- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DiTS uses a standard Flow Matching method as its main algorithmic framework to develop a conditional generative model for time series. The paper adds a novel Time-aligned Modulation module to Transformer, which provides different conditional modulation parameters for different target patches and leads to better performance. The method achieves relatively strong generation performance on datasets with future exogenous variables, but performs less well when future exogenous variables are unavailable.
Critical strengths
- The paper introduces a novel Time-aligned Modulation module into the Transformer, allowing different target patches to use different conditional modulation parameters and improving model performance.
Critical weaknesses
- The main innovation lies in adding a Time-aligned Modulation module to the Transformer. However, this only makes a minor change to the Transformer architecture and does not introduce any new methods or algorithms, so the methodological novelty is somewhat limited.
- The method performs well when future exogenous variables are available, but its performance is relatively poor when they are unavailable. This may be because the method used to predict future exogenous variables is not sufficiently effective, which limits the overall performance. This suggests that the method relies heavily on the accuracy of future exogenous variable predictions. Could you develop a novel approach to predicting future exogenous variables that is specifically designed for your framework, so as to further improve its performance and make it more widely applicable?
Questions for authors
- Could you develop a novel approach to predicting future exogenous variables that is specifically designed for your framework, so as to further improve its performance and make it more widely applicable?
- You need to compare your method with some representative methods, such as KITE, Sundial and TimeDiff.
5 comments
Dear Reviewer yKu1,
We hope our response has addressed the concerns you raised. We would welcome any further feedback before the discussion closes and would be glad to elaborate on any point. Thank you again for your careful reading and constructive suggestions.
Kind regards,
The Authors
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. The authors have made efforts to address my concerns. The new comparisons and future-covariate forecasting experiments provide a clearer picture of the method's performance. However, I still have concerns about the methodological novelty and the effectiveness of the proposed extension.
The additional explanations and ablation studies help clarify the role of Time-aligned Modulation. The results show that patch-wise conditioning can improve forecasting performance compared with several alternative conditioning mechanisms. However, the main contribution remains a modification of the existing AdaLN mechanism within a standard Transformer and flow-matching framework. The improvement over variate attention is also relatively small (0.204 versus 0.207 in average MSE). Therefore, my concern about the limited methodological novelty is only partially addressed.
The authors have also added an explicit future-covariate forecasting extension, but the new results do not show a clear improvement over the original DiTS. For future-covariate prediction, using generated price trajectories does not improve the average MSE compared with using historical information alone (0.120 versus 0.119). More importantly, when these predicted covariates are used for electricity price forecasting, the proposed extension achieves an average MSE of 0.281, slightly worse than the original DiTS (0.279). Although WQL improves slightly (0.1063 versus 0.1066), the difference is very small. Meanwhile, inference latency increases substantially from 15.5 ms to 49.6 ms. These results do not show a clear practical advantage of the proposed extension over the original DiTS.
I also have a concern about the training and inference procedures. The second DiTS is trained using paired observations, but during inference it uses price trajectories generated by the first model. This may lead to a distribution mismatch between training and inference. Prediction errors may also propagate through the covariate forecasting stage. It would be helpful if the authors could clarify how these issues are handled.
The additional comparisons with KITE, Sundial, and TimeDiff largely address my previous concern about insufficient experimental comparisons. The results show that DiTS performs competitively across the evaluated tasks. However, it would be helpful to clarify whether all methods use the same available covariate information and comparable inference budgets, especially since DiTS and the baselines use different sampling configurations.
Overall, the revisions have addressed several of my concerns and provided stronger experimental evidence for Time-aligned Modulation. However, the methodological novelty remains limited. The future-covariate forecasting extension also shows no clear improvement over the original DiTS, despite its much higher computational cost. Therefore, I maintain my original rating.
Many thanks to Reviewer yKu1 for the thoughtful review and suggestions for extending our evaluation.
W1. What DiTS adds to DiT
DiTS adapts multimodal DiT to covariate-aware forecasting. Electricity demand and price have different meanings and units, yet their timestamps tell us which intervals correspond. DiTS uses this structure to define what the model generates and how it is conditioned. Only target patches evolve through the backbone. A separate encoder preserves the timing of the covariates that guide target generation under conditional flow matching.
Time-aligned Modulation changes where a covariate enters the velocity prediction. Window-level AdaLN gives morning and evening price patches the same modulation even when their load forecasts differ. DiTS uses a shared mapping to derive each patch's scales, shifts and gates from its aligned covariates and flow time. Revising the evening load forecast can therefore change the evening price update directly. Temporal attention can carry that information to later hours without adding covariate tokens. In Table 13, this design yields lower mean MSE across five markets than global modulation or any of the attention alternatives tested.
W2. Forecasting with past-only covariates
With only historical covariates, DiTS has the lowest five-market mean MSE for 24-step EPF forecasting (0.280 vs. 0.285 for GCGNet, Table 2). In this setting, a shared linear adapter maps past covariate embeddings to a latent condition for each future patch. The adapter is trained through the target velocity loss. For example, it can learn which aspects of past load help forecast tomorrow's prices without estimating tomorrow's load in physical units. When a load forecast is available, each price patch receives the external forecast for its own interval. In that setting, Table 1 reports a 15.1% reduction in mean MSE over the strongest baseline, averaged across two horizons. We address your second question in Q1, where we evaluate a DiTS extension that explicitly forecasts future covariates.
Q1. An explicit future-covariate predictor
We implemented your suggestion by swapping the target and covariate roles. Past-only DiTS generates ten 24-hour price paths from 168 hours of history. A second DiTS forecasts each covariate using the aligned price path through Time-aligned Modulation. Training uses paired observations. Inference uses history and generated paths.
We tested five EPF markets with three paired seeds for the exogenous models. A uses the same history, including past prices. B and C share weights and noise. B receives the mean price path and C receives individual paths.
Forecasting the future covariates
Forecasting prices using those covariate predictions. A–C use the same frozen price model and ten output trajectories.
The extension supplies explicit forecasts of both external series. Price guidance reduced covariate MSE in PJM, FR and DE, with a small increase in the five-market mean. Feeding C's forecasts back improved price MSE over A at all three seeds. Relative to original DiTS, C lowered price MSE in four markets, but the increase in DE raised the overall mean. Its mean price WQL was slightly lower. End-to-end latency was 49.6 ms vs. 15.5 ms for original DiTS.
Q2. Comparisons with KITE, Sundial and TimeDiff
Sundial is discussed in Section 2.2 of the original submission. We now compare it, KITE and TimeDiff with DiTS on the 13 tasks and test windows of Figure 4. DiTS uses the original test-selected configurations (five steps, 50 samples). Baselines use default step counts. We report geometric means.
Sundial is closest on both metrics and achieves lower WQL and MASE on the Belgian electricity-price task. Across all 13 tasks, DiTS has the lowest aggregate error for both quantiles and point forecasts.
The separate full-test EPF comparison below uses covariates available throughout the forecast horizon. DiTS uses the paper's fixed configuration and averages ten trajectories for each point forecast.