- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper models gene-wise perturbation response patterns and magnitudes along a supplied temporal or pseudo time trajectory. It uses an analytical kernel to characterize response timing, persistence, and late reversal, as well as a transformer to learn magnitudes and refine the predicted curves. The model achieves reasonably good reconstruction accuracy, but its future prediction performance does not demonstrate robust improvements across different condition splits.
Critical strengths
Potential biological interpretability. The paper explicitly parameterizes gene-wise response timing, persistence, and late reversal using an analytical process kernel. This structured representation offers the potential for biological interpretability by distinguishing different temporal response patterns, such as transient, sustained, and biphasic responses, rather than treating gene expression changes as static endpoint predictions. However, the extent to which these parameters reflect underlying biological mechanisms remains to be established.
Critical weaknesses
1.Lack of single-cell heterogenety modeling. The proposed method represents gene responses as analytic functions along a chronological axis instead of the distribution of gene expression across cells. It can’t adequately characterize heterogeneous perturbation responses or changes in the proportions of distinct cellular subpopulations, raising concerns about whether the method fully exploits the heterogeneous information provided by single-cell data.
2.Failure to capture perturbation-induced divergence in cell trajectories. Perturbations can alter cell-state transitions and induce divergent differentiation trajectories, along which the same gene may exhibit distinct response patterns depending on the cellular state or developmental fate. However, the proposed method predicts gene-wise response curves along a given axis without explicitly modeling perturbation-dependent trajectory branching or cell-fate transitions. This limits its ability to characterize the dynamic consequences of perturbations at the cellular level.
3.Limited and insufficiently robust predictive performance. Its forecasting performance does not demonstrate robust improvements across different condition splits. In the main future-day prediction experiment, the average correlation across four additional condition splits is close to zero (0.007 ± 0.122).
4.Limited biological relevance of gene-wise response trends. Gene-expression programs are shaped by complex regulatory interactions. By focusing primarily on individual genes' overall response trends along a supplied trajectory, the proposed method captures only a limited aspect of these complex dynamics. It remains unclear whether such gene-wise predictions can reveal meaningful biological programs, illustrate coordinated responses to perturbations, or provide applicable insights into the underlying regulatory processes. Consequently, the biological relevance and downstream utility of the predicted response curves remain insufficiently demonstrated.
Questions for authors
-
Disentanglement of response kinetics and modulation. The model explicitly parameterizes response kinetics through the analytical kernel (k_g(\tau)), while the GPUA module learns a time-dependent gate (\gamma_g(\tau)) to modulate the kernel output. Since both components vary with (\tau), how does the model distinguish their respective roles and prevent the gate from learning temporal patterns that duplicate or override the response kinetics encoded by the kernel?
-
Selection of RBF basis functions and preservation of the explicit response prior. How is the number of RBF basis functions determined, and how sensitive are the results to this choice? Given the flexibility of the perturbation-conditioned RBF dictionary, what evidence demonstrates that it complements rather than overrides the response patterns encoded by the analytical kernel, thereby preserving the contribution and interpretability of the explicit response parameterization?
Suggestion for Future Work
- Downstream biological utility of explicitly modeled responses. The model characterizes gene-wise response timing, persistence, and late reversal, but the biological implications of these predicted response patterns remain unclear. How could these predictions be translated into applicable biological insights, such as prioritizing candidate regulators, identifying temporally coordinated gene programs, or generating experimentally testable hypotheses? Demonstrating such downstream utility would help establish the value of explicitly modeling response dynamics beyond curve reconstruction.
3 comments
I appreciate the authors' detailed responses and additional experimental results. However, I believe that some of my concerns remain insufficiently addressed. Therefore, I have decided to maintain my original rating.
Thank you for your continued consideration of our work. We understand that some of your concerns may not have been fully addressed. To ensure that we respond appropriately, could you please clarify which specific concerns you believe remain insufficiently addressed? We would be very happy to provide further explanations, analyses, or experimental results where appropriate. Your detailed guidance would help us better address the issues you have identified.
Response to Reviewer X7UQ, Model Scope, Component Controls and Generalization
Thank you for the detailed assessment. We added component controls and matched split reruns, and clarified the model scope.
W1 and W2. Population responses, not cell trajectories.
scUGPT predicts population mean expression along a supplied time or pseudotime axis. Cells define the means and pseudotime coordinate. It does not predict cellular distributions, proportions, branching, or fate transitions. Mean shifts can reflect changes within a state or in cell composition. Lineage panels use known lineages, not inferred perturbation induced branching. We now state these boundaries explicitly.
W3. Forecasting across condition splits.
We completed 270 matched trainings across five Ishikawa hiPSC CRISPR condition splits, nine configurations, two tasks, and three seeds per task. The original architecture and 96 gene panel are retained. Forecast training and validation targets end at day 4. Below are means ± SD across five split means, after averaging seeds within each split.
Change r compares predicted day 5 minus predicted day 4 with observed change. Static change correlation is undefined. No kernel retains the anchor and primary loss, fixing the kernel multiplier to one and removing kernel attention bias.
Full has lower mean MSE than the four external learned comparators, but not No kernel or static broadcast. Kernel addition improves change correlation on one of five splits, not consistently. Tables S13 through S18 retain every split. These reruns do not replace the historical 0.007 ± 0.122 result. Overlapping splits are not independent biological replicates.
Q1. Kernel and gate are not uniquely disentangled.
The bounded gate attenuates the anchor and kernel product. It cannot directly reverse its sign, but can change peak heights and timing. A constant initial gate and zero dictionary and residual outputs favor the analytic response initially. Training does not enforce unique temporal roles.
We retrained fixed and context only gates on split 2026. Fixed uses the initial gate value. Context only removes time input and broadcasts a context dependent gate. Both retain the anchor, analytic kernel, attention, lag, mixing, residual, and primary loss. Table S46 reports three seed means ± SD.
Similar errors do not establish equivalence or disentanglement. Initialization permutations reduce centre rank stability from 0.943 to 0.063, while prediction rank stability remains 0.895. Table S49 supports treating coefficients as response descriptors, not validated biological kinetics.
Q2. Dictionary size and analytic contribution.
Eight Gaussian bases were an implementation choice. Table S47 varies their number with the dynamic gate and matched training. Zero disables the dictionary, not the analytic kernel. Values are three seed means. RMS ratio is the root mean square magnitude of the gained dictionary divided by that of the analytic terms.
The analytic terms have greater aggregate magnitude here, but there is no orthogonality or norm constraint preventing overlap. More bases increase dictionary contribution without improving the displayed forecast means. We do not interpret the RMS ratio as explained variance or proof that the prior is preserved.
W4. Coordinated programs and downstream utility.
Gene mixing links the predicted curves. Across three historical checkpoints, coupling matrices have pairwise Spearman correlations of 0.70, 0.63, and 0.70. Among 4560 gene pairs, the strongest coupling decile has mean observed coresponse 0.134, versus 0.066 for the rest. Figure S2 illustrates coordinated pairs, including RPS12 with RPL10A and HMGCS1 with MVD.
This supports descriptive covariation, not regulatory direction. Association with STRING after controlling for coexpression is weak, partial Spearman 0.013. These outputs can nominate gene sets for follow up, but do not establish validated regulators or causal mechanisms.