acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Efficient Forward Path Tracing on Planar-Based Gaussian Splatting for Inverse Rendering

Abstract

Gaussian splatting has emerged as a promising representation for novel view synthesis, inverse rendering, and relighting, owing to its efficient rasterization and high-fidelity scene representation. Existing Gaussian-based inverse rendering methods typically adopt forward or deferred shading with precomputed or approximate visibility and indirect illumination, limiting their ability to model complex global light transport. Gaussian ray tracing methods can explicitly model visibility and indirect illumination, but incur high computational cost due slow ray-Gaussian intersection. Therefore, accurately disentangling material properties from illumination under complex global illumination effects while maintaining computational efficiency remains a key challenge in Gaussian-based inverse rendering. To address this challenge, we propose an efficient inverse rendering framework that combines planar-based Gaussians with the reconstructed scene mesh for efficient and physically-based material and illumination optimization. In the geometry reconstruction stage, we adopt the modified VA-GS to reconstruct accurate scene geometry, which is then kept fixed during inverse rendering. Based on the reconstructed geometry, we introduce a per-Gaussian forward shading method that leverages the scene mesh to query visibility and model multi-bounce light transport, enabling the outgoing radiance of each Gaussian primitive to be computed before rasterization. The resulting per-Gaussian radiance is -blended into the rendered image through differentiable Gaussian splatting to jointly optimize the material and illumination parameters. Experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms existing inverse rendering baselines while maintaining high-fidelity novel view synthesis.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Gaussian splatting, inverse rendering, relighting, path tracing, forward shading, differetiable rendering

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_Hfq5OpenReview ↗
Rating
2(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a two-stage inverse rendering method that combines Gaussian Splatting (GS) with mesh-based path tracing. It first reconstructs planar Gaussians using a modified VA-GS with normal and mask supervision, and then extracts a mesh with learnable textures. The inverse rendering stage performs multi-bounce path tracing at each planar Gaussian, using the mesh and its textures for visibility queries and secondary-ray shading, and renders the image by α-blending the shaded Gaussians. The authors argue that this design reduces multi-view inconsistency and the per-pixel shading cost of deferred shading. On Synthetic4Relight and TensoIR, the method achieves the highest novel view synthesis (NVS) and relighting PSNR among the compared methods, with a training time of approximately 40 minutes per scene. The paper also includes ablations on sampling, indirect illumination, and multi-view material consistency.

Critical strengths
  1. Explicit multi-bounce illumination modeling for GS-based inverse rendering. The method combines mesh-based multi-bounce path tracing with per-Gaussian shading and Gaussian splatting. Explicitly accounting for inter-reflections is a useful contribution toward more accurate material and lighting decomposition in GS-based inverse rendering.
  2. Strong performance with efficient training. The method achieves the highest NVS and relighting PSNR on both evaluated datasets, with competitive performance on other metrics. The reported training time of approximately 40 minutes is also favorable compared with existing GS-based inverse rendering.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient positioning against closely related work. MIRReS[1] already combines a radiance field with mesh-based multi-bounce inverse rendering, but is neither discussed nor evaluated. The contribution of per-Gaussian shading and the hybrid material representation needs clearer justification. A comparison with MIRReS[1] should also account for geometry optimization: MIRReS[1] refines geometry during inverse rendering, whereas the proposed method keeps the geometry fixed after the first stage. In addition, RadioGS [2] is categorized as a deferred-shading method, although it performs forward shading on Gaussian surfels. Please clarify this categorization and whether it affected how this baseline was implemented and evaluated.
  2. Limited evidence for the advantages over deferred shading. The paper argues that its formulation avoids problems caused by view-dependent attribute blending, but does not directly evaluate robustness to camera-position or field-of-view(FoV) changes mentioned in lines 258-259. Figure 2 is also difficult to assess without ground truth, and some edges appear sharper in the deferred results. Ground-truth crops and quantitative comparisons under controlled camera and FoV changes changes would help support this claim. An analysis of sensitivity to Gaussian size and density would further clarify the trade-off between the two shading approaches.
  3. Unclear consistency between Gaussian materials and proxy textures. Matching Gaussian material maps with learnable textures in image space does not guarantee that the mesh textures provide consistent material values at secondary intersections. Their convergence and the impact of such discrepancy remains unclear. Intermediate albedo maps and convergence plots over training would help assess convergence and the reliability of this design. Also, note that MIRReS[1] directly queries material of the intesection from the radiance field, thus additional comparison or discussion seems necessary to further justify the design.
  4. Noisy albedo and environment map. In Figures 3 and 5, the albedo near the contact region between the hotdog and the plate appears noisy compared to existing works, and the noise is also visible in the relighting results. Also, Figure 13 show rather noisy environment map. Could you discuss the possible cause of such noise? In my opinion, the Monte Carlo path tracing may have led the noise. For comparison, MIRReS[1] adopts ReSTIR[3] and RadiosityGS[4] adopts weighted reservoir sampling to reduce variance, while the proposed work seem to use standard importance sampling methods. Additional discussion in sampling strategy might be necessary.

[1] Dai et al. "Inverse Rendering Using Multi-Bounce Path Tracing and Reservoir Sampling." International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR), 2025.

[2] Han et al. "Radiometrically Consistent Gaussian Surfels for Inverse Rendering." International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR), 2026.

[3] Bitterli et al. "Spatiotemporal Reservoir Resampling for Real-time Ray Tracing with Dynamic Direct Lighting." ACM Transactions on Graphics (SIGGRAPH), 2020.

[4] Jiang et al. "Differentiable Light Transport with Gaussian Surfels via Adapted Radiosity for Efficient Relighting and Geometry Reconstruction", ACM Transactions on Graphics (SIGGRAPH ASIA), 2025

Questions for authors

For brevity, questions closely related to the weaknesses are included in the section above. Additional questions are listed below.

  1. Ablation interpretation. On TensoIR, removing indirect illumination during training improves albedo PSNR (+ 0.42dB). Removing multi-view consistency also improves relighting PSNR (+0.08dB) and albedo PSNR (+0.13dB). Is there additional analysis explaining these results?

  2. Rendering cost and relighting efficiency. Could you provide a rendering-cost analysis, separating path tracing and Gaussian rasterization time and reporting how the cost changes with image resolution, samples per Gaussian, and number of bounces? A comparison with RadioGS's finetuning-based relighting would also be useful.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Hfq5 (1)

W1: Missing related work

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the valuable suggestions, which have helped us improve the quality of our manuscript. We have expanded the related work section to discuss MIRReS and other relevant methods, and have also compared our method with MIRReS in terms of relighting quality. In the original manuscript, RadioGS was incorrectly categorized as a deferred-shading method. RadioGS performs surfel-level forward shading and uses a forward rasterizer to alpha-blend the resulting radiances. We have corrected this categorization in the revised manuscript and moved RadioGS to the discussion of forward-shading-based methods. This miscategorization in the text did not affect our baseline implementation or experimental evaluation. We used the official RadioGS implementation and preserved its original forward-shading and rasterization pipeline.

W2 & W3: Consistency between Gaussian and Mesh Representations and Limited evidence for the advantages over deferred shading.

We thank the reviewer for pointing out this important issue. We agree that matching Gaussian-rendered and mesh-rendered material maps in image space alone does not guarantee exact material consistency at all secondary intersections.

In our method, we use a modified VA-GS, a variant of PGSR, for geometry reconstruction. During this stage, multi-view consistency constraints encourage consistent surface geometry across different input views. This provides a basis for establishing a relatively stable spatial correspondence between the Gaussian representation and the extracted mesh proxy, supporting subsequent material alignment. In the second stage, we keep the mesh geometry and its UV parameterization fixed and optimize the learnable mesh textures by matching mesh-rendered and Gaussian-rendered material maps across multiple training views. Thus, the same surface region receives material supervision from multiple viewpoints whenever it is visible in those views. Moreover, secondary rays query the mesh material using the UV coordinates of their actual intersection points, providing a view-independent material lookup mechanism. Additionally, following GHPT, we discard intersections at very short distances from the ray origin and reject back-facing intersections. We have also added visualizations of Gaussian-based and mesh-based albedo estimates for different scenes during training, together with loss convergence curves for the second training stage. Across the displayed iterations, the Gaussian-based and mesh-based albedo estimates remain closely aligned in their surface color distributions, demonstrating good material consistency between the two representations. The loss convergence curves further show that our second-stage optimization converges stably across different scenes.

We thank the reviewer for raising questions about the effect of the camera’s field of view on deferred shading and the convergence of our method. In the Appendix, we provide visual comparisons of deferred- and forward-shading results under different fields of view (FoVs). These comparisons show that the results produced by deferred shading vary as the FoV changes. We have added ground truth images to Figure 2 in the revised manuscript to facilitate a direct visual comparison.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Hfq5 (2)

W4: Noisy albedo and environment maps

We thank the reviewer for raising concerns about noise. We agree that the noticeable noise in the estimated environment maps originates from Monte Carlo integration. During optimization, we employ BRDF importance sampling and environment-map importance sampling, but do not incorporate weighted reservoir sampling for variance reduction.Spatial and temporal resampling are not directly applicable to our method.

Specifically, our per-Gaussian shading formulation does not provide the screen-space neighborhoods typically required for spatial resampling, while temporal resampling is incompatible with our optimization process. MIRReS performs resampling across different samples, producing a noise-reduction effect similar to increasing the sample count.

The relatively high learning rate used to optimize material parameters makes material updates more sensitive to Monte Carlo sampling noise. Consequently, the estimated albedo near the contact region between the hotdog and the board appears noisier than that of existing methods, and this noise is also visible in the relighting results. The noise in the estimated environment maps also originates from Monte Carlo sampling, and the relatively high learning rate used to optimize these maps makes the noise more pronounced.

Our experiments show that lowering the environment map learning rate reduces noise but leads to less complete disentanglement of material and illumination within the same training budget, thereby degrading relighting quality. Similarly, lowering the material learning rate also results in less complete disentanglement within the same training budget. We therefore adopt relatively high learning rates for both material parameters and environment maps as a trade-off, accepting some visible noise in the estimated materials and environment maps to preserve the quality of material estimation and relighting.

Q1: Ablation interpretation

We thank the reviewer for their questions regarding our ablation study. The previously reported improvement in albedo PSNR on TensoIR when removing indirect illumination during training was due to an error in compiling the experimental results. We apologize for this error and have corrected the results in the revised manuscript. Removing multi-view consistency yields slight improvements in the average relighting PSNR +00˙8dB+0\.08 dB and albedo PSNR +01˙3dB+0\.13 dB. These gains are primarily driven by the Lego scene, whereas retaining multi-view consistency improves performance on the other scenes.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Hfq5 (3)

Q2: Rendering cost and relighting efficiency

We thank the reviewer for raising concerns about the efficiency of our method. We evaluated rendering efficiency on the Synthetic4Relight and TensoIR datasets at a resolution of 800 × 800, varying the number of samples per pixel and the maximum number of ray bounces, and reported the time spent on path tracing and rasterization separately. Since our method performs rendering on a per-Gaussian basis, the rendering cost is dominated by path tracing, whose runtime depends on the number of Gaussians.

In addition, we compared the rendering times of our method, IRGS, RadioGS, and the fine-tuned version of RadioGS using 256 samples per pixel. Although the fine-tuned version of RadioGS renders faster, it requires precomputation and does not support fully dynamic lighting. In contrast, our method supports fully dynamic lighting without such precomputation. We also provide a comparison of the training times of IRGS, RadioGS, and our method on both datasets. Our method achieves the shortest total training time on both datasets.

Rendering times under varying sample counts and maximum bounce counts

Sample CountMax BouncesPath Tracing (ms)Rasterization (ms)
1611.811.28
1632.491.29
1652.671.30
6417.421.30
64310.191.32
64510.961.33
256127.771.30
256335.871.33
256544.101.27

Rendering time (ms) at 256 spp

MethodSynthetic4Relight: Air Balloons msmsSynthetic4Relight: Chair msmsSynthetic4Relight: Hotdog msmsSynthetic4Relight: Jugs msmsTensoIR: Armadillo msmsTensoIR: Ficus msmsTensoIR: Hotdog msmsTensoIR: Lego msms
IRGS1934.631003.312547.821337.98695.67530.382043.061442.4
RadioGS118.07210.8586.59136.18148.67167.3970.92257.5
RadioGS (finetuned)––––5.085.135.015.92
Ours47.838.3528.7832.5928.08107.7629.7856.61

Training time (h)

MethodSynthetic4Relight: Stage ISynthetic4Relight: Stage IISynthetic4Relight: TotalTensoIR: Stage ITensoIR: Stage IITensoIR: Total
IRGS0.720.501.220.750.501.25
RadioGS0.751.101.850.801.101.90
Ours (deferred shading)0.500.250.750.500.250.75
Ours (forward shading)0.500.150.650.500.150.65
Reviewer_33GYOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a two-stage inverse rendering framework that combines planar-based Gaussians with a reconstructed scene mesh. The first stage reconstructs geometry using a modified version of VA-GS and extracts a surface mesh. With geometry fixed, the second stage estimates outgoing radiance at each Gaussian center through mesh-based multi-bounce light transport. The resulting radiance is α-blended through differentiable Gaussian rasterization to jointly optimize per-Gaussian material parameters and the environment map. Auxiliary mesh material textures are updated through image-space alignment to provide material values at secondary ray intersections. The paper reports quantitative results for novel view synthesis, albedo estimation, and relighting on Synthetic4Relight and TensoIR, with additional qualitative results on Mip-NeRF 360 in Appendix B.

Critical strengths
  • The combination has a reasonable motivation. Computing outgoing radiance before α-blending avoids evaluating shading and visibility queries using blended geometric and material attributes, which may not correspond to a valid surface point.
  • The framework reduces the number of separate optimization stages. Compared with GHPT [1], which first estimates mesh materials and illumination and subsequently recovers Gaussian materials through factorized inverse path tracing, this framework jointly optimizes Gaussian materials and the environment map while updating auxiliary mesh material textures. This removes the need for a separate mesh material and illumination estimation stage.
  • The reported results improve upon the compared baselines on several metrics. In particular, the method achieves relighting PSNRs of 37.15 dB on Synthetic4Relight and 32.88 dB on TensoIR, the highest values among the methods reported in Tables 1 and 2.
Critical weaknesses
  • Limited methodological novelty. Per-Gaussian shading before α-blending is already used in R3DG [2] and SVG-IR [3]. Mesh-based visibility and indirect illumination evaluation, together with differentiation restricted to direct illumination, are already present in GHPT [1]. Matching Gaussian-rendered and mesh-rendered material maps also has a related precedent in TexGaussian [4]. The combination is reasonably motivated, but its technical novelty remains unclear.
  • The benefit of the central design is not quantitatively isolated. Section 4.1 states that a deferred shading variant is implemented under the same training configuration, but only qualitative comparisons are provided. No quantitative results or timing comparisons are reported for this variant. Since the framework also changes geometry reconstruction, normal supervision, and material regularization relative to GHPT, the comparisons do not isolate the contribution of per-Gaussian forward shading. Reporting the proposed method’s training time alone, without baseline timings on the same hardware, also does not establish its efficiency advantage.
  • The experimental reporting is incomplete. Section 5.1 includes roughness among the quantities evaluated using PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS, but the tables do not report roughness metrics. Similarly, Figure 5 includes qualitative results without material smoothness regularization, whereas Table 3 omits the corresponding quantitative ablation.
Questions for authors
  1. What specific technical contribution distinguishes the joint optimization and online mesh material alignment from a combination of existing forward shading, mesh-based light transport, and image-space material transfer?
  2. Could the authors provide quantitative and timing comparisons with the deferred shading variant under identical settings? Training and rendering timings for both variants and relevant baselines on the same hardware would also help assess the claimed efficiency.
  3. Could the authors clarify the experimental settings and provenance of the w/o indirect (relight) row in Table 3? Its six relighting metrics—34.68/0.968/0.047 on Synthetic4Relight and 32.28/0.947/0.058 on TensoIR—exactly match the w/o indirect row in GHPT’s Table 4. Were these results independently obtained using the proposed method? Please specify which model was evaluated and whether indirect illumination was disabled during training, relighting, or both. Removing indirect illumination does not eliminate the differences in shading formulation, geometry, and material estimation between the two methods.
  4. Could the authors provide the roughness metrics mentioned in Section 5.1 and quantitative results for the material smoothness ablation shown in Figure 5?

References

[1] Jinyang Bo, Fan Dou, Wenrui Quan, Shangxun Liu, Yang Xu, Yuhe Zhang, Kang Li, and Guohua Geng. GHPT: Real-Time Relightable Gaussian Splatting using Hybrid Path Tracing. CVPR, 2026.

[2] Jian Gao et al. Relightable 3D Gaussians: Realistic Point Cloud Relighting with BRDF Decomposition and Ray Tracing. ECCV, 2024.

[3] Hanxiao Sun et al. SVG-IR: Spatially-Varying Gaussian Splatting for Inverse Rendering. CVPR, 2025.

[4] Bojun Xiong et al. TexGaussian: Generating High-quality PBR Material via Octree-based 3D Gaussian Splatting. CVPR, 2025.

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 33GY (1)

W1 & Q1 : Question of our contribution

We thank the reviewer for these constructive comments on our method. Our contribution lies in integrating R3DG’s per-Gaussian forward shading with GHPT’s mesh-based hybrid path tracing to enable efficient relighting under dynamically changing environment lighting. Compared with GHPT, our method achieves substantially better novel view synthesis NVSNVS quality and superior relighting quality, while requiring fewer training stages and less training time.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 33GY (2)

W2 & Q2 : Quantitative evaluation and efficiency

We thank the reviewer for raising concerns about the efficiency of our method. We present a quantitative comparison between deferred and forward shading for each scene in the Synthetic4Relight and TensoIR datasets. We evaluated rendering efficiency on the Synthetic4Relight and TensoIR datasets at a resolution of 800 × 800, varying the number of samples per pixel and the maximum number of ray bounces, and reported the time spent on path tracing and rasterization separately. Since our method performs rendering on a per-Gaussian basis, the rendering cost is dominated by path tracing, whose runtime depends on the number of Gaussians. In addition, we compared the rendering times of our method, IRGS, RadioGS, and the fine-tuned version of RadioGS using the 256 samples per pixel. Although the fine-tuned version of RadioGS renders faster, it requires precomputation and does not support fully dynamic lighting. In contrast, our method supports fully dynamic lighting without such precomputation.

Relighting

Synthetic4Relight

MethodAir Balloons PSNR↑Chair PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Jugs PSNR↑Air Balloons SSIM↑Chair SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Jugs SSIM↑Air Balloons LPIPS↓Chair LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Jugs LPIPS↓
Deferred shading35.3436.9733.1940.130.9720.9810.9650.9880.0620.0270.0540.014
Forward shading36.3638.4433.7240.080.9700.9810.9660.9870.0640.0280.0500.016

TensoIR

MethodArmadillo PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Ficus PSNR↑Lego PSNR↑Armadillo SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Ficus SSIM↑Lego SSIM↑Armadillo LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Ficus LPIPS↓Lego LPIPS↓
Deferred shading38.3232.4532.6127.340.9740.9540.9650.9250.0460.0680.0290.067
Forward shading38.8232.5732.7027.450.9750.9560.9630.9250.0450.0580.0270.063

Novel View Synthesis

Synthetic4Relight

MethodAir Balloons PSNR↑Chair PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Jugs PSNR↑Air Balloons SSIM↑Chair SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Jugs SSIM↑Air Balloons LPIPS↓Chair LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Jugs LPIPS↓
Deferred shading37.8539.6236.7843.300.9790.9830.9770.9910.0470.0210.0380.013
Forward shading38.4240.1036.7444.090.9790.9830.9760.9920.0510.0220.0380.014

TensoIR

MethodArmadillo PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Ficus PSNR↑Lego PSNR↑Armadillo SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Ficus SSIM↑Lego SSIM↑Armadillo LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Ficus LPIPS↓Lego LPIPS↓
Deferred shading42.2736.3235.8834.320.9840.9740.9780.9590.0300.0400.0190.037
Forward shading43.6236.4337.6534.660.9860.9730.9860.9610.0280.0390.0160.036

Albedo

Synthetic4Relight

MethodAir Balloons PSNR↑Chair PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Jugs PSNR↑Air Balloons SSIM↑Chair SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Jugs SSIM↑Air Balloons LPIPS↓Chair LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Jugs LPIPS↓
Deferred shading31.0730.7829.8638.080.9520.9610.9450.9710.0820.0420.1000.057
Forward shading32.1932.6229.1938.040.9490.9620.9450.9710.0810.0400.1000.059

TensoIR

MethodArmadillo PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Ficus PSNR↑Lego PSNR↑Armadillo SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Ficus SSIM↑Lego SSIM↑Armadillo LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Ficus LPIPS↓Lego LPIPS↓
Deferred shading44.2329.0136.3123.070.9760.9440.9720.8610.0640.0920.0320.154
Forward shading44.7429.1236.3424.000.9780.9440.9740.8640.0620.0900.0360.155
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 33GY (3)

The rendering times, training times, and rendering times under varying numbers of samples per pixel and maximum ray bounces are reported below.

Rendering time (ms) at 256 spp

MethodSynthetic4Relight: Air Balloons msmsSynthetic4Relight: Chair msmsSynthetic4Relight: Hotdog msmsSynthetic4Relight: Jugs msmsTensoIR: Armadillo msmsTensoIR: Ficus msmsTensoIR: Hotdog msmsTensoIR: Lego msms
IRGS1934.631003.312547.821337.98695.67530.382043.061442.4
RadioGS118.07210.8586.59136.18148.67167.3970.92257.5
RadioGS (finetuned)––––5.085.135.015.92
Ours47.838.3528.7832.5928.08107.7629.7856.61

Training time (h)

MethodSynthetic4Relight: Stage ISynthetic4Relight: Stage IISynthetic4Relight: TotalTensoIR: Stage ITensoIR: Stage IITensoIR: Total
IRGS0.720.501.220.750.501.25
RadioGS0.751.101.850.801.101.90
Ours (deferred shading)0.500.250.750.500.250.75
Ours (forward shading)0.500.150.650.500.150.65

Rendering times under varying sample counts and maximum bounce counts

Sample CountMax BouncesPath Tracing (ms)Rasterization (ms)
1611.811.28
1632.491.29
1652.671.30
6417.421.30
64310.191.32
64510.961.33
256127.771.30
256335.871.33
256544.101.27

W3 & Q3 & Q4: Ablation study

We thank the reviewer for their question about our ablation study. When preparing our ablation table, we extracted the table structure from Table 4 of GHPT, a prior work by other authors, to serve as a formatting template. In doing so, we mistakenly retained the six values in its “w/o indirect” (relight) row instead of replacing them with the results of our own ablation study. These values therefore originated from GHPT, not from an independent evaluation of our proposed method, and should not have been presented as our experimental results in the original submission. We have now replaced this row with the correct results obtained through an independent evaluation of our proposed method.

Here, “w/o indirect” denotes disabling indirect illumination during both training and relighting, whereas “w/o indirect (relight)” denotes disabling indirect illumination only during relighting. In addition, we have added quantitative results for the material smoothness ablation. Although removing the smoothness loss improves albedo PSNR on TensoIR, it reduces the visual quality of the estimated albedo and roughness maps. Separately, removing this loss also degrades relighting quality.

MethodSynthetic4Relight: NVS PSNR↑Synthetic4Relight: Albedo PSNR↑Synthetic4Relight: Relight PSNR↑Synthetic4Relight: Relight SSIM↑Synthetic4Relight: Relight LPIPS↓TensoIR: NVS PSNR↑TensoIR: Albedo PSNR↑TensoIR: Relight PSNR↑TensoIR: Relight SSIM↑TensoIR: Relight LPIPS↓
w/o indirect39.5131.8135.590.9730.04137.9132.8732.860.9540.050
w/o indirect (relight)37.14–35.240.9720.04136.44–32.740.9540.050
w/o L_smooth39.3532.7336.80.9750.04038.133.8732.560.9530.049
Full39.8433.0137.150.9760.03938.0933.5532.880.9550.048
Reviewer_FAksOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a two-phase planar Gaussian-mesh inverse rendering framework. First, it reconstructs Gaussian geometry and extracts a mesh using a modified version of VA-GS with external normal supervision from MoGe-3. For the second phase, with the fixed geometry, material and environment lighting are jointly optimized. The renderer evaluates radiance at each Gaussian center using the extracted mesh as visibility and multi-bounce proxy. The auxilary mesh material textures are optimized with Gaussian material maps. The experiments show improved relighting results on Synthetic4Relight and TensorIR dataset, alongside qualitative results on real scenes.

Critical strengths
  • Competitive relighting results The paper presents an inverse rendering framework using plarnar Gaussians and extracted mesh proxy. The paper reports the full system achieves good novel view synthetis and relighting performance on Synthetic4Relight and TensorIR datasets. Compared with GHPT, the relighting PSNR improved from 35.87dB to 37.15dB on Synthetic4Relight and from 32.46 to 32.88 on TensorIR and the NVS PSNR improved from 37.11 to 39.84, 35.57 to 38.09 respectively . The real-scene examples in the appendix support the practicality of applying this framework to real scenes. These results support the effectiveness of the overall framework, although it does not lead every NVS or material-recovery metric

  • A practical hybrid rendering framework The paper integrates per-Gaussian shading with an extracted mesh proxy for indirect lighting and visibility evaluation. The image is still composed using Gaussian alpha blending. The two-phase design separates geometry reconstruction from material and lighting estimation. In the second stage, Gaussian materials and environment lighting are optimized together, with auxiliary mesh textures updated through material alignment. This is a coherent integration of the two representations, although the benefits of the individual design choices require further experimental isolation.

Critical weaknesses
  • The overall system is a combination of many existing approaches and some new designs. Several major components have precedents in prior work: planar Gaussian representation and geometry reconstruction(PGSR/VA-GS) explicit external nomal supervision and extraction of mesh as the light transport proxy(GHPT) shading before Gaussian alpha blending(R3DG/SVG-IR) multi-view material consistency regularization(MaterialRefGS) joint estimation of material and environment lighting(R3DG/GS-IR/GI-GS) The main contribution therefore is the integration (and modification) of Gaussian-center shading with mesh-based light transport, with coupled optimization of materials and environment map, and auxiliary mesh textures. The integration itself can be valuable, but the current experiments do not sufficiently establish which changes account for the reported improvements. For example, comparing with the closest baseline GHPT, the method changes reconstruction, normal supervision, shading, optimization and regularization simultanrously. Figure 2 provides the qualitative comparison of why choosing forward shading instead of deferred shading, but no quantatative results are reported. Furthermore, the paper claims its reconstruction modifications brings improved geometry without directly evaluatin geometry accuracy. As a result, rationales of making those design choices and modifications are not presented cleanly in the paper. I have written down the evidence that would help with the assessment of the significance of the paper's contribution in Questions for Authors section.

  • The paper claims one of its contribution to be improved efficiency on both optimization time and rendering time(frame time). However, the paper only reports the training times for their own method. There are no matched training timing for the baselines to establish the training-speed advanrage. Moreover, the paper does not report rendering latency or FPS. This makes the rendering efficiency claim unsupported. The choice of evaluating radiance per Gaussian instead of per pixel does not guarantee a lower overall computational cost because the cost depends on Gaussian counts, resolution, path length, and ray sampling budget. Since efficiency is emphasized int he title and contributions. Comparable training timings and rendering timings are important for determining the advanrage over other methods.

Questions for authors
  1. Quantitative evaluation of the shading method

Section 4.1 describes the deferred variant using the same configuration. Could you report the quantitative results of quality and runtime for the forward/deferred comparision shown in Figure 2 across scenes? This will help establish the benefit of the proposed forward shading formulation without entanglement with reconsturction and supervision changes

  1. Rationale for Gaussian-center shading.

Per-Gaussian shading has precedents such as R3DG. What motivates the choice of the Gaussian center evaluation in the proposed renderer? Does it introduce any accuracy-cost tradeoff? From what I understand, if the sparial variation in illumination or specular reflection is dominant, per-pixel shading might have better results. Figure 2 only compares forward v.s. deferred. But no Gaussian center v.s. other forward-shading choices

  1. Evidence for geometry-reconstruction modifications

Do the modifications to VA-GS and the additional normal prior improve the accuracy of the reconstructed geometry compared with original pipeline? Experiments showing improved geometry accuracy will help substantiate the motivation of those changes.

  1. Evidence for efficiency

As stated in weakness 2, could you provide the comparative training times and rendering times under matched hardware and comparable quality against baselines?

  1. Diffentiating direct illumination only

The paper's appendix states that only direct illumination is differentiated. What motivates this approximation? is it computational cost, implementation issues, optimization stability or other considerations? If a region has large indirect contribution, will ignoring indirect contribution's gradient cause inaccurate shading results?

Questions 1 and 4 are most important to the recommendation, as they directly concern the evidence for the proposed shading formulation and efficiency advantage. Question 3 would help clarify the contribution of the reconstruction changes, while Questions 2 and 5 are for explanations of important design choices and limitations. My current recommendation is weak rejection, but I am open to revising it if the authors provide convincing evidence addressing the central concerns. I do not expect exhaustive ablations of every component.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FAks (1)

W1 & Q1: Quantitative evaluation of the shading method

We thank the reviewer for raising concerns about the evaluation of quality. For each scene in the Synthetic4Relight and TensoIR datasets, we report quantitative comparisons between deferred and forward shading for relighting, novel view synthesis (NVS), and albedo, in that order. During the second stage, training with forward and deferred shading takes an average of 10 and 15 minutes, respectively.

Relighting

Synthetic4Relight

MethodAir Balloons PSNR↑Chair PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Jugs PSNR↑Air Balloons SSIM↑Chair SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Jugs SSIM↑Air Balloons LPIPS↓Chair LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Jugs LPIPS↓
Deferred shading35.3436.9733.1940.130.9720.9810.9650.9880.0620.0270.0540.014
Forward shading36.3638.4433.7240.080.9700.9810.9660.9870.0640.0280.0500.016

TensoIR

MethodArmadillo PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Ficus PSNR↑Lego PSNR↑Armadillo SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Ficus SSIM↑Lego SSIM↑Armadillo LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Ficus LPIPS↓Lego LPIPS↓
Deferred shading38.3232.4532.6127.340.9740.9540.9650.9250.0460.0680.0290.067
Forward shading38.8232.5732.7027.450.9750.9560.9630.9250.0450.0580.0270.063

Novel View Synthesis

Synthetic4Relight

MethodAir Balloons PSNR↑Chair PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Jugs PSNR↑Air Balloons SSIM↑Chair SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Jugs SSIM↑Air Balloons LPIPS↓Chair LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Jugs LPIPS↓
Deferred shading37.8539.6236.7843.300.9790.9830.9770.9910.0470.0210.0380.013
Forward shading38.4240.1036.7444.090.9790.9830.9760.9920.0510.0220.0380.014

TensoIR

MethodArmadillo PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Ficus PSNR↑Lego PSNR↑Armadillo SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Ficus SSIM↑Lego SSIM↑Armadillo LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Ficus LPIPS↓Lego LPIPS↓
Deferred shading42.2736.3235.8834.320.9840.9740.9780.9590.0300.0400.0190.037
Forward shading43.6236.4337.6534.660.9860.9730.9860.9610.0280.0390.0160.036

Albedo

Synthetic4Relight

MethodAir Balloons PSNR↑Chair PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Jugs PSNR↑Air Balloons SSIM↑Chair SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Jugs SSIM↑Air Balloons LPIPS↓Chair LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Jugs LPIPS↓
Deferred shading31.0730.7829.8638.080.9520.9610.9450.9710.0820.0420.1000.057
Forward shading32.1932.6229.1938.040.9490.9620.9450.9710.0810.0400.1000.059

TensoIR

MethodArmadillo PSNR↑Hotdog PSNR↑Ficus PSNR↑Lego PSNR↑Armadillo SSIM↑Hotdog SSIM↑Ficus SSIM↑Lego SSIM↑Armadillo LPIPS↓Hotdog LPIPS↓Ficus LPIPS↓Lego LPIPS↓
Deferred shading44.2329.0136.3123.070.9760.9440.9720.8610.0640.0920.0320.154
Forward shading44.7429.1236.3424.000.9780.9440.9740.8640.0620.0900.0360.155
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FAks (2)

Q2:About Gaussian-center shading

We thank the reviewer for this insightful comment. Our choice of Gaussian-center shading is primarily motivated by the consistency of geometric and material attributes during shading. Specifically, our forward-shading formulation evaluates the BRDF and incident illumination at each Gaussian center using its associated geometric and material attributes, and subsequently alpha-blends the resulting radiance. This allows shading to be performed using the original per-Gaussian attributes before blending, rather than relying on screen-space attributes obtained by blending multiple Gaussians. In contrast, blending Gaussian attributes before shading, as in deferred shading, may lead to inaccurate depth, normal, and material estimates, particularly in multi-layer regions, near depth boundaries, and on thin structures such as leaves. Furthermore, the blended attributes vary with camera pose and field of view, potentially introducing view-dependent inconsistencies. By evaluating shading independently at each Gaussian center, our approach directly uses the corresponding geometric and material attributes of each Gaussian, avoiding additional errors introduced by screen-space attribute blending.

To further validate this observation, we provide qualitative comparisons between forward and deferred shading under different camera poses and field-of-view settings in Appendix D.1. As shown in Fig. 15, the rendering results of deferred shading exhibit variations with changes in camera pose and field of view, whereas those of forward shading remain largely unaffected.

We acknowledge that Gaussian-center shading assigns a single outgoing radiance value to each Gaussian, which may not fully capture spatial variations in visibility or specular reflections within its projected footprint. We agree that the spatially-varying shading strategy adopted by SVG-IR offers a promising direction for addressing this limitation. In future work, we plan to explore such a strategy to better capture spatially-varying appearance within individual Gaussian primitives while maintaining consistent geometric and material representations.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FAks (3)

W1 & Q3: Question of geometric accuracy

We thank the reviewer for raising concerns about geometric accuracy. We conducted a geometry ablation study to evaluate the impact of geometric quality on relighting performance by comparing PGSR with normal priors against our modified VA-GS. We provide a quantitative comparison of the relighting results. Our modified VA-GS improves relighting performance in most scenes, indicating that more accurate geometry reconstruction can contribute to better relighting quality.

Relighting

Synthetic4Relight

MethodAir Balloons PSNR ↑Chair PSNR ↑Hotdog PSNR ↑Jugs PSNR ↑Air Balloons SSIM ↑Chair SSIM ↑Hotdog SSIM ↑Jugs SSIM ↑Air Balloons LPIPS ↓Chair LPIPS ↓Hotdog LPIPS ↓Jugs LPIPS ↓
PGSR (MoGe-3)36.2238.1433.0739.910.9680.9780.9610.9860.0660.0330.0560.018
Ours36.3638.4433.7240.080.9700.9810.9660.9870.0640.0280.0500.016

TensoIR

MethodArmadillo PSNR ↑Hotdog PSNR ↑Ficus PSNR ↑Lego PSNR ↑Armadillo SSIM ↑Hotdog SSIM ↑Ficus SSIM ↑Lego SSIM ↑Armadillo LPIPS ↓Hotdog LPIPS ↓Ficus LPIPS ↓Lego LPIPS ↓
PGSR (MoGe-3)38.8932.2233.0326.920.9740.9510.9630.9190.0480.0630.0280.070
Ours38.8232.5732.7027.450.9750.9560.9630.9250.0450.0580.0270.063

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Our Responses and Revisions

We thank all reviewers for their careful reviews and constructive feedback, which have helped us improve both the content and presentation of our paper.

The revised PDF includes additional experiments and analyses (Tables 1–5, and Figures 15–18), with the additions highlighted in red. The main updates are summarized below:

Efficiency and Shading Comparison

  • We have added a quantitative comparison between deferred and forward shading. The results show that forward shading generally outperforms deferred shading across the evaluated metrics.
  • We have also compared training times and rendering times at the same number of samples per pixel against IRGS and RadioGS. Among the compared methods, our method achieves the shortest training time, while its rendering time is second only to that of fine-tuned RadioGS. Importantly, our method supports fully dynamic lighting, whereas RadioGS relies on precomputation.
  • We additionally report rendering times for different sample counts and numbers of light bounces.

Additional Experiments and Analyses

  • We have added an ablation study removing the smoothness loss, as well as additional experiments with PGSR incorporating MoGe-3 priors.
  • Compared with the configuration using PGSR incorporating MoGe-3 priors, the configuration using our modified VA-GS improves NVS PSNR by 0.96 dB on Synthetic4Relight dataset and 1.33 dB on TensoIR dataset.
  • We have added a quantitative comparison of roughness estimation, in which our method achieves the lowest MSE among the compared methods.
  • We also provide visualizations of Gaussian and mesh albedo during training, along with training loss convergence curves, to illustrate the albedo optimization process and the convergence behavior of our method.
  • We further provide visual comparisons illustrating the effects of changes in camera pose and field of view on rendering results under deferred and forward shading. Under the evaluated settings, deferred shading exhibits noticeable variations, whereas forward shading produces comparatively consistent results.

We sincerely thank the Area Chair and all reviewers for their time and consideration. We look forward to further clarifying the technical details during the discussion phase.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Summary

Dear Reviewers and Area Chair,

As the rebuttal period draws to a close, we would like to provide a brief summary of the clarifications and additional evidence presented in our responses.

First, we sincerely thank all the reviewers for taking the time to carefully read our paper and provide constructive feedback. We particularly appreciate their thoughtful and insightful comments, which have helped us identify aspects of our work that require further clarification and stronger empirical support.

In response to the reviewers' concerns, we have provided additional explanations and experimental evidence and revised the manuscript accordingly, with all changes highlighted in red. The main updates are summarized below:

1. Efficiency Evaluation

We provided training-time comparisons with IRGS and RadioGS. Our method requires only 40 minutes for the entire two-stage training process, with 30 minutes for the first stage and only 10 minutes for the second stage. We also compared the rendering times of IRGS, RadioGS, and a fine-tuned version of RadioGS under the same number of samples. Among the compared methods, only the fine-tuned RadioGS variant achieves a shorter rendering time than ours. However, RadioGS requires precomputation, whereas our method does not and supports fully dynamic lighting. Furthermore, we provided additional rendering-time comparisons between path tracing and rasterization, considering different sampling rates and ray-bounce counts for path tracing, offering a more comprehensive evaluation of rendering efficiency.

2. Additional Quantitative Evaluation

We supplemented our quantitative evaluation with comparisons against MIRReS and deferred shading, as well as roughness MSE evaluation on the Synthetic4Relight dataset. Our method achieves the lowest roughness MSE among the compared methods. Moreover, on both the Synthetic4Relight and TensoIR datasets, our method achieves higher PSNR than all baseline methods for both novel view synthesis (NVS) and relighting.

3. Comparison with Deferred Shading

We provided further analysis, together with quantitative and qualitative comparisons with deferred shading. The deferred shading approach requires approximately 45 minutes of training, while our method takes approximately 40 minutes.

In deferred shading, blending Gaussian attributes before shading can lead to inaccurate estimates of depth, normals, and material properties, particularly for thin objects. Fig. 2 of our paper presents a qualitative comparison between the two shading approaches. Furthermore, changes in camera pose or field of view can affect the projection and blending of Gaussians, thereby altering the effective attributes used for shading. Appendix Fig. 16 provides additional qualitative comparisons under different fields of view and camera poses.

Compared with deferred shading, our method achieves better overall performance on both datasets. Specifically, on the Synthetic4Relight dataset, our method improves PSNR by 0.45 dB, 0.57 dB, and 0.74 dB for NVS, albedo estimation, and relighting, respectively, while maintaining comparable SSIM and LPIPS. On the TensoIR dataset, the corresponding PSNR gains are 0.89 dB, 0.40 dB, and 0.20 dB, respectively. In addition, SSIM improves to 0.955 and LPIPS decreases to 0.048. These results demonstrate that our method effectively improves novel-view synthesis and albedo estimation while enhancing relighting quality.

4. Additional Experimental Results

We further included visualizations of Gaussian-based and mesh-based albedo estimates across different scenes and training iterations, together with loss convergence curves for the second optimization stage. Across the illustrated training iterations, the Gaussian-based and mesh-based albedo estimates exhibit highly consistent surface color distributions, demonstrating good material consistency between the two representations. Furthermore, the loss convergence curves show that our second-stage optimization converges stably across different scenes.

We have carefully considered the reviewers' comments and provided point-by-point responses to address the concerns raised. We hope that these clarifications and additional experimental results further demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of our method.

We hope that the reviewers will find our responses and additional experimental evidence helpful in their final evaluations. We also respectfully ask the Area Chair to consider our point-by-point responses and the additional evidence provided during the rebuttal period when making the final assessment.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Best regards,

The Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.