- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
scAMod predicts distributions of post-perturbation gene expression for unseen donors and drugs. It constructs a shared soft gene-to-module prior from pretrained gene representations, a PPI network, graph clustering, and balanced assignment. An adaptive module tokenizer uses each cell's full expression profile to adjust gene participation across modules. Module-level interactions and compression produce a cell representation, and a gene-query decoder reconstructs expression. Optimal transport provides training pseudo-pairs for conditional flow matching in the learned latent space. The autoencoder and flow model are then frozen, and Perturbation Module Readout (PMR) adds a condition-dependent contribution to the gene-level predictions. The paper evaluates the method on PBMC leave-one-donor-out prediction and SciPlex3 held-out-drug prediction, with ablations of the module backbone and PMR objectives, routing analyses, and five-seed results on SciPlex3.
Critical strengths
S1. Adaptive module composition is supported by ablations independent of PMR
The model separates the shared prior from cell-dependent participation weights . Decoder-query alignment and batch-averaged anchoring allow cell-specific routing while maintaining a common module reference. Table 3 tests this design without PMR: fixing the routing increases Full ED from 0.7371 to 1.3543 and DEG ED from 0.8364 to 0.9952 on SciPlex3. Shuffling the prior and removing the anchor loss also reduce performance. These results support the predictive value of adaptive module composition and the shared prior.
S2. The experiments cover two complementary forms of generalization
The 12 PBMC leave-one-donor-out folds test transfer across donor backgrounds. SciPlex3 holds out entire drug identities across doses and cell lines, testing generalization to unseen compounds. On PBMC, scAMod improves DEG from 0.7602 for control sampling to 0.8260 and reduces DEG ED from 1.1006 to 0.8339. On SciPlex3, it achieves the best reported result on seven of the eight metrics. The appendix provides donor-level results and five-seed results on SciPlex3, with DEG and DEG ED .
Critical weaknesses
W1. The contribution beyond existing module-based methods is not sufficiently established
scBIG (Ruan et al., ICML 2026) already combines GeneCompass embeddings and PPI priors with Gene-Relation Clustering, a Gene-Cluster-Aware Encoder, and conditional flow matching for perturbation prediction. The relevant contributions of scAMod are therefore its cell-specific gene-to-module routing, the corresponding decoder, and PMR. The paper needs a direct comparison that establishes what these components add beyond existing module-based models.
The PMR results also confound the readout architecture with additional supervision. In Table 4, DEG is 0.1508 without PMR, 0.1760 with ED-only PMR training, 0.4883 with DEG-MSE-only training, and 0.4364 with the combined objective. The gains in DEG mean prediction depend strongly on the training objective. These results do not separate the benefit of PMR's architecture from that of adding a supervised conditional correction stage. A conventional conditional readout trained with the same loss and comparable capacity, or fixed and adaptive module backbones paired with the same PMR, would provide a more informative comparison.
The biological analysis leaves a related question open: do the membership changes learned by adaptive routing add biological information beyond the shared prior or fixed routing? Concrete examples of changed gene groups or cross-module relationships, supported by reproducibility and independent evidence, would strengthen this interpretation.
W2. The evaluation does not directly establish perturbation specificity or DEG recovery
The reported metrics cover mean prediction error and differences between cell-population distributions, but leave perturbation-response patterns, discrimination between perturbations, and recovery of responsive genes insufficiently tested. Pearson delta correlation relative to matched controls, PDS with a specified candidate set and distance, and DES or an equivalent DEG-recovery measure would address these gaps. The existing error and distributional metrics should be retained alongside them.
Questions for authors
Q1. How much does adaptive routing improve on scBIG and other module-based predictors?
Please explain the differences between scAMod and scBIG in cell-specific routing, gene-query decoding, and PMR, and provide a targeted performance comparison using matched data splits, gene sets, conditioning information, and comparable training budgets. A conventional conditional readout trained with the same objective, or fixed and adaptive module backbones paired with the same PMR, would also help separate the contributions of adaptive organization and PMR.
Q2. What biological information is gained by adapting module membership?
The paper reports reproducible routing patterns across donors, but the pathway-enrichment analysis mainly concerns the static prior modules. Does adaptation yield candidate gene groups or membership changes not explicitly specified by the input prior? For one or two cases, describe the changes relative to the prior, their stability, and supporting evidence from data or resources not used in modeling.
Q3. Do the performance gains hold under perturbation-aware evaluation?
Please use the existing predictions to report Pearson delta correlation relative to matched controls, Perturbation Discrimination Score (PDS), and Differential Expression Score (DES) or an equivalent DEG-recovery measure. Specify the Cell-Eval version or other implementation, the PDS distance and candidate perturbation set, and the DEG-scoring procedure.
Q4. How does the noise-regularized training path match the inference initialization?
Algorithm 3 (p. 18) uses
but starts inference from the encoded control state without added noise. Please report the value of and explain how the training endpoints and inference initialization are matched. For nonzero , the training endpoint distributions are noise-smoothed; how is this handled during generation?