- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces StaLiNO, a latent neural operator model for traffic flow prediction. It first constructs a calendar-locked base field using learnable daily and weekly tables, and then models the deviation of traffic flows with respect to this base field. Then, the deviation trajectory of each sensor is encoded once by the routing GRU, and the sensors are soft-assigned to latent states that stay fixed across the whole window. Each field layer first performs the local road update and the pole-residue temporal update, and then performs the weighted pooling of the observed sensors in each latent state. Each latent sequence is evolved separately by a GRU with shared parameters and independent hidden states, without state mixing, and then sent back to each sensor through the same assignment. The final prediction is the sum of the future base field, the most recent valid deviation, and the learned correction.
Critical strengths
Based on the traffic physical fact that flow is two-to-one on the fundamental diagram, and that the characteristic speeds of free flow and congestion have opposite signs, this paper points out that operators that regenerate latent states at every step cannot provide a coherent trajectory for the temporal model. Accordingly, a trajectory assignment fixed across the window is designed. The problem formulation is clear and differs from generic latent neural operators.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The paper claims to achieve state-of-the-art performance, but does not compare with widely used baselines such as STAEformer and PDFormer. The MAE values reported in the original STAEformer paper on PEMS04, PEMS07 and PEMS08 are 18.22, 19.14 and 13.46, which are all lower than StaLiNO's 18.27, 19.63 and 13.81. In Table 1, GWNet is worse than STGCN and DCRNN on all four datasets, with 25.51 on PEMS04, which is far worse than the commonly reported value of about 18.8, and the source of the baseline results and the reproduction settings are not stated. Coupled with the fact that the margins on PEMS07 and PEMS08 are only 0.03 and 0.04 MAE with no standard deviation, the main empirical conclusion of the paper does not hold.
W2. In the PEMS08 component experiment, removing the base field increases MAE by 11.4%, removing the whole latent sharing only increases MAE by 0.75%, and the variant without latent sharing, at 13.917, already outperforms all baselines except STWave. Evidently, the performance mainly comes from the daily and weekly base field, which is similar to the idea of CycleNet and HyperD, and the anchored prediction. At the same time, the LWR derivation requires that disturbances propagate in the direction determined by the state, but is a symmetric kernel, and the intra-state average does not distinguish between upstream and downstream. The derivation also requires the base state to satisfy the conservation law, whereas the model uses a calendar-averaged flow table. Neither the latent state mechanism nor the physical motivation of the paper can explain the source of its gain.
Questions for authors
Q1. Both the daily and weekly tables are initialized with the slot means and then added directly. How does the initial base field avoid double-counting the mean? How much improvement can the attention-based refinement of the base field bring over directly using the slot means?
Q2. The pooling kernel is symmetric, so where does the model represent the direction-dependent propagation, downstream in free flow and upstream in congestion?
Sug1. The lack of recent spatio-temporal forecasting models is the biggest defect in the experiments of this paper, so it is suggested to supplement them.
Sug2. The occupancy of PEMS04 and PEMS08 should be used to report errors by the periods of congestion formation and dissipation, and a k-means control on the base-field residual trajectories should be added to the state alignment experiment.
Dear Reviewer hyaC,
Thank you for reading our paper. We acknowledge that our paper is not yet as solid as we would like, and that our research experience is limited. We appreciate that you recognize the physical motivation from the LWR model and the synergy between trajectory assignment and independent temporal evolution. We will improve the presentation to make the method easier to follow. However, limited experience does not mean that our results are unreliable.
We firmly disagree with the concern that our results may be an artifact of hyperparameter tuning. The review raises this suspicion without pointing to any specific evidence in the paper. We did not tune hyperparameters to obtain the reported results. All hyperparameters, including the number of latent states K, were selected on the validation set, and the test set was used only for the final evaluation.
Our code, configuration files, and trained checkpoints are included in the supplementary material. Every result in Table 1 can be reproduced directly with the released code, for example on AutoDL. We invite the reviewer and the AC to verify our results. If the reviewer finds any specific step in our pipeline that suggests test-set tuning, we would be glad to respond to it directly.
We also note that the review flags our paper for ethics review without stating an ethical concern. Our study uses only the public PeMS traffic flow data released by Caltrans. The data contain no personal information and involve no human subjects. A methodological suspicion is not an ethical issue, and we respectfully ask that the flag be reconsidered. A suspicion of tuning-driven results without supporting evidence is unfair to our work.
We have decided to withdraw this submission. We will use the feedback from all reviewers to improve the paper for a future version. We sincerely thank the reviewer, the AC, and the program committee for their time and effort in reviewing our work.
Sincerely, The Authors