- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies a specific issue in multimodal financial forecasting: The same price-volume window contains changes at different time scales, and they may require different news evidence; If the numerical states are aggregated first and then the news is uniformly matched, will the correspondence between the components and the evidence be lost? The author proposes CANER: Firstly, low, medium and high-frequency components are obtained through wavelet decomposition, and the observable technical states are tranwritten into text semantic anchors to calibrate component queries. Subsequently, each component selects news from the same historical news pool respectively, absorbs information through gating, and finally aggregates the enhanced status to predict the rise and fall. The evaluation is conducted on three datasets and three horizons,showing that CANER outperforms the baseline methods.
Critical strengths
CANER has an inspiring motivation: Market changes at different time scales may rely on different news, and a unified news context may not be able to preserve these differences. How should research evidence correspond to numerical components to have reference value for financial forecasting and broader multimodal time series modeling is very important.
Critical weaknesses
SpecTF has used representations of different frequencies as queries to generate frequency-specific attention outputs for the same text set, then updated the frequency representations and used them for prediction. Thus,SpecTF is an impotant precedent work which inspire many designs of this work (like Align Before Aggregation). But the performance of the method is not significantly better than the SpecTF baseline.
Questions for authors
- Could the author provide the efficiency of the method, including the time and space complexity of the model, and the time cost of training and inference? In addition, could the author provide efficiency comparisons with other baselines like SpecTF?
- Could the authors provide more details about the implementation of the method, including hyperparameter settings, training strategies, and the datasets details? This will help to better understand the method and its performance.
- The comparision of Global versus component-level alignment is not clear. They used different Top-K and news selection. It is hard to where the gains are from. Please provide more details on global alignment setting.
2 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments. The authors have adequately addressed my questions regarding efficiency, implementation details, and the global alignment comparison.
However, my main concern about the novelty relative to SpecTF remains. SpecTF already performs frequency-specific text alignment before aggregation, and the improvements over SpecTF are relatively modest despite the additional complexity and inference cost. Therefore, I will keep my original score unchanged.
Response to Reviewer d8xZ
Thank you for the questions on efficiency and the comparison with SpecTF.
Q1. Efficiency. For lookback L, K branches, N articles and up to M selections per branch, cached inference with fixed widths takes O(KTenc(L)+KTsel(N,M)+L+KL+KN+KM). Each branch runs the shared encoder (Tenc) and top-M selection (Tsel). The last four terms cover decomposition, anchors, scoring and absorption. Keeping all branch intermediates, with at most linear selection workspace, requires O(KSenc(L)+KL+KN+KM) space beyond parameters; Senc is one encoder's workspace. Uncached inputs add FinBERT encoding time and memory. Here L=30, K=3, N≤64, M=8: at most 90 anchor weights, 192 article scores and 24 selection slots per prediction.
Same A100 80 GB, CMIN-US next-day samples, BF16, training/inference batches 32/1:
Timing including encoding starts from the same tokenized inputs. Epoch times are close; CANER uses more training memory and has higher inference latency.
Q2. Implementation and data. Two-level db2 wavelets yield three frequency branches. One frozen FinBERT encoder handles anchors and news. For 1/3/5-day direction prediction we use binary cross-entropy, AdamW (LR 1e-4, weight decay 1e-5), batch size 64 and up to 100 epochs. We stop after 10 epochs without improvement in validation MCC, select checkpoints by validation MCC and report five-seed test means ± SD.
Train: 2018-01-01–2021-04-30; validation: 2021-05-01–2021-08-31; test: 2021-09-01–2021-12-31. CMIN-US has 110 US stocks; CMIN-CN has 300 CSI 300 constituents. We rank FNSPID stocks by article count over the full period, so the top-465 universe reflects test-period coverage. We split by target date, drop boundary-crossing samples and use per-stock training statistics for numerical features and missing values. We deduplicate news, include only articles available by the cutoff and exclude same-day news if timestamps are unreliable.
Q3. Global control. Price branches, parameter counts, prediction architecture, pool, cutoff and selection slots are matched. Global uses one query for up to 24 articles and shares the context. CANER selects up to eight per branch. Duplicate selections occupy separate slots, so distinct article counts may differ. Jointly, branch-specific selection and absorption raise next-day ACC by 0.64–1.97 percentage points (pp) and MCC by 0.0088–0.0277 over Global. Removing anchors or fixing the gate at 1 lowers ACC on all three datasets; the fixed gate raises CMIN-CN MCC from 0.0846 to 0.0853.
Critical weakness. SpecTF already uses frequency-specific attention over text and updates each frequency representation with its corresponding context. For a given stock, the news most relevant to a short-term price move may differ from the news that informs a more persistent trend. Even when the same article is relevant to both, its predictive value may differ across timescales. CANER explicitly models which articles each component selects and how much it absorbs from each one. Each component uses observable price and volume to calibrate its query, selects articles by content and time since publication, and gates their contributions before aggregation. Against SpecTF, five-seed mean ACC increases by 0.16–0.49 pp (nine-setting average 0.34 pp) and MCC by 0.0012–0.0137. Under Appendix E's daily equal-weight long-only top-three strategy without transaction costs, cumulative returns increase by 3/5/9 pp and Sharpe by 0.04/0.03/0.04 on CMIN-US/CMIN-CN/FNSPID, respectively.
Daily differences (CANER − SpecTF). On each test day, we calculated paired differences on the same stocks within each seed and averaged the five differences. The table gives the 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles of those averages across trading days. All nine ΔACC ranges lie above zero. For ΔMCC, the CMIN-US three-day range crosses zero [−0.0004, +0.0031], while the other eight ranges lie above zero. We do not report a paired confidence interval for the full-test mean gain, so the daily ranges do not establish its statistical significance.