- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses efficient 3D Gaussian rendering by avoiding depth sorting, with particular interest in deployment on resource-constrained mobile devices. It builds on stochastic transparency and introduces two main components. First, a cost-aware router assigns each Gaussian to either primitive-based or fragment-based stochastic sampling according to its opacity and projected footprint, exploiting the complementary performance characteristics of the two approaches. Second, a lightweight U-Net-based denoising network combines Gaussian attributes with reprojected historical observations to improve image quality at low sampling rates, where stochastic rendering otherwise produces substantial noise.
The method substantially improves rendering quality over the evaluated stochastic rendering baselines. However, relative to standard 3DGS and MobileGS, the reported configurations trade image quality for speed, or incur substantial computational cost for modest quality gains. The experiments therefore do not yet establish a consistently superior quality–performance trade-off against these baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The paper identifies complementary performance regimes of primitive-based and fragment-based stochastic rendering. Its cost-aware router exploits these differences by selecting the more efficient sampling method for each Gaussian, improving rendering throughput.
-
The lightweight U-Net-based reconstruction network substantially improves image quality at low sampling rates. Its deployment on a mobile NPU enables the framework to use both GPU and NPU resources efficiently on mobile devices, limiting the additional latency introduced by neural reconstruction.
-
The paper substantially improves the practicality of stochastic Gaussian rendering. Prior approaches suffer from severe noise at low sampling rates or extremely slow rendering at higher sampling rates. By combining efficient hybrid sampling with neural reconstruction, the proposed framework achieves a more useful balance between speed and image quality.
Critical weaknesses
1. Temporal stability.
My main concern is temporal flickering. Both neural reconstruction and TAA rely on depth-based reprojection, yet Gaussian splatting depth is unreliable, and stochastic sampling makes it even less reliable. Please clarify whether depth reliability is used to reject reprojected history samples and provide details of the TAA implementation.
The temporal evaluation should also be stronger. CVVDP in Table 2 is a temporal metric, however, the FLIP-based protocol from StopThePop would be more appropriate for evaluating flickering. Comparisons should include sorting-based methods such as 3DGS, since stochastic rendering methods alone provide only very weak baselines for temporal stability.
2. NPU dependence and precision.
While NPU deployment is valuable for mobile devices, a GPU-only ablation would clarify whether the complete pipeline retains a speed advantage without NPU acceleration. Please also confirm whether quality evaluation uses the actual deployed quantized/compiled NPU precision.
3. Mobile quality–performance trade-off.
Table 1 evaluates performance on a server GPU and does not show a consistently superior quality–speed trade-off for the proposed method. This is acceptable, as stochastic Gaussian rendering generally offers a worse quality–speed trade-off than conventional Gaussian splatting, and this paper already makes substantial improvements.
However, Table 4 reports only FPS, with no quality metrics. Please include quality results to demonstrate the trade-off on mobile devices. Both Tables 1 and 4 should also report temporal flickering using the FLIP-based protocol mentioned in my first point.
Questions for authors
- Please address the questions raised in my comments on the weaknesses above.
- I appreciate the paper’s contributions. If the authors adequately address these concerns, I would be willing to raise my score.
3 comments
Thank you for the response and the additional experiments, which resolve part of my concerns. Two points remain before I consider raising my score.
1. Report temporal FLIP in the paper. The response indicates temporal FLIP was computed, yet no numbers are reported. Please report ꟻLIP₁ and ꟻLIP₇ (StopThePop protocol) for all methods, including 3DGS and Ours, even if the results are unfavorable. I still want to see these metrics as I see clear flickering in the supplementary videos, which is expected from both stochastic sampling and neural reconstruction, and readers should see how it compares to a sorted renderer.
2. Report GPU-only results in Table 4. Table 4 lists only the GPU+NPU configuration for the paper's method, while no baseline uses the NPU. In Figure 7, the GPU-only pipeline runs at 22–24 FPS, versus 27–29 FPS for MobileGS, which also has higher PSNR on two of three datasets. Readers may otherwise conclude the method itself is faster than MobileGS, when the gain may come largely from the extra accelerator. Sorted pipelines could in principle use such hardware too (e.g., TensorGS, arXiv:2605.17855). Please add a GPU-only row for all 11 scenes and state which part of the speedup comes from the NPU.
Overall. I do not expect stochastic Gaussian rendering to already beat sorted Gaussian splatting on the speed–quality trade-off, and I will not lower my score for results that fall short of it; this direction deserves further exploration. I only ask that these results be reported completely and transparently.
Response to Reviewer BAkK 2
Response to Reviewer BAkK
Q1. Temporal ꟻLIP.
We have completed ꟻLIP₁ and ꟻLIP₇ evaluated on five DL3DV sequences in Appendix E.2. Note that the captured images do not achieve the best temporal ꟻLIP scores and even yield the worst score for ꟻLIP₇, whereas GPS (4 spp + TAA) achieves the lowest scores. These observations highlight the importance of considering temporal FLIP alongside visual assessments, as different evaluation approaches may capture complementary aspects of perceptual temporal quality.
| Image source | ꟻLIP₁ ↓ | ꟻLIP₇ ↓ |
|---|---|---|
| Captured Images | 0.100 | 0.179 |
| 3DGS | 0.072 | 0.158 |
| SS (4 spp + TAA) | 0.111 | 0.163 |
| GPS (4 spp + TAA) | 0.043 | 0.115 |
| Ours (1 spp + S) | 0.110 | 0.168 |
Q2. GPU-only results in Table 4.
We have added the requested GPU-only results for Ours-S across all 11 scenes in Table 4. In addition, we would also like to clarify that our mobile implementation of MobileGS leverages the NPU to accelerate its MLP component, as the NPU is well-suited for such computations. Further implementation details of MobileGS are provided in Appendices B.1 and E.6. Therefore, both our method and MobileGS benefit from NPU acceleration, ensuring a fair comparison. We report the resulting FPS improvements below.
| Method | Mip-NeRF 360 | Tanks & Temples | Deep Blending |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ours-S (1 spp) | 24.60 → 45.25 | 27.22 → 50.45 | 28.22 → 53.83 |
| MobileGS | 5.35 → 27.06 | 8.65 → 28.57 | 4.75 → 26.64 |
Response to Reviewer BAkK
Response to Reviewer BAkK
Q1a(W1a). Depth Reliability.
Regarding depth reliability, we do not use an explicit depth-reliability criterion to reject reprojected history samples. In particular, during forward reprojection, when multiple samples from the same historical observation project to one target pixel, we retain the nearest-depth sample. In addition, we intend for the reconstruction network to implicitly handle depth unreliability by jointly processing the reprojected historical depth information, RGB and other Gaussian descriptors.
Q1b(W1b). TAA Strategy.
Regarding the TAA implementation, the Ours (1 spp + S) results in Table 2 are measured on PC without any TAA strategy. Our temporal accumulation (TA) is a post-processing step in the mobile implementation, and the resulting outputs are shown in the original supplementary video. Implementation details are provided in Appendix E.5.
Q1c(W1c). FLIP-based protocol from StopThePop.
While the FLIP-based evaluation protocol adopted by StopThePop (hereafter referred to as temporal FLIP) provides a useful measure of temporal consistency, we believe that its results should be interpreted with some care in our scene settings. First, temporal FLIP relies on optical-flow-based alignment, which can be challenging in scenes involving semi-transparent blending, highly view-dependent appearance, or intricate geometry. Potential alignment inaccuracies may introduce uncertainty into the resulting scores. Second, as shown in Figure 13 and the supplementary videos, GPS with TAA exhibits noticeable oversmoothing, ghosting, and loss of fine detail, despite achieving the lowest temporal FLIP score (approximately half that of 3DGS in our experiments; lower is better). These observations suggest that temporal FLIP may not fully reflect all aspects of perceptual temporal quality in our settings.
Q2(W2). NPU dependence and precision.
Appendix B.3 and Figure 7 provide a detailed comparison between GPU-only and GPU--NPU execution. Averaged over the three scenes (Train, Counter, and Bonsai), our pipeline achieves approximately 2× the throughput of 3DGS-GL without NPU acceleration and 4.3× with GPU–NPU overlap. These results demonstrate that our pipeline maintains a substantial throughput advantage even without NPU acceleration.
Regarding numerical precision, in the mobile evaluation, quality results for the NPU-based methods are evaluated from their deployed FP16 NPU outputs. Precision settings for our method and all baselines are detailed in Appendix E.6.
Q3(W3). Mobile quality-performance trade-off.
Thank you for pointing out the missing mobile quality evaluation. We have expanded Table 4 to report both rendering quality and throughput across all 11 scenes from the three datasets used in Table 1, providing a more complete assessment of the mobile quality--performance trade-off.