- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscript proposes MVSI-IMVC (Missing-View Self-Distillation Imputation for Incomplete Multi-View Clustering). It establishes a target-view self-distillation predictor. The idea is to exploit full-information and pseudo-missing states from complete samples as well as the observed target view as supervision information. Then teacher predictions are used to guide target-view latent recovery for incomplete samples. The following shortcomings are severe. The paper have no very solid contributions.
Critical strengths
A couple of methods are used to conduct experimental comparison.
Critical weaknesses
First, it seems that there have no enough evidences for that the proposed scheme can work well. It is unconvincing that self-distillation is competent in extracting effective information. Second, a distillation network can perform well only under the condition that there are a large amount of samples. However, I see that the used datasets do not satisfy this point. Third, four datasets from different fields are selected for experiments. Moreover, the used handWritten dataset (Duin, 1998), the Scene-15 dataset (Lazebnik et al., 2006), the LandUse-21 (Yang & Newsam, 2010) dataset, and the ALOI-100 dataset were constructed a long time ago. At present many large-scale datasets are available and more suitable.
Questions for authors
- Why is the desigined self-distillation scheme effective for missing-views? And how many samples are enough for the experiments? I hope to see convincing explanations and evidences.
- It is not known how to properly set the parameters of the self-distillation scheme.