- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2(−1)
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a foundation model KiT based on diffusion Transformers specifically for financial candlestick forecasting. The authors reformulate future candlestick prediction as conditional path generation via a non-autoregressive flow in continuous space, while preserving candle geometry and handling multiscale heterogeneity. KiT achieves better scores than both the general and task-specific baselines across multiple markets and frequencies.
Critical strengths
-
This paper targets the important task of financial candlestick forecasting and identifies the research gap correctly. The proposed approach is well-motivated.
-
KiT implements a non-autoregressive inference that avoids error accumulation encountered in many autoregressive and point-forecasting alternatives, while handling certain levels of heterogeneity across multiscale and multimarket that challenges existing diffusion-based models.
-
Results are encouraging across multiple scenarios.
Critical weaknesses
-
Although KiT outperforms a wide variety of baselines, the improvements compared to the best alternative Kronos-base-FT in some configurations is small. Significance tests and confidence intervals are not provided to demonstrate the significance.
-
The paper claims that avoiding error accumulation is a major advantage, but there is no empirical validation to verify the superiority of this design over the autoregressive approaches under a fair comparison.
-
The testing period is fixed and relatively short, making the results less convincing. Financial markets change with complex temporal regime shifts. Model forecasts may have totally different in distinct periods.
Questions for authors
-
Does KiT handle the heterogeneity in cross-sectional dependence and regime shift?
-
Regarding the above weakness 2, can you show the model performance of the KiT variant using autoregressive architecture while keeping the other designs the same for a fair comparison?
-
Does KiT’s performance remain the best when evaluated on a different testing period?
Minor issue: Citation formatting reads a little confusing throughout this paper.
4 comments
Comment for Reviewer f5cK (part2)
Weak3 / Q3: Does KiT remain the best on a different testing period?
- Seven unseen months (13 Apr – 30 Oct 2026), paper checkpoint frozen (data that did not exist at training time; 1,000 A-share and 824 U.S. names). Volatility RankIC is 0.677 [0.646, 0.714] (A-share) and 0.861 [0.849, 0.872] (U.S.). On every anchor it is above MLE-fitted GARCH (+0.082, t 9.6 / +0.045, t 8.9), EWMA (+0.051 / +0.057), zero-shot Kronos and the five TSFMs. It also beats OHLC range estimators and HAR built on the same input on 86–100% of anchors.
- Nineteen held-out months (Apr 2025 – Oct 2026). For a longer held-out window, we also evaluate an A-share KiT-L of the same architecture, recipe and size (training ≤ 2023-12-31, validation to 2025-03-31) on 73 anchors × ~1,000 names. On identical cases:
| KiT | Chronos-2 | Chronos-Bolt | Sundial | TimesFM 2.5 | TimesFM 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Return RankIC | .085 | .048 | .017 | .073 | .069 | .068 |
| Volatility RankIC | .603 | .509 | .510 | .466 | .524 | .497 |
| Q5–Q1 spread / 20 days | +2.1% | +0.9% | +0.0% | +0.7% | +0.7% | +1.0% |
KiT's return RankIC is positive in each of the six quarters (0.055 / 0.087 / 0.106 / 0.141 / 0.069 / 0.058; overall t 5.2). Its volatility RankIC is higher on 99–100% of anchors (t 11.2–13.7), and its market-neutral spread is the only one significant at the 5% level (t 3.3; best TSFM t 1.9). Against zero-shot Kronos on 300 of these names, return RankIC is 0.082 vs 0.029 and volatility RankIC 0.611 vs 0.483 (t 10.2).
Q1: Heterogeneity, cross-sectional dependence and regime shift
- Heterogeneity across instruments and markets. One set of parameters serves 4,830 instruments and seven resolutions through the scale-free candle state, with market, sector, instrument and resolution identity injected through AdaLN and calendar / event signals per bar. Two tests show that this transfers. (i) Three-market pretraining beats an A-share-only KiT-L of the same size on unseen A-share data: volatility RankIC 0.677 vs 0.649 (t 3.5), CRPS 0.750 vs 0.795 (t −2.2), 90% coverage 0.64 vs 0.57 (t 4.3). (ii) Zero-shot, on 161 actively traded perpetual futures outside its vocabulary (null instrument identity, 15m bars, Apr–Oct 2026), KiT's volatility RankIC is 0.709, above per-instrument MLE-fitted GARCH (0.660, t 4.8) and historical volatility (0.650, t 6.5); its return RankIC is 0.050 (t 3.6).
- Cross-sectional dependence. KiT generates each instrument's path conditionally on its own history and identity, so cross-asset dependence is captured only implicitly, through shared market-level and calendar conditioning. We will state this as a limitation, and leave explicit cross-asset attention to future work.
- Regime shift. Over all 2026 anchors, KiT's volatility advantage over fitted GARCH and EWMA holds on 100% of anchors in every calendar month, in every tercile of market volatility and of cross-sectional dispersion, and in rising and falling markets, in both markets (mean gain over GARCH +0.099, t 9.7, A-share; +0.045, t 10.9, U.S.). Return skill shows no decay with time since the training cutoff (slope t −0.3).
Minor: Citations We will unify the citation style (textual vs. parenthetical) and fix misplaced citations throughout.
We hope these experiments settle Weak1–Weak3. If so, we would be grateful if you would consider raising your score. Thank you again for recognizing the value of the diffusion based models!
Thanks for your response. I think this is a good opportunity to upload the revised manuscript to formally address the reviewers' concerns and strengthen the paper during the rebuttal period. I would like to review the revisions, if available.
Thank you for the suggestion. We are finalizing the revised manuscript and will upload it. For you reference, in summary, the revision will include:
-
Significance: block-bootstrap 95% CIs, Newey–West t-statistics and paired tests for all main results, together with a Kronos baseline fine-tuned under KiT’s protocol with validation-based checkpoint selection (Weak1).
-
Joint vs. autoregressive generation: an autoregressive twin trained from scratch with everything else identical. The joint model ranks returns better at 19 of 20 horizons and is better calibrated (Weak2, Q2).
-
Different testing periods: evaluation on seven unseen months (Apr–Oct 2026) with the frozen checkpoint, and on 19 held-out months with a model trained through 2023 (Weak3, Q3).
-
Heterogeneity and regime shift: the cross-market transfer and zero-shot futures results, and the per-month and per-regime analysis. Cross-sectional dependence will be stated as a limitation. (Q1)
Thank you again for recognizing the contributions of our work!
Comment for Reviewer f5cK (part1)
Thank you for the positive assessment, and for noting that the paper "identifies the research gap correctly" and that the approach is "well-motivated." Each of your requests led to new experiments, which we will add to the revision. This part answers Weak1 and Weak2 / Q2; part 2 answers Weak3 / Q3, Q1 and the citation issue.
Weak1: Significance and confidence intervals
We will report every result with circular block-bootstrap 95% CIs over anchors, Newey–West t-statistics and paired tests on identical cases.
Weak2 / Q2: The autoregressive variant, all else equal
The joint model ranks returns better at 19 of the 20 horizons. The AR twin's skill plateaus around 0.03–0.04, while the joint model reaches 0.071 at h = 20. Conditioning on its own samples also damps the AR twin's paths: the ratio of predicted to realized mean absolute bar return at h = 20 is 0.60, vs 0.67 for the joint model.