- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This study investigates the prediction of surface subsidence in mining areas using early InSAR observations and proposes a multimodal physics-based posterior inference framework. The framework fuses deformation maps, observation statistics, and geological and mining conditions to estimate the probability distributions of the maximum subsidence magnitude and its growth rate. Future deformation is then generated through temporal evolution and spatial subsidence models, and prediction intervals are constructed via parameter sampling.
Critical strengths
-
The use of physical parameters to bridge multimodal information and future prediction constitutes a well-targeted modeling strategy. Geological conditions provide external complementary information to early deformation observations, while parameter distributions are employed to characterize uncertainty in predictions.
-
The ablation settings are aligned with the core design. Comparisons between numerical and textual representations help disentangle the roles of information sources and representation modalities, whereas comparisons among deterministic regression, posterior mean, and posterior sampling support the assessment of probabilistic learning and uncertainty propagation.
-
The manuscript is clearly structured, with the framework diagram, spatial prediction comparisons, and temporal curves mutually complementing each other. The evaluation covers parameter estimation, deformation prediction, and the quality of prediction intervals, offering a relatively comprehensive presentation of the results.
Critical weaknesses
- The posterior learning objective is not described with sufficient specificity. Section 4.1 mentions parameter regression and distribution learning, but the loss formulation and the way it is combined with the physical fitting objective are not explicitly provided. These definitions should be supplemented to facilitate the understanding of the gains from probabilistic learning in Table 3.
- Certain definitions in the physics module require clarification. If Eq. (21) adopts the Euclidean norm and the integration domain does not vary with the direction angle, the rotation term will not alter the kernel function; likewise, under the definition of the predicted quantities provided in the paper, Eq. (25) and Eq. (27) are mathematically equivalent. It is recommended to clarify how the direction parameter acts and to explain the rationale for the separate design of the two loss terms.
Other issues: The temporal split of the data, the length of historical observations, and the prediction horizon should be explicitly specified to facilitate understanding of the task setup. In addition, the publication years and reference information for some methods in Table 4 need to be verified.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses