method called DeltaFlow, a single-stage flow-matching model built on a diffusion transformer (DIT) for direct triangle-mesh generation. The main contribution of this paper is a Laplacian positional encoding. The dual-graph Laplacian of the mesh is embedded onto a shared honeycomb template, and give each face a connectivity prior during denoising. This can makes meshes more regular and better connected than prior flow-based methods, with fewer duplicate faces. The learned priors also transfers to downstream tasks such as point-cloud-conditioned generation and mesh inpainting.
Critical strengths
The core idea is injecting connectivity through Laplacian positional encoding, which I think is sound and well-motivated. Mapping the dual-graph Laplacian onto a shared honeycomb template gives the model a connectivity prior that directly targets the main failure of triangle-soup generation, also duplicate and disconnected faces.
DeltaFlow uses a single-stage flow matching, which sidesteps face by face generation, while still keeping a positional prior. Comparisons show it produces better-connected meshes with fewer duplicate faces.
Critical weaknesses
The geometric-fidelity evaluation is incomplete. The paper mainly reports 1-NNA, a custom tightness score, and duplicate-face rate, but no overall Chamfer distance. The demand for CD applies specifically to the conditional settings for point-cloud-conditioned generation and mesh completion where ground-truth meshes do exist. Chamfer distance should be reported for those.
This paper is trained only on four categories in ShapeNet, and all qualitative results shown are shapes with simple mesh structures and geometries. However, most current mesh generation work is trained on more complex datasets. The data complexity demonstrated in this paper is far lower than that of current SOTA (MeshAnything, BPT, EdgeRunner) methods. This makes it impossible for me to judge the upper bound of the method's capability.
The reported MeshFlow figures appear not consistent with the original paper. Table 1 lists MeshFlow at 586M parameters and 2.8s inference, but MeshFlow's original paper report roughly 124M parameters and 0.877s? This is not a cosmetic mismatch, since the the paper claims to be smaller and faster than MeshFlow.
It seems the tightness metric lacks a ground-truth reference. Without this reference it is hard to judge how tight is good enough, or whether the reported improvements are meaningful in absolute terms.
Questions for authors
Could you please report Chamfer distance for the conditional tasks?
Could you add a No PE + No vertex weighting ablation to isolate the independent contribution of the Laplacian positional encoding?
Please expand the dataset by incorporating more diverse shapes to demonstrate the upper-bound performance of the method and compare it against SOTA approaches.
2 comments
Concerns About the More Diverse Datasets
Thank you very much for your reply. The response addressed most of my questions except one. I still have major concerns regarding your claim in Fig. 12 about more diverse datasets. It can be clearly seen that the shapes listed in the Figure have simplest geometries in Objaverse. Most of them are box-like shapes with very few faces. This cannot demonstrate the method's ability to generalize to complex shapes.
The field of mesh generation has developed rapidly in recent years, with increasingly higher face counts and complexity. I think that this kind of extremely sparse and simplistic mesh generation is far from the current development trends.
Also, I do not think that the text and point cloud conditions can serve as a reason for insufficient complexity. These are merely differences in input and does not affect the representational capacity of the network. Overall, I believe the proposed method is indeed interesting and innovative and very insightful, but the extremely simple results on a few categories really run counter to current development trends in the mesh generation field.
Dear Reviewer 3uoe,
With one day left in the discussion period, we would greatly appreciate it if you could take a look at our responses and the additional results we provided to address your concerns. Please let us know whether they resolve them, or if anything remains that we can clarify in the time left. If so, we would be grateful if you would consider raising your score.
Thank you again for your time.