acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

YSNO: A Yield-Source Neural Operator for Inverse Modeling of Slope Mechanics

Abstract

Frequent landslide disasters underscore the need for monitoring-driven models that can assess slope risk before catastrophic failure. A key capability underlying such models is to infer the spatially varying strength of a slope from observed deformation, which in turn requires a differentiable forward model capable of resolving both localized yielding and its nonlocal mechanical consequences. However, existing neural operators and their benchmarks have been developed predominantly for fluid dynamics and generic PDEs, leaving heterogeneous elastoplastic slope mechanics and inversion largely underexplored. We introduce the Yield-Source Neural Operator (YSNO), an inverse-oriented neural operator for spatial material-field inference in slopes, together with SlopeBench, a paired finite-element benchmark for elastoplastic field prediction and material inversion. YSNO combines a differentiable finite-element physics lift, a plasticity-gated local operator for localized nonlinear corrections, and a finite-rank global integral operator that propagates yield-related source information across the domain. The resulting fully differentiable surrogate can be frozen and directly embedded into gradient-based inversion, establishing an end-to-end computational pathway from displacement observations to spatially distributed strength estimates. On SlopeBench, YSNO reduces full-setting displacement relative- error by approximately 44.9% relative to the strongest evaluated baseline and yields substantially more accurate material-field reconstruction in inverse tasks. Cross-resolution and out-of-distribution experiments further demonstrate useful generalization beyond the standard training regime. By providing a benchmark for jointly evaluating forward accuracy and inverse suitability in elastoplastic slope mechanics, SlopeBench fills an underexplored regime in scientific operator learning. More broadly, YSNO provides a computational foundation for transforming deformation monitoring into interpretable estimates of internal slope strength, with the potential to support more reliable landslide risk assessment, early warning, and disaster mitigation for vulnerable communities worldwide.

Primary area:
applications to physical sciences (physics, chemistry, biology, etc.)
Keywords:
Neural operators, Scientific machine learning, Inverse problems, Material field inversion, Geotechnical mechanics, PDE benchmarks

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_toKfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3(+1)
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes YSNO for slope response prediction and material inversion, and evaluates it on the new SlopeBench dataset.

Critical strengths

YSNO combines elastic FEM with learned nonlinear corrections and achieves lower displacement and stress errors than the tested baselines.

Critical weaknesses

Only 1 to 3 displacement points are used to recover 128 parameters. The results may mainly depend on the training distribution and parameterization. The prior p(z) is not specified, and there is no prior only baseline. Inversion is tested on only four cases, without testing different material distributions.

YSNO uses an elastic FEM reference, but no standard neural operator is compared using the same reference. The improvement from the proposed architecture is unclear.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the prior p(z) in Eq. (16)? Is the prior term in Eq. (16) included in the actual inversion experiments?

  2. How sensitive are the inversion results to the latent parameterization and training material distribution, given only 1 to 3 observations for 128 parameters?

  3. Can the authors provide inversion results on more than four cases, including different material distributions?

  4. Do baselines, such as FNO and U-Net, use the same elastic FEM reference as YSNO? If not, is the comparison fair?

  5. Can the authors provide the code, dataset, and data splits during the rebuttal so that reviewers can verify the results?

8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q1, Q2 and W1

Response to Q1 and W1

We thank the reviewer for raising this important question. We provide the following clarifications.

Prior distribution. In the absence of reliable site-specific geological information, we adopt a non-informative uniform prior distribution for the soil material-parameter fields within their physically admissible ranges. This choice is motivated by the fact that conventional geotechnical investigation reports are often not contemporaneous with the actual monitoring period, and their test results may not accurately represent the in-situ material properties at the time deformation occurs (Cao et al., 2016).

where V(Ωm)V(\Omega_m) denotes the volume of the feasible material-parameter domain.

For the affine KL representation adopted in this study, the mapping from the latent-variable coefficients to the discretized material-parameter fields has a constant Jacobian. Consequently, the prior probability density induced in the feasible latent-variable space Z\mathcal Z is also uniform:

p(z)=1V(Z)IZ(z).p(\mathbf z)=\frac{1}{V(\mathcal Z)}\mathbb I_{\mathcal Z}(\mathbf z).

Posterior distribution and sampling. Assuming that the observation errors follow Gaussian distributions, the posterior distribution of the latent variables can be derived using Bayes' theorem:

\propto p(\mathbf d\mid\mathbf z)p(\mathbf z).$$ The likelihood function is given by: $$p(\mathbf d\mid\mathbf z) \propto \exp\left[ -\frac{1}{2} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d)^{\mathrm T} \mathbf\Gamma^{-1} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d) \right].$$ Substituting the uniform prior distribution yields: $$p(\mathbf z\mid\mathbf d) \propto \exp\left[ -\frac{1}{2} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d)^{\mathrm T} \mathbf\Gamma^{-1} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d) \right] \mathbb I_{\mathcal Z}(\mathbf z).$$ We employ the Metropolis–Hastings (MH) algorithm to sample from the posterior distribution of the latent variables and subsequently map the resulting latent-variable samples to their corresponding material-parameter fields (Hastings, 1970). Since the uniform prior is constant within the feasible latent-variable space, its negative logarithm is a constant independent of the optimization variables. Therefore, the MAP optimization objective in Eq. (16) can be simplified to: $$\underset{\mathbf z\in\mathcal Z}{\arg\min} \frac{1}{2} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d)^{\mathrm T} \mathbf\Gamma^{-1} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d).$$ **References** [1] Cao, Z., Wang, Y., & Li, D. (2016). Quantification of prior knowledge in geotechnical site characterization. *Engineering Geology*, 203, 107–116. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enggeo.2015.08.018 [2] Hastings, W. K. (1970). Monte Carlo sampling methods using Markov chains and their applications. *Biometrika*, 57(1), 97–109. https://doi.org/10.1093/biomet/57.1.97 ## **Response to Q2 and W1** We thank the reviewer for raising this important question. First, we would like to clarify that the numbers 1–3 refer to the number of boreholes, rather than the number of individual observation points. Each borehole contains approximately 30–40 measurement points along its depth. Therefore, the one- and three-borehole configurations correspond to approximately 30–40 and 90–120 observations, respectively. There was some ambiguity in the wording of the previous text, and we have corrected this in the revised version. To investigate the influence of spatial observation coverage on inversion results, we conducted comparative experiments under a 5% observation noise level using full-field, three-borehole, and one-borehole observation configurations. The standard deviation (SD) and coefficient of variation (CV) of the inverted material parameter fields are summarized in Table R1. **Table R1. 5% SD and CV of material parameters under monitoring noise** | Material parameter | Full field SD | Full field CV | 3 boreholes SD | 3 boreholes CV | 1 borehole SD | 1 borehole CV | | ------------------ | ------------- | ------------- | -------------- | -------------- | ------------- | ------------- | | $c_1$ (kPa) | 1.423 | 6.57% | 2.202 | 10.31% | 4.888 | 15.66% | | $\phi_1$ (°) | 0.702 | 2.62% | 1.169 | 4.15% | 1.321 | 4.26% | | $c_2$ (kPa) | 1.241 | 6.73% | 1.911 | 10.50% | 4.496 | 15.75% | | $\phi_2$ (°) | 0.705 | 3.08% | 1.210 | 4.91% | 1.342 | 4.49% | The results indicate that the variability of the inverted material parameter fields generally increases as the number of boreholes decreases. These results suggest that cohesion estimates are more affected by sparse borehole observations, whereas friction angle estimates exhibit comparatively smaller variations.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q3 and W1

We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. To further evaluate the generalization capability of the proposed method across different slope geometries and material distributions, we have extended the inversion evaluation from the original four slope cases to all 39 slope geometries in the full test split that were unseen during training.

These geometries cover conventional cases, including natural and engineered slopes, as well as out-of-distribution (OOD) geometries, such as bidirectional and large-scale slopes. For each geometry, we considered three conventional material realizations and three material variants incorporating a weak zone, resulting in a total of 234 test samples. Inversion experiments were conducted under two observation configurations, namely borehole-based and full-field observations, to evaluate the performance under different material configurations and observation conditions.

The inversion results and mean computational times are summarized in Table R2. The results show that the proposed YSNO method achieves the lowest mean displacement-fitting metric across all four combinations of material configurations (with and without weak zones) and observation settings (borehole-based and full-field).

Table R2. Inversion performance across 39 previously unseen slope geometries.

MethodWeak zone: BoreholeWeak zone: Full fieldNo weak zone: BoreholeNo weak zone: Full fieldMean optimization time (s)
GA0.4917 ± 0.14150.4774 ± 0.16010.6144 ± 0.04040.5521 ± 0.092257.16
DREAM-ZS0.4826 ± 0.19360.4588 ± 0.19460.6330 ± 0.11940.4456 ± 0.142849.81
BUS0.5011 ± 0.21310.4564 ± 0.19590.6781 ± 0.10490.4820 ± 0.174551.22
CMA-ES0.4475 ± 0.08150.7075 ± 0.21160.5123 ± 0.12150.5968 ± 0.144467.63
TEKI0.4238 ± 0.10370.8019 ± 0.47440.3992 ± 0.06710.4394 ± 0.162854.14
FNO0.3883 ± 0.10790.5962 ± 0.10390.4594 ± 0.17750.6339 ± 0.06701.297
GINO0.4447 ± 0.16171.2879 ± 0.49130.4321 ± 0.16930.8475 ± 0.26921.324
LNO0.3289 ± 0.06260.6824 ± 0.16380.5255 ± 0.33700.7138 ± 0.50082.806
Transolver0.3747 ± 0.07740.6918 ± 0.18050.4030 ± 0.16050.4953 ± 0.21108.522
MambaNO0.4197 ± 0.08920.8268 ± 0.18820.6709 ± 0.41060.7301 ± 0.20758.211
U-Net0.5429 ± 0.28571.1610 ± 0.42540.6373 ± 0.41391.2341 ± 0.58040.902
YSNO0.2726 ± 0.06180.2524 ± 0.04680.2116 ± 0.08390.2545 ± 0.09571.008
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q4 and W2

Thank you for raising this important question. We clarify that the original FNO, U-Net, and other baseline models did not use the same elastic FEM reference solutions as YSNO. To further examine the fairness of the comparison, we conducted additional experiments by providing the same elastic FEM reference information to the other baseline models, as shown in Table R3.

The supplementary results show that incorporating the elastic FEM reference information improves the prediction accuracy of strain (Δε)(\Delta\varepsilon) and stress (Δσ)(\Delta\sigma) for some baseline models. However, the improvement in displacement-difference (Δu)(\Delta u) prediction is relatively limited. This is because the displacement differences between the two loading stages obtained from the elastic FEM simulations exhibit relatively small variations, providing limited additional information for displacement prediction. The fact that the displacement prediction errors of most baseline models remain largely unchanged after incorporating this reference information further supports this observation.

It is also worth emphasizing that, although YSNO utilizes elastic FEM reference solutions, the full FEM results are not directly fed into the operator. Instead, they are compressed into a yield-aware input designed to extract information relevant to material yielding behavior. Therefore, YSNO does not directly rely on the complete elastic FEM solutions for displacement prediction; rather, it exploits the physically relevant information through its specifically designed architecture.

As demonstrated by the supplementary results, YSNO maintains clear advantages in displacement prediction accuracy and sliding-region identification (IoU). These results indicate that its improved performance cannot be attributed solely to the additional elastic reference information, but also to the proposed yield-aware input representation and operator architecture.

Table R3. Comparison of different models incorporating elastic FEM reference information.

ModelΔu\Delta u · Rel-(L_2) ↓Δε\Delta\varepsilon · Rel-L2L_2↓Δσ\Delta\sigma · Rel-L2L_2 ↓IoU@25% (Δu)(\Delta u) ↑
FNO0.637 ± 0.0430.418 ± 0.0550.089 ± 0.0230.414 ± 0.025
GINO0.697 ± 0.0600.634 ± 0.0740.125 ± 0.0130.358 ± 0.030
LNO0.679 ± 0.0730.735 ± 0.2380.212 ± 0.0400.448 ± 0.013
Transolver0.908 ± 0.2090.704 ± 0.0150.285 ± 0.0630.434 ± 0.046
U-Net0.741 ± 0.1170.632 ± 0.0570.186 ± 0.0230.400 ± 0.021
MambaNO0.586 ± 0.0580.783 ± 0.0610.162 ± 0.0140.450 ± 0.079
YSNO0.352 ± 0.0290.668 ± 0.0880.181 ± 0.0200.746 ± 0.027
Reviewer_QKKrOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

In this paper, the authors focused on the problem of forward modeling and inverse reconstruction of elastoplastic slope mechanics. They proposed a physics-informed neural operator, named YSNO, which combines a differentiable elastic finite-element reference, yield-aware local nonlinear corrections, and a source-conditioned nonlocal integral operator to predict displacement, strain, and stress fields. The trained surrogate is further incorporated into a gradient-based Bayesian inversion framework to reconstruct spatially varying material-strength parameters from displacement observations. The authors also introduced SlopeBench, a synthetic benchmark comprising 197 slope geometries and 9,828 paired two-stage elastoplastic simulations. Experimental results show improved forward prediction and material inversion compared with several neural operator baselines, along with encouraging results under limited-data, out-of-distribution, and cross-mesh evaluation settings.

Critical strengths

1. Well-motivated methodology and clear presentation

The paper is well organized and clearly written, with a logical progression from the physical problem to the proposed architecture and experimental validation. The integration of elastic FEM lifting, yield-aware local corrections, and nonlocal response modeling is physically motivated. The mathematical formulation is relatively detailed, and the individual architectural components are supported by ablations.

2. Strong experimental performance and comprehensive evaluation

YSNO achieves substantial improvements over the baselines, particularly in displacement and stress prediction and plastic-region localization. The evaluation covers multiple baselines, limited-data learning, out-of-distribution geometries, mesh-resolution variations, and downstream material inversion. The introduction of SlopeBench also provides a potentially useful resource for studying neural operators and inverse problems in an underexplored area of computational mechanics.

Critical weaknesses

1. Dependence on an elastic FEM reference and insufficient clarity regarding computational efficiency and baseline fairness

A central component of YSNO is the elastic finite-element solution, which provides a strong physical prior for predicting elastoplastic responses. While the ablation results demonstrate its importance, it is not sufficiently clear how much of the improvement over existing neural operators can be attributed to the additional physical information rather than the proposed neural architecture. A more controlled comparison in which competing neural operators receive the same elastic reference would strengthen the evaluation.

2. Limited validation of the inverse modeling framework and practical generalization

Although inverse modeling is a central motivation of the paper, the inversion experiments are conducted on only four unseen slope geometries. Moreover, the inverse problem uses a constrained, relatively low-dimensional material parameterization, with other physical quantities and the elastic companion fields held fixed. These choices limit the extent to which the reported results demonstrate general high-dimensional material-field inversion.

Questions for authors

1. Contribution of the elastic FEM reference

Could the authors clarify whether the compared neural operator baselines have access to the same elastic FEM reference fields? It would also be helpful to report the end-to-end computational cost (including the elastic FEM solve) to better quantify the practical efficiency of YSNO.

2. Robustness of material inversion

Given that the inversion experiments are limited to four held-out slope geometries, could the authors evaluate additional unseen cases and different levels of observation noise? Furthermore, how sensitive is the inversion accuracy to the dimensionality and spatial resolution of the material-field parameterization?

3. Cross-resolution generalization

The cross-resolution experiments vary the underlying Abaqus finite-element mesh while retaining a common learning representation grid. Could the authors clarify whether the trained YSNO can directly operate on different neural operator input/output resolutions without retraining?

4. Generalization to realistic mechanical conditions

How well would YSNO perform under more complex mechanical settings, such as uncertain boundary conditions, different loading histories, or coupled hydromechanical processes?

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q1 and W1

We thank the reviewer for raising this important issue. First, we clarify that the neural operator baselines in the original manuscript did not directly use elastic finite element (FEM) reference fields. To further investigate the contribution of these reference fields, we conducted additional comparative experiments by providing the elastic FEM reference fields as additional inputs to the baseline neural operators and comparing their performance with that of YSNO. The results are summarized in Table R1.

It is worth noting that although YSNO utilizes the elastic FEM results, it does not directly feed the complete reference fields into the operator. Instead, this information is encoded into a compact yield-aware input. In contrast, the baseline models in the supplementary experiments directly receive the elastic FEM reference fields and thus have access to more comprehensive reference information.

The results show that some baseline models achieve better performance in strain and stress prediction. However, directly incorporating the elastic reference fields does not lead to better displacement-increment predictions. In contrast, YSNO achieves the best performance among all compared methods in both the relative L2L_2 error of Δu\Delta u and the IoU metric, with values of 0.352 and 0.746, respectively.

This observation is closely related to practical engineering requirements. In actual slope monitoring, the primary quantity of interest is the displacement increment between different monitoring stages. Meanwhile, the displacement difference between the two stages obtained from the elastic FEM solution is relatively small, providing limited additional information for predicting the target displacement increment. These results further demonstrate the effectiveness of the YSNO architecture.

Regarding computational efficiency, we evaluated the computational cost on an NVIDIA RTX 4080 GPU with a batch size of 4. The average per-sample forward-pass time of the six baseline models ranged from 5 to 25 ms, while the YSNO operator required only 17 ms. The elastic FEM reference-field computation took 179 ms, resulting in a total forward-pass time of 196 ms for YSNO. It is worth noting that, in practical inversion, the key unknown parameters are the material strength parameters rather than the elastic parameters. Therefore, the elastic FEM reference field only needs to be computed once and can then be reused throughout multiple YSNO operator iterations without repeated FEM solutions. Thus, although incorporating the FEM reference field increases the computational cost of a single forward evaluation, its impact on the overall inversion efficiency is limited.

Table R1. Comparison of different models incorporating elastic FEM reference information.

ModelΔu\Delta u · Rel-L2L_2 ↓Δε\Delta\varepsilon · Rel-L2L_2↓Δσ\Delta\sigma · Rel-L2L_2 ↓IoU@25% (Δu)(\Delta u) ↑
FNO0.637 ± 0.0430.418 ± 0.0550.089 ± 0.0230.414 ± 0.025
GINO0.697 ± 0.0600.634 ± 0.0740.125 ± 0.0130.358 ± 0.030
LNO0.679 ± 0.0730.735 ± 0.2380.212 ± 0.0400.448 ± 0.013
Transolver0.908 ± 0.2090.704 ± 0.0150.285 ± 0.0630.434 ± 0.046
U-Net0.741 ± 0.1170.632 ± 0.0570.186 ± 0.0230.400 ± 0.021
MambaNO0.586 ± 0.0580.783 ± 0.0610.162 ± 0.0140.450 ± 0.079
YSNO0.352 ± 0.0290.668 ± 0.0880.181 ± 0.0200.746 ± 0.027
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q2 and W2 (Part 1/2)

To systematically evaluate the robustness of the proposed material inversion method, we conducted additional experiments from three perspectives: generalization to previously unseen slope geometries, sensitivity to observation noise, and sensitivity to the parameterization dimensionality and spatial resolution of the material parameter fields.

(1) Inversion robustness on additional unseen slopes

We expanded the inversion evaluation from the original four slope geometries to all 39 previously unseen slope geometries in the full test split. These geometries cover conventional cases, including natural and engineered slopes, as well as out-of-distribution (OOD) cases, such as bidirectional and large-scale slopes. For each geometry, we constructed three conventional material samples and three material variants containing weak zones, resulting in a total of 234 test samples (39 × 6).

We performed inversion experiments for material fields with and without weak zones using both borehole-based and full-field observations, and compared the proposed method with multiple optimization algorithms and neural operator baselines. As shown in Table R2, YSNO achieved the best displacement-fitting performance across all four evaluation settings, with corresponding metric values of 0.2726 ± 0.0618, 0.2524 ± 0.0468, 0.2116 ± 0.0839, and 0.2545 ± 0.0957. Its average optimization time was only 1.008 s. These results demonstrate favorable inversion performance across different slope geometries and material-field configurations.

(2) Robustness under different observation noise levels

To investigate the influence of observation noise on material parameter recovery, we considered four monitoring noise levels (0%, 1%, 5%, and 10%) under both full-field and three-borehole observation configurations. The absolute and relative errors of the recovered material parameters are summarized in Table R3.

The inversion errors generally increase with the monitoring noise level. Overall, although observation noise reduces the accuracy of material parameter recovery, the proposed method retains reasonable inversion robustness even under relatively high noise levels.

(3) Sensitivity to parameterization dimensionality and spatial resolution

Furthermore, we investigated the influence of parameterization dimensionality by varying the spatial discretization resolution of the material parameter fields. Experiments were conducted using both synthetic monitoring data and real slope monitoring data, with spatial resolutions of 4 m, 2 m, 1 m, and 0.5 m. The corresponding results are presented in Table R4.

The results show that the inversion accuracy using synthetic data is relatively insensitive to changes in spatial resolution. In contrast, the inversion accuracy using real monitoring data exhibits greater sensitivity to spatial resolution.

This difference may be attributed to the more complex localized deformation characteristics present in actual slopes. Compared with synthetic data, real monitoring data contain more information associated with localized slip surfaces and shear-band deformation, requiring adequate spatial resolution to capture these features.

In summary, these additional experiments demonstrate the robustness of the proposed method in terms of generalization to unseen slope geometries, tolerance to observation noise, and adaptability to different spatial discretizations. They also reveal the importance of selecting an appropriate spatial resolution when performing material parameter inversion using real slope monitoring data.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q2 and W2 (Part 2/2)

Table R2. Inversion performance across 39 previously unseen slope geometries

MethodWeak zone: BoreholeWeak zone: Full fieldNo weak zone: BoreholeNo weak zone: Full fieldMean optimization time (s)
GA0.4917 ± 0.14150.4774 ± 0.16010.6144 ± 0.04040.5521 ± 0.092257.16
DREAM-ZS0.4826 ± 0.19360.4588 ± 0.19460.6330 ± 0.11940.4456 ± 0.142849.81
BUS0.5011 ± 0.21310.4564 ± 0.19590.6781 ± 0.10490.4820 ± 0.174551.22
CMA-ES0.4475 ± 0.08150.7075 ± 0.21160.5123 ± 0.12150.5968 ± 0.144467.63
TEKI0.4238 ± 0.10370.8019 ± 0.47440.3992 ± 0.06710.4394 ± 0.162854.14
FNO0.3883 ± 0.10790.5962 ± 0.10390.4594 ± 0.17750.6339 ± 0.06701.297
GINO0.4447 ± 0.16171.2879 ± 0.49130.4321 ± 0.16930.8475 ± 0.26921.324
LNO0.3289 ± 0.06260.6824 ± 0.16380.5255 ± 0.33700.7138 ± 0.50082.806
Transolver0.3747 ± 0.07740.6918 ± 0.18050.4030 ± 0.16050.4953 ± 0.21108.522
MambaNO0.4197 ± 0.08920.8268 ± 0.18820.6709 ± 0.41060.7301 ± 0.20758.211
U-Net0.5429 ± 0.28571.1610 ± 0.42540.6373 ± 0.41391.2341 ± 0.58040.902
YSNO0.2726 ± 0.06180.2524 ± 0.04680.2116 ± 0.08390.2545 ± 0.09571.008

Note: The fitting metrics are reported as mean ± standard deviation.

Table R3. Sensitivity of material parameter inversion to observation noise

(a) Full-field observations

Noise levelc1c_1 (kPa / %)ϕ1\phi_1 (° / %)c2c_2 (kPa / %)ϕ2\phi_2 (° / %)
0%1.130 / 5.28%0.556 / 2.08%0.982 / 5.38%0.552 / 2.41%
1%1.193 / 5.59%0.606 / 2.26%1.038 / 5.70%0.608 / 2.66%
5%1.423 / 6.57%0.702 / 2.62%1.241 / 6.73%0.705 / 3.08%
10%1.980 / 9.08%0.964 / 3.62%1.734 / 9.34%0.958 / 4.21%

(b) Three-borehole observations

Noise levelc1c_1 (kPa / %)ϕ1\phi_1 (° / %)c2c_2 (kPa / %)ϕ2\phi_2 (° / %)
0%1.931 / 9.04%1.037 / 3.68%1.673 / 9.22%1.069 / 4.33%
1%1.941 / 9.09%0.996 / 3.53%1.681 / 9.26%1.038 / 4.20%
5%2.202 / 10.31%1.169 / 4.15%1.911 / 10.50%1.210 / 4.91%
10%2.706 / 12.52%1.442 / 5.13%2.356 / 12.83%1.468 / 5.98%

Note: Each entry reports the standard deviation followed by the coefficient of variation.

Table R4. Sensitivity of inversion performance to spatial resolution

Data type4h4h (4 m)2h2h (2 m)hh (1 m)h/2h/2 (0.5 m)
Real monitoring data3.55 ± 0.332.40 ± 1.191.67 ± 0.721.86 ± 0.94
Synthetic data0.65 ± 0.420.64 ± 0.460.58 ± 0.400.52 ± 0.35

Note: Values are reported as mean ± standard deviation.

Reviewer_2T6jOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces YSNO, a neural operator for predicting elastoplastic responses in slopes and estimating spatially varying material properties from displacement observations. The authors also build SlopeBench, a finite-element simulation dataset for forward prediction and material inversion. Results show improvements over several neural operator baselines, although the evidence for real-world applicability and material inversion remains limited.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses an important problem and combines physical reference solutions with learned local and nonlocal corrections. This is a reasonable approach for modeling complex mechanical responses.

  2. SlopeBench supports both forward prediction and inverse estimation. The experiments compare YSNO with several baselines and include limited-data, out-of-distribution, and cross-resolution evaluations.

Critical weaknesses
  1. SlopeBench is generated using finite-element simulations rather than real monitoring data. Although the dataset covers different slope geometries and material configurations, it remains unclear how well the results transfer to actual slopes, where the material properties and physical conditions may differ from the simulated settings.

  2. The inverse evaluation is conducted on only four held-out slope profiles. This is a limited basis for assessing whether the method can reliably recover material fields across different geometries and observation conditions. More evaluation cases would make the conclusions more convincing.

Questions for authors
  1. Is there any evidence that YSNO generalizes to real slope-monitoring data, or can the authors discuss the main challenges in transferring the method to such data?

  2. Can the authors evaluate material inversion on more held-out slope profiles to demonstrate the robustness of the results?

  3. Beyond the reported point estimates, can the proposed Bayesian inversion provide meaningful uncertainty estimates for the recovered material fields?

10 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q1 and W1

We thank the reviewer for raising this important issue. To further evaluate the applicability of the proposed model to real engineering slopes, we conducted additional validation using field monitoring data from actual slopes and compared the YSNO-inverted results with the corresponding field measurements. The error metrics and comparisons of maximum displacements are summarized in Table R1.

The RMSE values across the 12 sites range from 1.307 to 8.415 mm, while the NRMSE values range from 5.28% to 40.41%. The inverted maximum displacements are consistently lower than the measured values, with peak deviations ranging from −0.83% to −37.33%. These results indicate that the proposed model can reproduce the monitored displacement responses to some extent at most sites.

Furthermore, the discrepancies between actual slope behavior and finite element simulations are also related to their underlying deformation mechanisms. Finite element simulations generally adopt a continuum-based representation, in which deformation is characterized by a continuously distributed field within the geomaterial. In actual slopes, however, particularly those containing distinct weak interlayers or localized shear zones, displacement may be concentrated along a localized shear band. Consequently, the soil mass above the shear band may exhibit approximately rigid-body translation, while most of the shear deformation is concentrated within the relatively thin shear band (Ruggeri et al. ,2020; Vassallo et al. , 2020).

Consequently, this model is capable of simulating the majority of displacement monitoring data from stable slopes; however, for large-deformation slopes on the verge of instability, the interaction between rigid-body sliding deformation and distributed deformation within the medium remains a challenge to be addressed in future research.

Table R1. Validation results using field monitoring data from actual slopes

Index of slopeNo. of BoreholesRMSE (mm)NRMSE (%)Measured Maximum Displacement (mm)YSNO-Inverted Maximum Displacement (mm)Peak Displacement Deviation (%)
0111.67815.4416.47913.861−15.88
0233.3497.6667.37566.814−0.83
0312.38324.6722.98416.348−28.87
0418.41540.4165.11154.851−15.76
0512.05312.5733.48130.098−10.10
0612.28828.9421.07319.602−6.98
0711.3078.0634.91633.514−4.01
0812.0155.2872.54566.192−8.76
0911.91015.2334.78131.865−8.38
1021.4035.5249.32547.643−3.41
1121.49932.869.4315.910−37.33
1231.66525.3317.15114.473−15.62

References

Ruggeri, P., Fruzzetti, V. M. E., Ferretti, A., & Scarpelli, G. (2020). Seismic and rainfall induced displacements of an existing landslide: Findings from the continuous monitoring. Geosciences, 10(3), 90. https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences10030090

Vassallo, R., Calcaterra, S., D'Agostino, N., De Rosa, J., Di Maio, C., & Gambino, P. (2020). Long-term displacement monitoring of slow earthflows by inclinometers and GPS, and wide area surveillance by COSMO-SkyMed data. Geosciences, 10(5), 171. https://doi.org/10.3390/geosciences10050171

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q2 and W2

We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. To further evaluate the generalization capability and robustness of the proposed material inversion method on previously unseen slope profiles, we expanded the evaluation from the original four slope geometries to all 39 slope geometries in the full test split that were not encountered during training.

These geometries cover both conventional cases, such as natural and engineered slopes, and out-of-distribution (OOD) cases, including bidirectional and large-scale slopes. For each slope geometry, we constructed three conventional material samples and three material variants containing weak zones, resulting in a total of 234 test samples (39 × 6). Based on this dataset, we conducted inversion experiments using both borehole-based and full-field observations, considering material fields with and without weak zones. The proposed method was also compared with multiple baseline approaches.

As shown in Table R2, YSNO achieved the best fitting performance across all four evaluation settings, with corresponding metric values of 0.2726 ± 0.0618, 0.2524 ± 0.0468, 0.2116 ± 0.0839, and 0.2545 ± 0.0957. Meanwhile, its average optimization time was only 1.008 s, substantially shorter than those of the optimization-based approaches combining GA, DREAM-ZS, BUS, CMA-ES, and TEKI with YSNO (49.81–67.63 s). Its computational time was also comparable to those of the other direct surrogate-model-based methods.

These results demonstrate that the proposed method maintains favorable inversion performance across different slope geometries, material-field configurations, and observation settings, supporting its generalization capability and robustness when applied to previously unseen slopes.

Table R2. Comparison of inversion performance across 39 previously unseen slope geometries

MethodWeak zone: BoreholeWeak zone: Full fieldNo weak zone: BoreholeNo weak zone: Full fieldMean optimization time (s)
GA0.4917 ± 0.14150.4774 ± 0.16010.6144 ± 0.04040.5521 ± 0.092257.16
DREAM-ZS0.4826 ± 0.19360.4588 ± 0.19460.6330 ± 0.11940.4456 ± 0.142849.81
BUS0.5011 ± 0.21310.4564 ± 0.19590.6781 ± 0.10490.4820 ± 0.174551.22
CMA-ES0.4475 ± 0.08150.7075 ± 0.21160.5123 ± 0.12150.5968 ± 0.144467.63
TEKI0.4238 ± 0.10370.8019 ± 0.47440.3992 ± 0.06710.4394 ± 0.162854.14
DI+FNO0.3883 ± 0.10790.5962 ± 0.10390.4594 ± 0.17750.6339 ± 0.06701.297
DI+GINO0.4447 ± 0.16171.2879 ± 0.49130.4321 ± 0.16930.8475 ± 0.26921.324
DI+LNO0.3289 ± 0.06260.6824 ± 0.16380.5255 ± 0.33700.7138 ± 0.50082.806
DI+Transolver0.3747 ± 0.07740.6918 ± 0.18050.4030 ± 0.16050.4953 ± 0.21108.522
DI+MambaNO0.4197 ± 0.08920.8268 ± 0.18820.6709 ± 0.41060.7301 ± 0.20758.211
DI+U-Net0.5429 ± 0.28571.1610 ± 0.42540.6373 ± 0.41391.2341 ± 0.58040.902
DI+YSNO0.2726 ± 0.06180.2524 ± 0.04680.2116 ± 0.08390.2545 ± 0.09571.008

Note: The first four columns report the displacement-fitting evaluation metric (mean ± standard deviation).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Q3

Thank you for this valuable comment. In addition to the point estimates reported in the manuscript, the proposed Bayesian inversion framework can also provide uncertainty quantification for the recovered material parameter field. Specifically, Eq. (16) defines the posterior distribution of the 128-dimensional material parameters. When both model error and monitoring error are taken into account, the posterior distribution can be written as

p(z∣d)∝p(d∣z) p(z),p(\mathbf{z}\mid \mathbf{d}) \propto p(\mathbf{d}\mid \mathbf{z})\,p(\mathbf{z}),

where the likelihood function is given by

\exp\left[ -\frac{1}{2} \big(\hat{\mathbf{d}}(\mathbf{z})-\mathbf{d}\big)^{\mathrm T} \mathbf{\Gamma}^{-1} \big(\hat{\mathbf{d}}(\mathbf{z})-\mathbf{d}\big) \right].$$ Here, $\mathbf{d}$ denotes the monitoring data, $\hat{\mathbf{d}}(\mathbf{z})$ is the model prediction for a given parameter vector $\mathbf{z}$, and $\mathbf{\Gamma}$ is the total error covariance matrix. Assuming that the errors are mutually independent and Gaussian, the covariance can be decomposed as $$\mathbf{\Gamma} = \Gamma_{\mathrm{mon}} + \Gamma_{\mathrm{sur}}$$ where $\Gamma_{\mathrm{mon}}$ is the covariance of the monitoring error, and $\Gamma_{\mathrm{sur}}$ is the covariance of the surrogate-model error. In this study, the monitoring error is simulated using Gaussian noise at different levels, while the surrogate-model error is estimated from the standard deviation of the residuals on the test set. Based on this posterior distribution, we further performed uncertainty analysis for each inversion test slope under a 5% monitoring-noise level. Table R3 summarizes the mean posterior standard deviation (SD) and coefficient of variation (CV) of the main material parameters. The results show that the parameter uncertainty increases noticeably as the amount of observation information decreases. These results indicate that the proposed method can not only recover point estimates of the material parameters, but also provide meaningful uncertainty quantification for the inferred parameter field under different observation conditions. Furthermore, the posterior parameter samples can be propagated into Abaqus to obtain the probability distribution of the factor of safety, which can then be used to assess the probability of slope instability. **Table R3. Uncertainty estimates of the main material parameters** | Material parameter | Full-field SD | Full-field CV | 3-borehole SD | 3-borehole CV | 1-borehole SD | 1-borehole CV | | ------------------ | ------------: | ------------: | ------------: | ------------: | ------------: | ------------: | | $c_1$ (kPa) | 1.423 | 6.57% | 2.202 | 10.31% | 4.888 | 15.66% | | $\phi_1$ (°) | 0.702 | 2.62% | 1.169 | 4.15% | 1.321 | 4.26% | | $c_2$ (kPa) | 1.241 | 6.73% | 1.911 | 10.50% | 4.496 | 15.75% | | $\phi_2$ (°) | 0.705 | 3.08% | 1.210 | 4.91% | 1.342 | 4.49% |

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response to All Reviewers

We sincerely thank all reviewers for their careful evaluations and constructive suggestions. Below, we summarize our core contributions and the additional experiments and clarifications addressing the main concerns. Revisions in the manuscript are marked in blue.

Core Contributions of Our Work

  1. Yield-aware neural operator. We propose YSNO, integrating differentiable FEM physics, yield-aware local corrections, and nonlocal interactions for elastoplastic slope modeling and material inversion.
  2. SlopeBench benchmark. We establish a paired FEM benchmark comprising 197 slope geometries and 9,828 simulations, supporting both forward prediction and material inversion.
  3. Differentiable inversion framework. YSNO enables gradient-based Bayesian inversion of spatially varying material properties from displacement observations.

Additional Experimental Evidence

  • Real-world validation. We evaluate YSNO using monitoring data from 12 actual slopes, demonstrating its ability to reproduce field displacement responses.
  • Robust material inversion. We extend inversion tests from 4 to 39 unseen slope geometries, covering 234 material configurations, and investigate different observation conditions. Additional results directly evaluate material-field recovery under joint inversion and stage-1-informed inversion, achieving mean NMAEs of 25.7% and 6.3%, respectively. YSNO achieves the lowest recovery error across all eight parameter–setting pairs.
  • Uncertainty quantification. We analyze posterior uncertainty under different monitoring noise levels and observation configurations.
  • Baseline fairness and generalization. We provide elastic FEM references to competing baselines, evaluate cross-resolution generalization without retraining, and test adaptation to the Drucker–Prager yield criterion.

Analyses and Clarifications

  • We clarify the latent-variable prior, observation information content, and the role of elastic FEM references.
  • We report computational costs, discuss boundary conditions, loading history, and hydro-mechanical coupling, and clarify the limitations of real-world applications.
  • We address reproducibility by preparing to provide the source code, datasets, and exact data splits.
  • We clarify the ill-posedness of joint material-field inversion, the latent-variable prior, observation information content, and the role of elastic FEM references. We further explain how stage-1 geological information and Kriging-based conditional random fields can provide informative priors for subsequent inversion.
  • We discuss the engineering implications of material-field uncertainty, including its propagation to factor-of-safety estimation and failure probability for landslide early warning. We also demonstrate how the framework can help determine the required amount of prior information and guide borehole investigations and monitoring layouts for critical slopes.

We hope these additional results and clarifications adequately address the reviewers' concerns. We sincerely thank all reviewers again for their valuable feedback, which has helped us improve the rigor and completeness of this work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.