- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses transfer learning and how to make pretrained coastal flood prediction models adapted to new regions with few shot learning, and whether this can be achieved in a model-agnostic way. For this, the paper proposes a model-agnostic post-hoc module (physics adapter (PA)) that takes elevation and data driven features from pretrained model and outputs the predicted water level. The transferability with the proposed method was tested in two regions (Abu Dhabi and San Francisco) and the model-agnostic aspect was tested with different backbones. The experiments showed on these two regions that the proposed PA improves RMSE under different scenarios.
Critical strengths
- The evaluation regarding the model-agnostic aspect is convincing.
- I really enjoyed reading the main part of the paper, because it is clear and easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
I think this paper is leaning to reject:
- The main argument of the paper is that the proposed PA helps with transferability e.g., L016-019: “we introduce the Physics Adapter (PA), a compact, architecture-agnostic adaptation interface that enables efficient few-shot transfer of flood prediction models across diverse coastal regions” and L116-117: “... including across geographically and hydrodynamically distinct coastlines.” I think this is over-claim and not supported by the results. The model is only tested on two regions, and the proposed PA helps improving RMSE and not helping or solving the transferability issue. In addition, no flood detection metrics were reported to support the main argument, RMSE is not suitable metric for flood detection (see Q3).
- The experiments do not provide any clue of the contribution of the proposed method compared to existing approaches. There is no comparison to other transfer learning methods for coastal floods. Table 1 looks like an ablation study rather than a benchmarking of the proposed module (see learned surrogates for flood prediction in related works). Also, there are no ablation studies about the components of the proposed physics adapter e.g., some ablation should include a comparison to location-aware adaptive normalization where affine transformation is learned inside the model like AdaNorm, also the whole PA can be replaced by an AdaNorm or different ways to inject elevation as conditioning. Otherwise, the physics adapter is not justified.
Questions for authors
- The first question that comes to my mind is why the elevation is injected two times in the model! The backbone uses elevation already so maybe the way such static information is injected in each backbone is not good.
- Is elevation enough to achieve transferability and isn’t this contradicting L60-62: “... domain shift arises in different forms: geographic transfer changes terrain, protection geometry, landcover structure, and flood response, whereas SLR transfer affects the forcing within the same region. An effective adaptation mechanism must handle both from only a handful of labeled examples.”?
- Can you report transfer learning results like tables 6 and 7 in appendix? In flood we are interested mainly on flood detection not RMSE. Different models can have different systematic biases and important are metrics for flood detection like F1.
- Line 252-253: why would the model collapse to data-driven branch if the physics branch is useful? What is the motivation?
- The model does not work in zero-shot learning. Do you have any thoughts why?
- The model works as an emulator of Delft3D rather than estimating the observed water level to test real-world transferability.
Things to improve the paper that did not impact the score:
- L284-286: “Geographic transfer changes the region (), whereas SLR transfer keeps the region fixed and changes only the forcing”, how the forcing was changed? Do you do extrapolation in time?
- Format page 6: the bottom margin is against the guideline format.
- I would make figure 2 (b) do multiplication of gate with both branches then some the two branches so it becomes clearer from the figure without reading the text.
3 comments
## Response to Reviewer g7VG (2/3)
Q3. Flood detection (F1) and transfer tables like Tables 6 and 7.
We agree that flood detection matters. In our setting it is a sub-task of the PWL regression, since a location is flooded when its predicted PWL exceeds 0.05 m, so F1 follows from the same predictions. We focused on PWL because protection planning needs water levels and not only the wet/dry status, for example to size defenses.
Changes made. Detection is now reported in full.
- F1 next to RMSE in Table 1 and Figures 2b and 2d, and the F1 gain from the PA in Table 11.
- Transfer tables in the format of Tables 6 and 7, for every setting at K=10 and averaged over K (Appendix G.4, Tables 12–31), with flooded, dry and mean F1 in Tables 19–21 and 29–31.
- Precision and recall of the flooded class by backbone family (Appendix G.5, Table 32), and the definitions in Appendix F.
Findings. All models detect floods well, so F1 leaves much less room for improvement than RMSE. F1 is 0.91 to 0.99 in domain and 0.93 to 0.97 after transfer at K=10 (Table 1). The relative gain from the PA is therefore smaller in F1 than in RMSE. Over all settings at K=3 it is 4.5 to 8.2% in F1 against 33 to 46% in RMSE, both computed from the averaged metrics (Table 11). The gain is concentrated where models fail without the PA (Table 32, K=3, cross-region, full fine-tuning).
| Backbone family | RMSE (m), FT → FT+PA | F1, FT → FT+PA |
|---|---|---|
| Graph and operator | 1.309 → 0.394 | 0.454 → 0.918 |
| Dense | 0.214 → 0.193 | 0.916 → 0.907 |
This is the rise in F1 "from 0.45 to 0.92 at K=3" stated in the abstract, and it comes from the graph and operator backbones. Without the PA, they predict flooding at many dry locations (precision 0.28 to 0.38), and the PA raises their precision to 0.70 to 0.82. For the dense backbones, F1 is already about 0.9. The PA lowers their RMSE, while F1 changes by −0.01 under full fine-tuning and by −0.05 to −0.07 with PEFT and head-only adaptation, with a higher recall and a lower precision. We report this openly in Sec. 5.2, Appendix G.5 and the conclusion. In Dubai, FT+PA has the highest F1 at every K with SF as the source (Table 2a).
Q1. Why is elevation given twice?
The backbone does receive elevation as an input, but inside the network it is normalized and mixed with land cover, protection status and SLR, so its scale in meters is lost. The PA uses the raw DEM in meters to compare it with a predicted water level (Eq. 3). The ablation shows that this matters. With elevation only through the backbone (data branch only), the RMSE is 0.262 m against 0.182 m for the PA (cross-region, K=3, head only, Table 35). Change made. This explanation is added to Sec. 3.3.
Q2. Is elevation enough for transfer?
No, and the PA does not rely on elevation alone. Only the physics-guided branch uses the raw DEM, and even there the wet/dry threshold and water level are predicted from the backbone features, which carry land cover, protection status and SLR. The data branch uses all features, and the gate decides per location how much to trust each branch. The ablation confirms that elevation alone is not enough, since the physics-guided branch alone gives 0.269 m against 0.182 m for the full PA (Table 35).
## Response to Reviewer g7VG (3/3)
Q4. Why would the gate collapse onto the data branch?
The data branch sees all the features and can fit the training labels of the source region on its own. Without a penalty, the gate drifts towards it during source training, and the elevation structure that helps in a new region is lost. The penalty only discourages this collapse and does not force the same gate everywhere. The ablation supports this. Without the penalty, the PA gives 0.289 m against 0.182 m across regions and 0.182 m against 0.072 m under SLR transfer (K=3), and the gate of the AD source model falls well below that of the SF model and varies strongly between seeds (Appendix I, Figure 22). Change made. This motivation is added to Sec. 3.4.
Q5. Why does the model not work zero-shot?
The reference water level is learned on the source region. Without any target data, the PA compares the target terrain with the source water level, which is wrong for a new region or sea level. One target simulation is enough to correct this, and from K=1 on every PA regime has a lower RMSE than every regime without it (Figure 2a). This is discussed in Sec. 5.2 ("Zero-shot behavior") and in the limitations. On VM-UNet with only the head adapted, about three target simulations are needed (Appendix I).
Q6. The model emulates Delft3D rather than observed water levels.
We agree. This is inherent to the task. Protection scenarios are planning options that have not been built, so their flooding cannot be observed, and the surrogate replaces the simulator when screening them. The AD hydrodynamic model was validated over a three-month period at 194 locations in the Gulf (Hassan et al., 2026, supplement).
Change made. The limitations now state that all targets are simulated and not observed.
Minor points (changes made)
- Forcing (L284–286). SLR transfer changes the sea level in the simulations (0.5, 1.0 and 1.5 m). There is no extrapolation in time. This is now stated in Sec. 3.4.
- Page 6 margin. Fixed.
- Adapter figure. Figure 1(b) is redrawn. Each branch is multiplied by its gate weight ( and ), and the two products are summed, as in Eq. (5).
## Response to Reviewer g7VG (1/3)
Thank you for the careful review, and for the positive comments on the clarity of the paper and on the model-agnostic evaluation. All changes are marked in blue in the revised PDF.
W1. Over-claiming, only two regions, and no flood-detection metric.
W2. Comparison with other transfer methods, and ablations.
Findings. With only the head adapted, the PA is clearly the best, with far fewer parameters. When the whole model is adapted, all designs are within 0.002 m, and the PA keeps the highest F1. The ablation of the parts of the PA is in our response to Reviewer H7Zj and in Table 2b.