- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes STAD, a structure-guided transferable active defense that protects GIS generated by GANs and diffusion models without access to the secret message, decoder key, or target decoder. A frozen VQGAN encoder is adopted as a fixed surrogate, the horizontal and vertical spatial relationships of its intermediate features are perturbed, and the optimization is regularized by neighborhood aggregation, edge weighting, and multiscale smoothing under a post-quantization distortion constraint; the encoder and defense hyperparameters are fixed across all tested GIS targets, and only image-wise perturbations are optimized per input image.
Critical strengths
This paper addresses the key limitation that most existing active defenses are designed for traditional modification-based steganography and exhibit poor transferability against GIS constructed by GANs and diffusion models. To address this issue, STAD is proposed as a black-box defense that uses a single frozen surrogate model with fixed hyperparameters to counter both categories of GIS under settings that closely reflect real-world attack--defense scenarios; experimental results indicate its effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
(1) GIS scenarios with embedded error-correcting codes (ECC) are not evaluated. Since ECC can recover a certain proportion of bit errors, the robustness of the proposed method under ECC remains unclear.
(2) STAD assumes that secret information is encoded within local spatial neighborhood correlations in deep VQGAN features. It remains unclear whether STAD would fail for newly designed GIS schemes that do not rely on such local spatial feature structures.
(3) Perturbations are added to images by STAD; however, corresponding steganalysis experiments on these perturbations are not reported. It is therefore unclear how it can be guaranteed that the proposed method will not be identified by third parties as steganographic images.
(4) The loss function, gradient sampling, edge weighting, smoothing, and distortion constraints are involved, but the purpose of each introduced component is not clearly explained, and targeted ablation experiments for each module are lacking.
(5) A frozen VQGAN encoder is adopted directly as the surrogate model, and defense performance with other pre-trained encoders (e.g., CLIP, DINOv2, ResNet) as surrogates is not compared.
Questions for authors
(1) GIS scenarios with embedded error-correcting codes (ECC) are not evaluated. Since ECC can recover a certain proportion of bit errors, the robustness of the proposed method under ECC remains unclear.
(2) STAD assumes that secret information is encoded within local spatial neighborhood correlations in deep VQGAN features. It remains unclear whether STAD would fail for newly designed GIS schemes that do not rely on such local spatial feature structures.
(3) Perturbations are added to images by STAD; however, corresponding steganalysis experiments on these perturbations are not reported. It is therefore unclear how it can be guaranteed that the proposed method will not be identified by third parties as steganographic images.
(4) The loss function, gradient sampling, edge weighting, smoothing, and distortion constraints are involved, but the purpose of each introduced component is not clearly explained, and targeted ablation experiments for each module are lacking.
(5) A frozen VQGAN encoder is adopted directly as the surrogate model, and defense performance with other pre-trained encoders (e.g., CLIP, DINOv2, ResNet) as surrogates is not compared.
(6) The efficiency of the proposed model is not analyzed. In particular, quantitative metrics such as FLOPs, per-image inference latency, GPU memory consumption, and throughput are absent from the evaluation.
Please Participate in the Discussion Phase
Dear Reviewers,
The authors have posted their rebuttal and responses addressing your review comments and questions.
Please carefully read their responses (as well as the updated manuscript, if applicable) and actively engage in the reviewer-author discussion phase. If you have any remaining concerns or follow-up questions, please post them so the authors can address them before the discussion period closes.
Your timely participation and updated assessments are essential to helping us reach a fair and well-informed recommendation for this submission.
Best regards,
Area Chair