- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes StegoCoder, which combines classical steganographic coding (LDGM and polar codes) with a learned image channel. A neural renderer embeds coded binary sequences into images, while a bit predictor recovers them after perturbations. Experiments demonstrate strong robustness to Gaussian noise at high payloads.
Critical strengths
-
The integration of steganographic coding with a learned image channel is interesting and provides a useful perspective on robust information hiding.
-
The method achieves strong message recovery under Gaussian noise, particularly at high embedding rates.
Critical weaknesses
-
There is a classical research direction in image steganography, namely “steganographic distortion cost learning”, which uses neural networks to learn cover-dependent modification cost maps and has a theoretical foundation in rate–distortion theory. However, this relevant line of research is not adequately discussed or cited in the paper.
-
The framework uses the message and an all-zero binary cover to generate the binary stego sequence. Since the binary cover contains only zeros, the resulting binary stego depends on the message but contains no information from the actual cover image. This is somewhat strange, as the Steganographic Embedding module essentially becomes a cover-independent message encoder, seemingly designed mainly to produce a binary representation for fusion with the cover image. The necessity and advantages of this design are unclear.
-
The experimental comparisons are limited and mainly involve relatively old methods. Although SteganoGAN and LISO are well-known methods, I am sure they are not competitive baselines in modern image steganography. Therefore, the reported superior performance does not sufficiently demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed design. Moreover, comparisons with neural steganography equipped with equivalent error-correcting codes are missing, making it difficult to isolate the contribution of the learned channel.
-
Appendix L reports that 99–100% of the original stego images are flagged by pretrained steganalyzers. The proposed defense is evaluated only against the targeted, frozen detectors, without testing generalization to unseen or adaptively trained steganalyzers. This raises concerns about the practical security of the proposed method.
-
Figure 1 appears somewhat AI-generated images.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses
Response to Reviewer cpV2: addresing reviewers concerns
We thank the reviewer for the comments and here we address the questions raised by the reviewer.
We will add this line of work to the Introduction and Section 2.1. Cost-learning methods such as ASDL-GAN (Tang et al., 2017), UT-6HPF-GAN (Yang et al., 2020) and SPAR-RL (Tang et al., 2021) learn the costs ρi of Eq. (1) for a fixed binary representation of the cover, such as its LSBs, and embed over a lossless channel. StegoCoder instead learns the representation and the channel (Render and BitPredictor) and uses uniform costs ρi=1, since it is trained with the same pflip at every position. Combining learned, cover-dependent costs with a position-dependent pflip is a natural extension, which we will state as future work.
The binary stego does not depend on the cover image, but the stego image does: the cover enters through the Render and acts as a channel state known to the sender only (Sec. 3.1). With a fixed binary cover, the code flips only the fraction of positions set by its rate (8.3–12.9%, Table 3), and the image distortion grows approximately linearly with the number of flips (Appendix B), matching the additive distortion assumed by the codes.
We added two coded baselines: QIM with the same nested polar code (response to Reviewer sQJ1, item 2), and the same networks with a standard channel polar code, retrained for its input (response to Reviewer DMrb, item 1). With equivalent codes, both recover (almost) every image at σ=5⋅10−3. At σ=10−2, QIM with the code loses every image at matched PSNR, and the channel-polar networks need LPIPS 0.136 vs. 0.077 for StegoCoder (at 1.3 dB lower PSNR) to recover every image. Regarding recent methods, the comparison includes LISO (2023) and, under JPEG, LISO + neural cover selection (2024).
We tested both (response to Reviewer sQJ1, item 1). SRNet, XuNet and KeNet retrained from scratch on StegoCoder images detect 92–100% of the images defended against the frozen detectors. Rerunning the defence against each retrained detector takes that detector to 0% on all 500 test images, but every other detector, retrained or frozen, still flags almost all of them. The defence therefore evades only the detector whose weights the sender knows. We will add these results in a new appendix, state this in the Limitations, and present StegoCoder as robust data hiding rather than secure steganography.
Figure 1 was drawn by the authors in draw.io, as stated in the Use of Generative AI section. We will redraw it as a plain block diagram (Render, BitPredictor, steganographic code) without decorative elements.