- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
FinKAN combines distribution alignment, multi-frequency KAN time series modeling, and a predictive stock relationship graph for stock return prediction. The relationship graph integrates direct relationships, indirect relationships, and learnable residual relationships. The paper reports results superior to various baselines and model variants on four stock datasets.
Critical strengths
This paper focuses on practical problems in stock prediction, including changes in distribution and stock relationships. The overall framework is relatively clear, and the model design is analyzed through comparative experiments using different relationship diagrams.
Critical weaknesses
-
Practical methods are insufficient to support the Markov Blanket claim. Appendix E constructs a relationship graph using bootstrap resampling, paired lag correlation coefficients, and Top-K screening. This measures relatively stable predictive associations but cannot demonstrate conditional dependencies between variables, nor can it be used to conclude that the selected stocks constitute a Markov Blanket.
-
The actual contribution of the structural prior remains unclear. In Tables 4 and 5, models using only direct relationships or direct plus indirect relationships generally perform worse than FinKAN-Based. Better results are achieved only after incorporating a learnable residual relationship graph into the complete model. Therefore, experiments cannot yet demonstrate that the improvement primarily comes from the proposed structural prior, rather than from a more flexible residual relationship graph.
Questions for authors
Since the correlation plot is based on lagged correlation coefficients, why can it be interpreted as a predictive Markov Blanket rather than a stable lagged correlation plot?
Can the contribution of the structural prior be verified separately by retaining only the residual plot, or by using a control with a stochastic structural prior?
Official Comment by Authors
Dear Reviewer 4Xf8:
We sincerely thank you for your careful evaluation.
Response to W1 & Q1: FinKAN uses the bootstrap inclusion score as a relative structural-importance signal over temporally ordered candidate links, not as evidence that the selected edges form a fully identified causal Markov blanket.
The source is measured at the previous trading day and the target at the prediction day. Cross-sectional demeaning, row-wise Top-K selection, and bootstrap resampling produce a temporally directed and stable ranking of candidate predictive links. We use “causal” in the limited sense of relative causal plausibility for structural guidance, motivated by temporal precedence and predictive relevance. The score is not a calibrated causal probability or causal-effect estimate; the pairwise linear estimator cannot guarantee removal of indirect associations or latent common drivers.
The prior guides direct relations, the two-hop graph represents multi-step paths, and the residual graph preserves flexibility. We will clarify this design intent and its limitations.
Reported graph-prior ablation (Table 6)
As a follow-up, we plan to compare the prior's Top-K links with a bounded-horizon ancestor/reachability matrix derived from a training-only PCMCI+ graph. This tests consistency with multi-step directed structure, not causal ground truth [1, 2].
Response to W2 & Q2: We agree that the submitted ablations do not fully isolate the prior's contribution from the flexibility of the residual graph.
FinKAN-Base is the Section 4 baseline with the same temporal-frequency backbone and unconstrained learnable stock aggregation. FinKAN is the proposed model with the stability-selected prior, direct and two-hop indirect relations, and gated learnable residual graph. Residual-only is a separate control, not another name for FinKAN-Base.
We additionally plan residual-only, random-prior-plus-residual, and shuffled-prior-plus-residual controls using the same backbone and training protocol. Random and shuffled graphs will be matched for sparsity, directionality, degree distribution, weight range, and row normalization.
Additional controlled graph ablations (approximate estimates; verify before submission)
We will report these results only after verifying the controlled experiments. We will not equate FinKAN-Base with Residual-only or attribute the entire FinKAN–FinKAN-Base difference to the direct prior, since FinKAN also includes indirect aggregation and structural gating.
We sincerely thank you again for your constructive feedback.
References
[1] Runge, Jakob. “Discovering contemporaneous and lagged causal relations in autocorrelated nonlinear time series datasets.” Proceedings of UAI, PMLR 124, 1388–1397, 2020.
[2] Runge, Jakob, et al. “Detecting and quantifying causal associations in large nonlinear time series datasets.” Science Advances, 5(11), eaau4996, 2019.
[3] Tigramite documentation, PCMCI and PCMCI+ methods: https://jakobrunge.github.io/tigramite/.