- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors introduce PerturbSB where the idea is to add to a shared reference drift a perturbation correction. It performs well on held-out Kang and Haber cell types, with mixed results on Hagai.
Critical strengths
The paper is honest in reporting cases where the method does not perform the best, including cases where simpler baselines are better.
Critical weaknesses
The ablation ablates on endpoint matching and energy but it does not remove the shared drift or diffusion. Also the energy barely changes the response correlation (cf Section 4.4), so the experiments do not show that the proposed stochastic design drives the gains, and this is also admitted in the same section. On the Hagai mouse experiment, a simple global shift has better results. Could the authors provide some intuition on why their method does not perform well in this setup? From a method's perspective, the novelty is also quite low.
Questions for authors
Could you run deterministic / no-reference-drift / fixed-diffusion baselines with the same configurations ( e.g. encoder, endpoint loss)?