- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Flow3D-OPD, a two-stage post-training framework for improving 3D geometry generation. The authors first employ semi-policy fine-tuning and train three specialized teachers for orientation, pose, and geometric consistency using agentic rewards and DPO. Subsequently, multi-teacher on-policy distillation with mixed divergence optimization is used to integrate their capabilities into a unified student model.
The experiments demonstrate improvements across multiple geometric quality dimensions compared with existing methods.
Critical strengths
1. Meaningful problem and practical reward design.
The paper addresses an important problem in 3D generation. The agentic reward system, incorporating multi-view rendering, zoom-in inspection, and case memory, provides a practical approach to evaluating fine-grained geometric quality.
2. Encouraging experimental results.
The proposed framework achieves improvements across several evaluation dimensions. The final student demonstrates more balanced performance than the individual specialized teachers.
Critical weaknesses
1. Limited methodological novelty.
My main concern is that the proposed method largely combines existing techniques, including DPO, multi-teacher on-policy distillation, and gradient accumulation. In particular, prior works such as Flow-OPD have already explored multi-teacher distillation for flow-matching models.
While extending these techniques to 3D generation is useful, the paper does not sufficiently clarify what fundamentally new methodological contributions are introduced beyond combining existing approaches.
I would appreciate further clarification of the specific novelty and how the proposed framework differs from existing OPD methods.
2. Insufficient justification for the complex training framework.
The proposed method involves multiple training stages, including semi-policy fine-tuning, three specialized teacher models, and student distillation. Although the overall framework achieves promising results, it remains unclear whether such a complex design is necessary.
In particular, the proposed Mixed Divergence Optimization appears closely related to conventional task-specific routing and gradient accumulation. The improvement over the simpler multi-step sequential strategy is relatively modest (61.0% vs. 60.4%).
Could simpler approaches, such as single-model multi-objective DPO or conventional multi-task distillation, achieve comparable performance? Stronger comparisons under matched computational budgets would help justify the necessity of the proposed framework.
3. Evaluation reliability.
The main multi-dimensional evaluation relies on an agentic verifier closely related to the reward system used during training. Although the authors provide additional GPT-5.5 and human evaluations, the improvement over the strongest teacher under GPT-5.5 is relatively small (51.4% vs. 50.9%).
Additional independent evaluations or statistical significance analysis would help strengthen the conclusions.
Questions for authors
The paper addresses a meaningful problem and presents a practical framework with encouraging empirical results. However, my main concerns are the limited methodological novelty and the insufficient justification for combining multiple existing techniques into a relatively complex training pipeline.
Although the complete framework performs well, the current experiments do not convincingly establish why this particular combination is necessary or what new methodological insights it provides beyond existing approaches.
I therefore lean toward rejection in the current form, but would be willing to reconsider my rating if the authors can adequately address these concerns during the rebuttal.
5 comments
Response to W2
First, the overall metric in Table 1 of the paper shows that each module of our design progressively improves the generation quality. Moreover, it is not reasonable to consider our method unnecessary merely because its B-wins gain over the multi-step sequential strategy is modest, since that strategy itself already adopts our FT initialization and gradient-accumulated distillation. Regarding training complexity, our only additional time cost compared with FT+DPO is the distillation stage, which takes only about 1/3 of the time needed to train a single teacher because it requires no verifier calls. Regarding comparisons with simpler approaches, "FT + DPO" in Table 1 of the paper corresponds to single-model multi-objective DPO, and it shows a clear gap to Flow3D-OPD (48.3% vs. 61.0% B-wins). In addition, we implement conventional multi-task distillation, whose results are reported in Table R6 in our response to W1 and further demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
Response to W3
The independent evaluation uses GPT-5.5 as the judge model. We found it to be relatively conservative: for every dimension, the spread of its A-wins and B-wins scores is smaller than that of Gemini-3-Flash. Nevertheless, our method still outperforms the best expert model on the overall metric. We further add comparisons with more judge models (e.g., GLM-5.3) and with geometric metrics, namely reconstruction metrics such as Chamfer Distance (CD) and F-score with a threshold of 0.001 on the GSO subset-200, as shown in the following Table R7. We also add a statistical significance analysis under Gemini-3-Flash. Our method achieves the best results under all of these evaluations. The relevant experimental details and explanations have been added in sections 4.2 and 4.3 of the Appendix.
Table R7. Additional independent evaluations. (1) A-wins / B-wins (%) by the agentic verifier with GLM-5.3 as the judge; (2) Reconstruction metrics against ground-truth meshes on the GSO subset-200; (3) Uncertainty analysis of Gemini-3-Flash over 5 repeated evaluations with different seeds.
| Method | GLM-5.3 (A/B wins) | CD () | F1-score () | Gemini-3-Flash (A/B wins, mean std) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Orient-Teacher | 24.6 / 65.1 | 694 | 2.70 | 10.5 0.4 / 52.7 0.5 |
| Pose-Teacher | 25.1 / 67.9 | 767 | 2.56 | 15.9 0.6 / 48.2 0.7 |
| Consistency-Teacher | 22.7 / 69.0 | 696 | 2.62 | 5.4 0.2 / 56.2 1.1 |
| Flow3D-OPD (Ours) | 20.6 / 71.2 | 643 | 2.79 | 4.8 0.3 / 60.6 0.6 |
Response to W1 & Q1
Our contribution is not limited to the final OPD stage. Rather, we propose a complete framework for post-training in 3D generation that addresses three challenges: the base model cannot roll out high-quality samples, no reliable reward is available, and multiple rewards must be properly integrated into a single student model. Specifically, we fine-tune the model with a semi-policy strategy in the first stage, which enables the base model to roll out high-quality samples and benefits the subsequent training. As shown in Table 1 in the paper, OPD from the pretrained model reaches only 57.3% B-wins, while ours reaches 61.0%. Second, for teacher training, we design an agentic VLM verifier that is aligned with how human experts judge 3D meshes, which is the key to training the teacher models effectively. Most importantly, in the OPD stage, previous methods do not assign each sample its own most suitable teacher. Their input data or text prompts are not clearly separated by the samples' own characteristics, so semantically similar samples may learn from multiple conflicting teacher velocity fields. In contrast, our method matches each input image with its preferred and aligned teacher: samples prone to orientation errors are supervised by the orientation teacher, and samples with complex human poses are distilled by the pose teacher. This allows each sample to learn the trajectory of its most suitable teacher, which is necessary in 3D generation. The following Table R6 compares our method with learning the velocity fields of all three teachers simultaneously on each sample. The results show that the previous strategy is inferior to our method in both B-wins and Uni3D-I, and its user-study score is even lower than that of FT+DPO. The relevant experiments have been added in section 5.3 of the revised version.
Table R6. Comparison with various alternatives: single-model multi-objective DPO (FT+DPO), previous mixture distillation strategy like DiffusionOPD, and our method.