- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces Dynamic Homing Optimization (DHO), an RL post-training method for flow-matching 3D generators. For each input image, the model generates multiple meshes and uses Gemini to score them. Minimum-Cost Attractive Matching (MAM) assigns each retained negative sample a distinct positive target. Time-Aware Dynamic Correction (TDC) trains the velocity field to move from negative-sample interpolants toward the assigned target. DHO is applied to the Hunyuan3D 2.1-based Stage I of Flow3D-Pro after SFT. The LATTICE-based Stage II remains frozen. The experiments report higher scores than GRPO-style, DPO-style, and NFT-style objectives, as well as improvements over the evaluated image-to-3D systems.
Critical strengths
- The main idea is simple and intuitive. DHO gives negative samples explicit positive targets instead of only suppressing their original directions. Policy updates use initial noises and rollout endpoints without storing full sampling trajectories, which simplifies implementation.
- Table 1 provides a controlled comparison of RL objectives with the same SFT initialization, reward model, and frozen Stage II refiner. The appendix includes ablations of the main design choices.
Critical weaknesses
-
Diversity is not evaluated. Redirecting negative samples toward existing positive samples may reduce output diversity. The paper provides no diversity comparison with GRPO, DPO, or NFT.
-
The comparison settings are not fully fair. Tables 2 and 9 and Figure 6 do not control for refinement. Stage II alone raises the Table 2 user study score from 4.14 to 5.64. Please compare Stage I outputs or use the same refiner for compatible baselines.
-
Geometric accuracy metrics are missing. ULIP and Uni3D measure feature similarity, with gains of only 0.002 to 0.003 in Table 1. Direct geometric accuracy remains unevaluated.
-
Reward reliability is not quantified. The paper reports neither Gemini–human agreement nor test-set rewards across methods. These results would help assess reward reliability and potential reward hacking.
Questions for authors
-
How does DHO perform at G=16? What is the distribution of B during training? With G=8, B is at most 4. When B=1, MAM is equivalent to random pairing.
-
Can Table 2 include LATTICE and SFT + Stage II in the same comparison group?
-
How does DHO compare with standard flow matching along , using target velocity ? Table 4’s static variant retains the negative-sample interpolants and does not test this alternative path.
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments. The new text-to-image results provide evidence that DHO is effective beyond 3D generation, addressing my concern about its generality. I will therefore raise my score.
However, I am not yet convinced that a score of 4 is warranted, as the mechanism behind the improvements remains insufficiently clear. The one-to-one matching strategy has an intuitive motivation in terms of covering more positive samples and potentially preserving diversity. However, it is less clear why this construction should offer an advantage over existing reward-based optimization methods in improving properties such as fidelity to the conditioning image. A higher-reward endpoint is not necessarily better in every desired property, particularly under a multi-objective reward.
The additional experiments strengthen the empirical case for the method, but the explanation of why the proposed matching and correction mechanisms lead to these improvements remains incomplete.