- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces a new training-free morphing pipeline via a novel velocity field interpolation (VFI) for textured 3D morphing. They use a pretrained Trellis text-image-to-3D flow model without retraining any weights. Via direct latent manipulation using their novel VFI, they are able to perform morphing naturally without training. With this they are able to perform multiple types of morphing, such as color, shape, and basic semantics. They are able to surpass previous baselines and achieve a SoTA morphing benchmark. Additionally, they developed a novel benchmark for morphing, called MorphEdit3D.
Critical strengths
- A newer way of evaluating morphing that is essential for the community, as the MorphEdit3D benchmark, as morphing evaluation is difficult and counterintuitive.
- State-of-the-art results on their own evaluation dataset
- Marginal numerical results on MorphEdit3D
- Impressive 3D morphing results when compared to prior training-free schemas.
- Technically sound and well-written paper with a simple pipeline for latent morphing.
Critical weaknesses
The biggest weaknesses of this pipeline and the historical approach to training free 3D morphing is that the morphing task is most commonly used to morph between objects that are distant from each other, for example, a human becoming a wolf, a car becoming a humanoid car, a human becoming a fish. So on, obviously, sometimes a human-to-human morph is also requested, but is less common. What I am saying here is that your pipeline does not behave well with highly different subjects (semantically), and that is a downside that has to be made clear in the main text, not only in the supplementary material.
-
Marginal numerical results on MorphEdit3D
-
Under 3D morphing-related works, some newer models can perform morphing with implicit neural networks [2] and also with flow models [1], which some are not "training-free" and perform well with semantically different inputs, but [2] has downsides of needing matching landmarks and [1] is not open-source; could you please compare their approach with yours, either numerically or in the related works.
-
The MorphEdit3D seems like a good dataset for evaluating 3D morphing. However, I would like to see some examples of it (input and output). Also, the most important part of morphing is the 0.5 time of interpolation. How do you evaluate that? I know that the evaluation is done at 1/3 and 2/3 of alpha, but 1/2 is the most challenging part. I'd also like to see an evaluation table at the 1/2 time point.
-
What is the comparison of computer time to generate a morphing FlowMorpher vs. baselines? An "average time" column on Table 1 would suffice for my question. A per-scene breakdown of time to generate the morph is also good to answer my question but would have less impact.
I am open to considering raising my scores if the authors can address my concerns.
[1] Wukong's 72 Transformations: High-fidelity Textured 3D Morphing via Flow Models, NeurIPS 2025 [2] FLOWING 🌊: Implicit Neural Flows for Structure-Preserving Morphing, NeurIPS 2025
Questions for authors
I do not have any questions.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer MAM7 (Part 2/2)
W4: The MorphEdit3D seems like a good dataset for evaluating 3D morphing. However, I would like to see some examples of it (input and output). Also, the most important part of morphing is the 0.5 time of interpolation. How do you evaluate that? I know that the evaluation is done at 1/3 and 2/3 of alpha, but 1/2 is the most challenging part. I'd also like to see an evaluation table at the 1/2 time point.
Dataset examples: We have added the source and target input images to Figures 6–12, so that each qualitative result now shows the inputs next to the generated sequence.
Evaluation at α = 1/2: The midpoint was already one of the seven frames generated for each pair, and the smoothness metrics in Table 1 (LPIPS_adj and PDV) are computed over all six adjacent transitions, including the two around α = 1/2. Only FID and KID were evaluated at α = 1/3 and 2/3. We now also report them at α = 1/2 with the same protocol: the midpoint asset is rendered from 1,000 viewpoints and compared with the renders of the two endpoints.
Results: FlowMorpher remains the best method at the midpoint, and its margin is wider there. Its FID is 17% lower and its KID 33% lower than the strongest baseline at this point (Interp3D), compared with 3.5% and 11.2% over the strongest baseline at α = 1/3 and 2/3 (Nano3D, Table 1). This agrees with the point that the midpoint is the most demanding part of a morph. We have added these results to Table 1 in the revised manuscript.
Table C2: Quantitative comparison on MorphEdit3D at α = 1/2. KID values are multiplied by .
| Methods | FID@½ ↓ | KID@½↓ |
|---|---|---|
| FreeMorph | 142.59 | 91.88 |
| VoxHammer | 83.31 | 40.65 |
| DiffMorpher | 81.28 | 37.55 |
| Nano3D | 61.14 | 22.95 |
| Interp3D | 58.38 | 19.69 |
| FlowMorpher (ours) | 48.46 | 13.21 |
W5: What is the comparison of computer time to generate a morphing FlowMorpher vs. baselines? An "average time" column on Table 1 would suffice for my question. A per-scene breakdown of time to generate the morph is also good to answer my question but would have less impact.
Experimental setup: We measured all methods on a single RTX 4090 for a 7-frame sequence on MorphEdit3D. Setup covers every per-pair cost before the first frame (2D morphing, inversion, feature caching, LoRA tuning), and peak memory is the maximum allocated GPU memory.
Results: The efficiency results are reported in Table C3. FlowMorpher has no setup stage and the lowest total time. This is 20% less than Nano3D, 2.4× faster than Interp3D and 4.6× faster than VoxHammer, whose inversion alone takes 95 s.
Table C3: Efficiency comparison for generating a 7-frame sequence.
| Method | Inversion (MiB) | Feature cache (MiB) | Per-pair tuning | 3D mask | Setup (s) | Per-frame (s) | Peak mem (GB) | Total (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Image morphing + 3D generation | ||||||||
| FreeMorph | 0.5 | — | ✗ | ✗ | 46.4 | 5.8 | 16.6 | 87.0 |
| DiffMorpher | 26 | 2625 | ✓ | ✗ | 59.1 | 5.7 | 15.9 | 99.2 |
| 3D editing adapted for morphing | ||||||||
| VoxHammer† | 47,383 | 61 | ✗ | ✓ | 95.1 | 29.5 | 15.8 | 301.4 |
| Nano3D† | — | — | ✗ | ✓ | 10.9 | 10.2 | 14.3 | 82.5 |
| Native 3D morphing | ||||||||
| Interp3D | — | 2303 | ✗ | ✗ | 17.1 | 20.7 | 16.9 | 161.9 |
| FlowMorpher (ours) | — | — | ✗ | ✗ | — | 9.44 | 15.7 | 66.1 |
[C1] Bizzi A, Grynberg Portnoy M, Pereira Matias V, et al. Flowing: Implicit neural flows for structure-preserving morphing. NeurIPS, 2025.
[C2] Minghao Yin, Yukang Cao, and Kai Han. Wukong’s 72 Transformations: High-fidelity Textured 3D Morphing via Flow Models. NeurIPS, 2025.
You addressed all my concerns: the evaluation at α = 0.5, the computational efficiency comparison, the user study, and the clearer discussion of limitations regarding large semantic transformations.
The new experiments strengthen the empirical evidence supporting the proposed method, and the revised manuscript provides a more complete evaluation of its strengths and limitations. Although some limitations remain, I believe the authors have adequately addressed my major concerns, and the paper itself provides a technical contribution. I will wait for the other reviewers' discussions, but I am leaning towards improving my score.
Thank you very much for your thoughtful follow-up and for recognizing the technical contribution of our work. We are glad that the evaluation at α = 0.5, the efficiency comparison, the user study, and the clearer discussion of limitations have addressed your concerns.
Your suggestions have substantially improved the paper. We sincerely appreciate your positive assessment of our work.
Response to Reviewer MAM7 (Part 1/2)
We sincerely thank you for your appreciation and recognition of our work. Below, we provide detailed responses to your concerns.
Thank you for pointing this out. We have revised the Introduction and Method to state explicitly which cases FlowMorpher handles and where it fails.
Specifically, FlowMorpher handles moderate changes, up to the semantic level of MorphEdit3D. For more distant categories (e.g., a human and a fish), local attributes such as color still change gradually, but the overall geometry jumps abruptly at an intermediate weight. We attribute this to the pretrained prior, which offers no plausible intermediate shapes between such categories.
Thanks for your comment. From the Table 1 in manuscript, the margins over the strongest baselines are modest for FID and LPIPS_adj, and that the larger differences are in PDV and target-endpoint DINO-I. However, our qualitative comparisons show a clear gap in fidelity, with baselines exhibiting artifacts such as collage-like compositions. Therefore, to further compare FlowMorpher with the baselines, we ran a user study with 30 participants on 45 pairs randomly selected from MorphEdit3D.
Experimental setup: For each comparison, participants saw the results of FlowMorpher and one baseline side by side, anonymized and in random order, and rated their preference on a 7-point scale. Ratings were coded so that 1 means a strong preference for the baseline, 4 no preference, and 7 a strong preference for FlowMorpher.
Results: As shown in Table C1, the mean rating is above the neutral value of 4 for every baseline and criterion (smoothness, plausibility, endpoint fidelity, and overall). This user study provides complementary evidence that participants prefer FlowMorpher over the baselines.
Table C1: User study comparing FlowMorpher with baselines on MorphEdit3D.
Thank you for pointing these works out. They are closely related and deserve a more explicit discussion. Like FLOWING [C1], FlowMorpher builds on a flow-based generative model, and Wukong [C2] is the closest prior work to ours, as it also performs training-free 3D morphing.
We have clarified the differences and positioned our method relative to them in detail in Related Work (Sec. 2). Specifically, the key differences are as follows: