- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3(+1)
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes YSNO for slope response prediction and material inversion, and evaluates it on the new SlopeBench dataset.
Critical strengths
YSNO combines elastic FEM with learned nonlinear corrections and achieves lower displacement and stress errors than the tested baselines.
Critical weaknesses
Only 1 to 3 displacement points are used to recover 128 parameters. The results may mainly depend on the training distribution and parameterization. The prior p(z) is not specified, and there is no prior only baseline. Inversion is tested on only four cases, without testing different material distributions.
YSNO uses an elastic FEM reference, but no standard neural operator is compared using the same reference. The improvement from the proposed architecture is unclear.
Questions for authors
-
What is the prior p(z) in Eq. (16)? Is the prior term in Eq. (16) included in the actual inversion experiments?
-
How sensitive are the inversion results to the latent parameterization and training material distribution, given only 1 to 3 observations for 128 parameters?
-
Can the authors provide inversion results on more than four cases, including different material distributions?
-
Do baselines, such as FNO and U-Net, use the same elastic FEM reference as YSNO? If not, is the comparison fair?
-
Can the authors provide the code, dataset, and data splits during the rebuttal so that reviewers can verify the results?
8 comments
Response to Q3 and W1
We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. To further evaluate the generalization capability of the proposed method across different slope geometries and material distributions, we have extended the inversion evaluation from the original four slope cases to all 39 slope geometries in the full test split that were unseen during training.
These geometries cover conventional cases, including natural and engineered slopes, as well as out-of-distribution (OOD) geometries, such as bidirectional and large-scale slopes. For each geometry, we considered three conventional material realizations and three material variants incorporating a weak zone, resulting in a total of 234 test samples. Inversion experiments were conducted under two observation configurations, namely borehole-based and full-field observations, to evaluate the performance under different material configurations and observation conditions.
The inversion results and mean computational times are summarized in Table R2. The results show that the proposed YSNO method achieves the lowest mean displacement-fitting metric across all four combinations of material configurations (with and without weak zones) and observation settings (borehole-based and full-field).
Table R2. Inversion performance across 39 previously unseen slope geometries.
| Method | Weak zone: Borehole | Weak zone: Full field | No weak zone: Borehole | No weak zone: Full field | Mean optimization time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GA | 0.4917 ± 0.1415 | 0.4774 ± 0.1601 | 0.6144 ± 0.0404 | 0.5521 ± 0.0922 | 57.16 |
| DREAM-ZS | 0.4826 ± 0.1936 | 0.4588 ± 0.1946 | 0.6330 ± 0.1194 | 0.4456 ± 0.1428 | 49.81 |
| BUS | 0.5011 ± 0.2131 | 0.4564 ± 0.1959 | 0.6781 ± 0.1049 | 0.4820 ± 0.1745 | 51.22 |
| CMA-ES | 0.4475 ± 0.0815 | 0.7075 ± 0.2116 | 0.5123 ± 0.1215 | 0.5968 ± 0.1444 | 67.63 |
| TEKI | 0.4238 ± 0.1037 | 0.8019 ± 0.4744 | 0.3992 ± 0.0671 | 0.4394 ± 0.1628 | 54.14 |
| FNO | 0.3883 ± 0.1079 | 0.5962 ± 0.1039 | 0.4594 ± 0.1775 | 0.6339 ± 0.0670 | 1.297 |
| GINO | 0.4447 ± 0.1617 | 1.2879 ± 0.4913 | 0.4321 ± 0.1693 | 0.8475 ± 0.2692 | 1.324 |
| LNO | 0.3289 ± 0.0626 | 0.6824 ± 0.1638 | 0.5255 ± 0.3370 | 0.7138 ± 0.5008 | 2.806 |
| Transolver | 0.3747 ± 0.0774 | 0.6918 ± 0.1805 | 0.4030 ± 0.1605 | 0.4953 ± 0.2110 | 8.522 |
| MambaNO | 0.4197 ± 0.0892 | 0.8268 ± 0.1882 | 0.6709 ± 0.4106 | 0.7301 ± 0.2075 | 8.211 |
| U-Net | 0.5429 ± 0.2857 | 1.1610 ± 0.4254 | 0.6373 ± 0.4139 | 1.2341 ± 0.5804 | 0.902 |
| YSNO | 0.2726 ± 0.0618 | 0.2524 ± 0.0468 | 0.2116 ± 0.0839 | 0.2545 ± 0.0957 | 1.008 |
Response to Q4 and W2
Thank you for raising this important question. We clarify that the original FNO, U-Net, and other baseline models did not use the same elastic FEM reference solutions as YSNO. To further examine the fairness of the comparison, we conducted additional experiments by providing the same elastic FEM reference information to the other baseline models, as shown in Table R3.
The supplementary results show that incorporating the elastic FEM reference information improves the prediction accuracy of strain and stress for some baseline models. However, the improvement in displacement-difference prediction is relatively limited. This is because the displacement differences between the two loading stages obtained from the elastic FEM simulations exhibit relatively small variations, providing limited additional information for displacement prediction. The fact that the displacement prediction errors of most baseline models remain largely unchanged after incorporating this reference information further supports this observation.
It is also worth emphasizing that, although YSNO utilizes elastic FEM reference solutions, the full FEM results are not directly fed into the operator. Instead, they are compressed into a yield-aware input designed to extract information relevant to material yielding behavior. Therefore, YSNO does not directly rely on the complete elastic FEM solutions for displacement prediction; rather, it exploits the physically relevant information through its specifically designed architecture.
As demonstrated by the supplementary results, YSNO maintains clear advantages in displacement prediction accuracy and sliding-region identification (IoU). These results indicate that its improved performance cannot be attributed solely to the additional elastic reference information, but also to the proposed yield-aware input representation and operator architecture.
Table R3. Comparison of different models incorporating elastic FEM reference information.
| Model | · Rel-(L_2) ↓ | · Rel-↓ | · Rel- ↓ | IoU@25% ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FNO | 0.637 ± 0.043 | 0.418 ± 0.055 | 0.089 ± 0.023 | 0.414 ± 0.025 |
| GINO | 0.697 ± 0.060 | 0.634 ± 0.074 | 0.125 ± 0.013 | 0.358 ± 0.030 |
| LNO | 0.679 ± 0.073 | 0.735 ± 0.238 | 0.212 ± 0.040 | 0.448 ± 0.013 |
| Transolver | 0.908 ± 0.209 | 0.704 ± 0.015 | 0.285 ± 0.063 | 0.434 ± 0.046 |
| U-Net | 0.741 ± 0.117 | 0.632 ± 0.057 | 0.186 ± 0.023 | 0.400 ± 0.021 |
| MambaNO | 0.586 ± 0.058 | 0.783 ± 0.061 | 0.162 ± 0.014 | 0.450 ± 0.079 |
| YSNO | 0.352 ± 0.029 | 0.668 ± 0.088 | 0.181 ± 0.020 | 0.746 ± 0.027 |
Response to Q1, Q2 and W1
Response to Q1 and W1
We thank the reviewer for raising this important question. We provide the following clarifications.
Prior distribution. In the absence of reliable site-specific geological information, we adopt a non-informative uniform prior distribution for the soil material-parameter fields within their physically admissible ranges. This choice is motivated by the fact that conventional geotechnical investigation reports are often not contemporaneous with the actual monitoring period, and their test results may not accurately represent the in-situ material properties at the time deformation occurs (Cao et al., 2016).
where V(Ωm) denotes the volume of the feasible material-parameter domain.
For the affine KL representation adopted in this study, the mapping from the latent-variable coefficients to the discretized material-parameter fields has a constant Jacobian. Consequently, the prior probability density induced in the feasible latent-variable space Z is also uniform:
p(z)=V(Z)1IZ(z).
Posterior distribution and sampling. Assuming that the observation errors follow Gaussian distributions, the posterior distribution of the latent variables can be derived using Bayes' theorem:
\propto p(\mathbf d\mid\mathbf z)p(\mathbf z).$$ The likelihood function is given by: $$p(\mathbf d\mid\mathbf z) \propto \exp\left[ -\frac{1}{2} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d)^{\mathrm T} \mathbf\Gamma^{-1} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d) \right].$$ Substituting the uniform prior distribution yields: $$p(\mathbf z\mid\mathbf d) \propto \exp\left[ -\frac{1}{2} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d)^{\mathrm T} \mathbf\Gamma^{-1} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d) \right] \mathbb I_{\mathcal Z}(\mathbf z).$$ We employ the Metropolis–Hastings (MH) algorithm to sample from the posterior distribution of the latent variables and subsequently map the resulting latent-variable samples to their corresponding material-parameter fields (Hastings, 1970). Since the uniform prior is constant within the feasible latent-variable space, its negative logarithm is a constant independent of the optimization variables. Therefore, the MAP optimization objective in Eq. (16) can be simplified to: $$\underset{\mathbf z\in\mathcal Z}{\arg\min} \frac{1}{2} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d)^{\mathrm T} \mathbf\Gamma^{-1} (\hat{\mathbf d}(\mathbf z)-\mathbf d).$$ **References** [1] Cao, Z., Wang, Y., & Li, D. (2016). Quantification of prior knowledge in geotechnical site characterization. *Engineering Geology*, 203, 107–116. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enggeo.2015.08.018 [2] Hastings, W. K. (1970). Monte Carlo sampling methods using Markov chains and their applications. *Biometrika*, 57(1), 97–109. https://doi.org/10.1093/biomet/57.1.97 ## **Response to Q2 and W1** We thank the reviewer for raising this important question. First, we would like to clarify that the numbers 1–3 refer to the number of boreholes, rather than the number of individual observation points. Each borehole contains approximately 30–40 measurement points along its depth. Therefore, the one- and three-borehole configurations correspond to approximately 30–40 and 90–120 observations, respectively. There was some ambiguity in the wording of the previous text, and we have corrected this in the revised version. To investigate the influence of spatial observation coverage on inversion results, we conducted comparative experiments under a 5% observation noise level using full-field, three-borehole, and one-borehole observation configurations. The standard deviation (SD) and coefficient of variation (CV) of the inverted material parameter fields are summarized in Table R1. **Table R1. 5% SD and CV of material parameters under monitoring noise** | Material parameter | Full field SD | Full field CV | 3 boreholes SD | 3 boreholes CV | 1 borehole SD | 1 borehole CV | | ------------------ | ------------- | ------------- | -------------- | -------------- | ------------- | ------------- | | $c_1$ (kPa) | 1.423 | 6.57% | 2.202 | 10.31% | 4.888 | 15.66% | | $\phi_1$ (°) | 0.702 | 2.62% | 1.169 | 4.15% | 1.321 | 4.26% | | $c_2$ (kPa) | 1.241 | 6.73% | 1.911 | 10.50% | 4.496 | 15.75% | | $\phi_2$ (°) | 0.705 | 3.08% | 1.210 | 4.91% | 1.342 | 4.49% | The results indicate that the variability of the inverted material parameter fields generally increases as the number of boreholes decreases. These results suggest that cohesion estimates are more affected by sparse borehole observations, whereas friction angle estimates exhibit comparatively smaller variations.