- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates landslide segmentation based on aerial imagery. It proposes to integrate digital elevation model to add terrain information and improve segmentation, alongside a band attention strategy to improve the analysis from multispectral data. It evaluates its contributions through the prism of accuracy and computational efficiency on the Landslide4Sense dataset.
Critical strengths
- Integrating digital elevation model to perform landslide segmentation is a good idea.
Critical weaknesses
A. Writing
While not critical in itself, the writing is overall quite subpar. A lot of concepts are only superficially described, e.g. the Band-Group Attention and the Terrain-Gated Encoder which are supposed to be big contributions. I am not confident I would be able to reimplement the TAG based on the description from 3.1.2, for example. There are also many weird details in the writing, such as out-of-place equations, very detailed trivial stuff (Equations 2, 5, 6, 10, 11).
B. Unconvincing experimental results
Overall the experimental results have failed to convince me that they properly support the claims. For example, the paper claims that the proposed method is on the optimal Pareto front for the accuracy/compute trade-off (measured in FLOPs), but it is obviously not: as shown in Figures 3 and 4, simply removing the final module decreases mIoU by 2 points but improves FLOPs count by 15%.
Compared to previous works, the results are also reported on a single benchmark (LandSlide4Sense), while common practices consist in also evaluating on the Bijie Landslide and Luding Landslide datasets. This is problematic considering that all the ablations and the hyperparameters tuning have been performed on the Landslide4Sense dataset, which makes the reported result optimistic and we cannot be sure the tweaked architecture with all its bells and whistles will properly generalize on other benchmarks.
Last but not least, the relative improvements metrics make no sense (Equations 10 and 11): they are heavily dependent on the choice of baselines. Choosing underperforming baselines (which is the case as I will explain below) result in overstated relative improvements that bear no relation with the actual SotA in landslide segmentation.
C. Related work on Band Group Attention
The paper claims to introduce band group attention but it is not clear how novel this is. There have been plenty of papers contributing band-level attention, especially for hyperspectral imagery: SiamBAG, Attend in Bands, BAE-Net, etc.
The proposed implementation (Eq (3)) is overall a straightforward attention but on grouped channels, which does not seem particularly new. In addition, this contribution is never evaluated with a dedicated ablation study anyway.
D. Related work and comparison to prior landslide segmentation models
Continuing of the previous trend of missing related work, there is no comparison or discussion to previous terrain-aware models. Yet, integrating the DEM into segmentation models is a relatively hot topic, especially for floods (e.g. Tan et al., Adhikari et al.) and landslide (see in particular Dar et al., ECCV 2026, Zhang et al., JSTARS 2026, Zhao et al., PLOS 2025, Liu et al., TGRS 2025, etc.).
The absence of any discussion of these papers has two broad consequences that severely undermine the contribution of the reviewed manuscript:
- the proposed "terrain-gated encoder" is never compared or positioned to existing "terrain-aware" modules from the state of the art of computer vision for remote sensing, despite many relevant works existing;
- the only baselines reported in the experimental results are generic semantic segmentation models, which ignore previous baselines specifically tailored for landslide segmentation including FFS-Net and TerrainGraphtNet.
This is made worse by the fact that the reported metrics on LandSlide4Sense (OA and mIoU) are inconsistent with the state of the art. For example, the paper claims 76.2% mIoU (which is on par, but slightly below, the 76.39% reported by TerrainGraphNet), but also reports an amazing ~85.5 F1 score which blows TGN's 70.3 out of the water, meanwhile reporting ~85% accuracy, a complete downfall against TGN's ~98.6.
While I'm not saying the reported numbers are wrong, my point is that the absence of comparison makes it very hard to understand what is going on. Is the method better than the state of the art? It is impossible to know based on the manuscript.
Questions for authors
See my main questions above.
I have some additional minor remarks regarding the presentation:
- l.43: missing reference ot Landslide4Sense
- l.103: I've never seen this symbol for the indicator function, it seems an uncommon choice.
- Equation (2) gives no useful information
- Figure 4(b): I'm not sure what this is supposed to show.
- It's unclear how the hyperparameters (e.g. l.396-400) have been tuned.
- Figure 6 and 4.4: I don't see how this shows spatial uncertainty.