- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BrainIPAgent, a framework for integrating structural connectivity and functional connectivity for brain disorder classification. It extracts structural patterns, generates clinical reports, and uses them to guide functional encoding and classification. Experiments on ADNI and two clinical cohorts demonstrate improvements over reported baselines.
Critical strengths
- The framework uses SC through both explicit attention biases and textual representations, providing complementary pathways for integrating structural knowledge into functional representation learning.
- The framework also offers a basis for studying how multi-agent systems as tools are involved in the brain model.
Critical weaknesses
- The interpretability claims exceed the current evidence. The generated reports are SC-derived input priors whose embeddings enter the agents, so they describe the input and its presumed clinical relevance but do not establish faithfulness to the proposed model’s decisions. In other words, they are from the LLM's knowledge and the value of dMRI. In particular, prompts encourage disease-relevant patterns and later utilize the disease-related paper to explain these findings.
- The current ablation of the RL controller does not separate policy learning from repeated candidate evaluation and validation-based selection. Could you please compare against a matched non-learning best-of-four sampler and a tuned (, ) schedule. The claim in line 62 that structural constraints help early training but limit later plasticity also requires stage-specific analyses or parameter trajectories.
- The hierarchical pooling formulation needs to be clarified. The dimensions of attention and hierarchical mask are unclear, particularly between Eqs. 6–7. If only pooling SC mask, their dimension seems to be mismatched with each other. Further, could you please clarify whether cluster centers are trainable and how cluster centers are determined?
- The contribution of SC-guidance versus direct prior knowledge from LLMs remains unclear. The gains may be primarily from generated textual information related to the corresponding brain disease.
Questions for authors
- Although the authors report some computational costs, no exact model complexity is reported. Since the RL-controller add 5 minibatches per epoch and LLM's inference, their cost may be substantial relative to standard training. Could you please provide matched runtime or FLOP/MAC comparisons with the baselines, and report both cached-prior and end-to-end inference latency, including prior generation and text encoding.
- Could a type of agent finish extracting the pairwise/triplet patterns and generate the corresponding clinical reports? Extracting the top value from SC might be an easy task.