- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
LW-MIH is proposed as a VAE-based generative framework that addresses all three questions. FLUX, SD1.5, and Sana are used only as frozen secret encoders, while a separate rectified flow trained on the AFHQ-Cat dataset is employed to synthesize the cover. The encoder latents are packed into a single tensor of fixed size, the tensor is filled under three hiding schemes, and the packed field is aligned with the flow prior through a learnable invertible whitener (LIW). Up to 96 images are hidden in one cover without the widespread failures observed in the untrained pipeline.
Critical strengths
This paper derives a capacity formula based on VAE geometry and shows that the maximum number of hidden images is determined by the tensor size together with the downsampling and channel parameters of the VAE. A Learnable Invertible Whitener (LIW) is further proposed to calibrate the amplitude and heavy-tailed distribution and to suppress extremely large values. The ablation studies are well designed and involve rigorous control of variables.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The proposed method relies on an additional information for recovery, and reconstruction performance degrades severely if suffers bit errors, loss, or tampering. Only simple tests are conducted in the appendix. An analysis of this single-point vulnerability should be provided in the main text, together with fault-tolerant schemes.
(2) A cryptographic security analysis is missing. The key space and brute-force complexity are not evaluated, and security under attack models such as ciphertext-only attacks and chosen-secret attacks is not discussed.
(3) The Patch-CNN experiment shows that the cover images are not statistically undetectable. Beyond Patch-CNN, more mainstream steganalysis tools are not adopted for detection experiments. It should be clarified how the detection resistance of cover images can be improved.
(4) All experiments are conducted under an ideal lossless channel, and recovery performance under real-world channel distortions, including JPEG compression, noise, cropping, and scaling, is not tested. Since channel robustness is a critical metric for steganography, relevant experiments should be supplemented, or the lossless-channel assumption should be stated explicitly.
(5) The three packing strategies (FC/HFD/UP) perform allocation only by packing VAE latents; the underlying bit-capacity upper bound is not raised, and bits are merely redistributed among different secret images. The advantages and disadvantages of this design relative to latent compression schemes should be elaborated.
(6)The HFD strategy provides little benefit and slightly decreases PSNR with the FLUX encoder, and positive benefits are observed only for Sana. Although HFD is presented as a general-purpose scheme, it is compatible with only a subset of VAEs, and the underlying reason for this behavior remains unanalyzed.
Questions for authors
(1) The proposed method relies on an additional information for recovery, and reconstruction performance degrades severely if suffers bit errors, loss, or tampering. Only simple tests are conducted in the appendix. An analysis of this single-point vulnerability should be provided in the main text, together with fault-tolerant schemes.
(2) A cryptographic security analysis is missing. The key space and brute-force complexity are not evaluated, and security under attack models such as ciphertext-only attacks and chosen-secret attacks is not discussed.
(3) The Patch-CNN experiment shows that the cover images are not statistically undetectable. Beyond Patch-CNN, more mainstream steganalysis tools are not adopted for detection experiments. It should be clarified how the detection resistance of cover images can be improved.
(4) All experiments are conducted under an ideal lossless channel, and recovery performance under real-world channel distortions, including JPEG compression, noise, cropping, and scaling, is not tested. Since channel robustness is a critical metric for steganography, relevant experiments should be supplemented, or the lossless-channel assumption should be stated explicitly.
(5) The three packing strategies (FC/HFD/UP) perform allocation only by packing VAE latents; the underlying bit-capacity upper bound is not raised, and bits are merely redistributed among different secret images. The advantages and disadvantages of this design relative to latent compression schemes should be elaborated.
(6)The HFD strategy provides little benefit and slightly decreases PSNR with the FLUX encoder, and positive benefits are observed only for Sana. Although HFD is presented as a general-purpose scheme, it is compatible with only a subset of VAEs, and the underlying reason for this behavior remains unanalyzed.
(7) Both encryption and decryption require forward/backward ODE integration of the rectified flow, which leads to prohibitive inference cost. Quantitative reports of inference time and GPU memory consumption are lacking.