- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MALM, a Bayesian framework for mediation analysis using paired structural (SC) and functional (FC) connectivity networks. Rather than modeling SC and FC as separate or sequential mediators, MALM learns a unified network-valued mediator through cross-modal attention and gated fusion. The method uses structured attention and sparsity regularization to identify edge-level mediation pathways. Under specified causal assumptions, the authors derive natural direct, indirect, and total effects, and use stochastic gradient Langevin dynamics (SGLD) for Bayesian uncertainty estimation. The authors evaluate MALM on seven synthetic scenarios, comparing it with four baseline methods and conducting ablation studies. The results show improved indirect-effect estimation and interval coverage, particularly when cross-modal interactions are present. The method is also applied to the HCP and ABCD cohorts, using BDNF Val66Met genotype as the exposure and cognitive performance as the outcome. The authors report negative indirect effects in both cohorts and identify mediating connections involving default-mode, visual, and somatomotor networks. The identified pathways also show greater cross-cohort overlap than those of competing methods.
Critical strengths
- The main contribution is learning a unified network-valued mediator from paired SC and FC networks, rather than treating them as independent or sequential mediators. This is useful when the two modalities are closely related and contain complementary information. The use of cross-modal attention, gated fusion, and edge-level pathway modeling provides a reasonable way to combine representation learning with mediation analysis.
- The evaluation includes seven simulation settings, four baseline methods, and ablation studies. The experiments cover different relationships between SC and FC, including cross-modal interactions and nonlinear dependencies. The analyses on HCP and ABCD further examine whether the identified pathways are consistent across cohorts. The reported cross-cohort Jaccard index of 0.87, compared with 0.53 and 0.36 for competing methods, is encouraging, although its interpretation depends on the reliability of the posterior inference and pathway-selection procedure.
Critical weaknesses
-
MALM treats a representation learned from SC and FC as a causal mediator, but this relies on strong assumptions, particularly representation sufficiency (Assumption 1) and the identification conditions in Assumption 4. Representation sufficiency requires that SC–FC configurations mapped to the same mediator have identical potential outcomes under a fixed exposure. This is much stronger than predictive sufficiency, and the proposed training procedure does not guarantee it. The paper also does not examine whether this assumption is reasonable in practice. Moreover, the mediator is learned jointly with the exposure and outcome pathways. While Section 3 defines the causal effects using a fixed population encoder, it is unclear how this relates to the data-adaptive learning procedure or how outcome-guided representation learning affects causal inference. Proposition 3.1 derives the effect decomposition under the stated assumptions, but does not show that the learned mediator satisfies them. This distinction matters because the paper's main claim concerns causal mediation rather than prediction.
-
Equation (14) combines the conditional density of the learned mediator with reconstruction likelihoods for SC and FC, although the mediator is deterministically defined as . Could the authors clarify whether this objective corresponds to a properly normalized likelihood under an explicit generative model, or whether it should instead be interpreted as a composite or generalized Bayesian objective? Furthermore, Appendix C reports a fixed learning rate and an independently tuned noise-scale parameter for SGLD. Please provide the exact parameter update rule and explain how the injected noise relates to the step size and the intended posterior distribution.
Questions for authors
- Assumption 1 requires the learned mediator to be sufficient for the potential outcome under interventions on SC and FC. How can this assumption be justified or assessed for the proposed learned representation? In particular, how does the model ensure that different SC–FC configurations mapped to the same mediator do not have different potential outcomes? Could the authors provide additional theoretical conditions or other evidence showing that the learned representation preserves the required causal structure?
- Equation (14) combines the mediator density with SC/FC reconstruction likelihoods, although the mediator is deterministically defined as . Could the authors clarify whether this defines a valid joint likelihood under an explicit generative model or should be viewed as a composite or generalized Bayesian objective? Appendix C describes SGLD with a fixed learning rate and a separately tuned noise scale. Could the authors provide the exact update rule, explain how the noise scale relates to the target posterior, and clarify how burn-in, sample collection, and convergence were assessed?
- MALM reports significant indirect effects in both HCP and ABCD, unlike the compared methods. Could the authors provide further evidence that this difference is not mainly due to underestimated posterior uncertainty, greater model capacity, or regularization? Appendix E indicates that SC and FC are reconstructed from modality-specific projections of the shared fused node embeddings, rather than directly from the final mediator matrix . Can both observed connectomes be reconstructed using only the final network-valued mediator? If not, how does the auxiliary reconstruction objective ensure that the final mediator retains the information required for causal interpretation?
- MALM combines several established techniques, including cross-modal attention, gated fusion, sparsity regularization, and Bayesian inference. While the overall framework is interesting, its methodological novelty is not entirely clear. Could the authors clarify the main contributions beyond integrating existing techniques? Specifically, how does the learned mediator differ from standard multimodal representations? Does MALM introduce a new mediation estimation or identification method, or mainly apply existing mediation theory to a learned representation? What is the advantage of joint learning over a two-stage approach that learns the representation before estimating mediation effects?
By now, I still can not see the rebuttal. I keep my Rating.