- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes VARIS, a framework for cross-asset financial forecasting built on a frozen Kronos backbone. It combines dynamic layer selection, common market factor modeling, and selective use of lagged residual information from other stocks. Experiments across six equity markets and three forecast horizons report improvements in return prediction and stock ranking, supported by ablation and generalization studies.
Critical strengths
Cross-asset forecasting better reflects real financial markets and provides a much-needed extension to Kronos by incorporating dependencies between stocks.
The experimental design is comprehensive, covering multiple markets, forecast horizons, ablations, and generalization tests.
Critical weaknesses
Several mathematical symbols are not clearly defined when first introduced, making the method difficult to follow. Please explain their meanings and clarify the dimensions of key tensors.
There is a potential overlap between the evaluation data and Kronos’s pretraining data. Kronos’s published pretraining range extends through June 2024, whereas VARIS’s main test period precedes this cutoff and its OOT evaluation begins in May 2024. The authors should verify the overlap for the specific checkpoint used and separately report results after its pretraining cutoff. Freezing the backbone does not eliminate this concern.
The choice of Kronos and its replaceability are insufficiently discussed. An alternative backbone such as univariate TSFM (PatchTST-FM, Tabby) and multivariate TSFM (Chronos-2, TimesFM-3, Toto-2) could help test whether VARIS’s gains transfer beyond Kronos. Native multivariate models would provide relevant forecasting baselines. TabPFN(-TS) and KumoRFM also merit discussion as alternative tabular and relational prediction approaches. These comparisons would clarify whether the improvements depend on Kronos’s financial pretraining or demonstrate a more general benefit of the proposed relational adaptation.
Questions for authors
Please define mathematical symbols when they first appear.
Please verify whether the evaluation data overlap with the pretraining data of the specific Kronos checkpoint used. Disclose its pretraining cutoff and report results on a non-overlapping test period to address potential data leakage.
Please justify the choice of Kronos and discuss whether it can be replaced by other foundation models.
Why the Relation Path Is the Incremental Contribution
We thank the reviewer for asking which part of VARIS is responsible for the improvement over existing cross-asset methods.
The relation-path ablation gives a direct answer. In Table 3, removing the relation path reduces Test RankIC from 0.0948 to 0.0764 in A-shares and from 0.0607 to 0.0447 in S&P 500. The corresponding gains from the relation path are therefore 0.0184 and 0.0160. The no-relation variant keeps the individual and common-component paths unchanged, so this comparison isolates the contribution of prediction-time residual relation inference.
The similarity between the no-relation variant and MASTER or DeltaLag is also informative. These baselines already capture shared or lagged information. VARIS adds a further decision: after removing the common market component, it determines which source--lag evidence is relevant to each target asset and whether that evidence should be used.
The relation path first estimates a common market state and uses it to construct residual representations. It then scores source--lag candidates according to their current compatibility and their consistency in previous windows. The retained candidates compete with a NULL option in the same softmax. The weights q_t distribute information across accepted candidates, while rho_t controls the amount of relational information entering the update. State-conditioned routing selects the backbone representations used for individual prediction, common-state estimation, and relation inference.
The routing--selection matrix is:
With selective relation updates, dynamic routing improves RankIC over static routing by 0.0101 in A-shares and 0.0079 in S&P 500. The corresponding interaction contrasts are 0.0046 and 0.0042. These results show that the choice of representation and the decision to accept relational information both contribute to the final prediction.
The negative controls show what information the relation path uses. Source permutation lowers A-shares RankIC to 0.0773, lag randomization lowers it to 0.0842, and past-window displacement lowers it to 0.0798, compared with 0.0948 for VARIS. The improvement therefore depends on the source identity, the temporal alignment of the lag, and the consistency of the relation in the preceding window.
Overall, the relation path contributes more than an additional lagged feature. It removes the shared market component, selects relevant residual source--lag candidates, and decides whether their information should enter the prediction. This conditional use of relational evidence is the main incremental contribution of VARIS over the existing cross-asset baselines.