- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TGRS, a unified framework for incomplete multi-view clustering (IMVC), which employs smooth self-representation learning to guide missing-view recovery and tensorized graph learning to capture high-order cross-view structural correlations and promote structural consistency. These components are jointly optimized through an alternating optimization strategy, and the resulting consensus graph is used for spectral clustering. Experiments on eight datasets under three missing ratios show that TGRS outperforms seven IMVC baselines in most evaluated settings, while ablation studies further support the contributions of the main components to overall clustering performance.
Critical strengths
- The paper presents a well-motivated joint framework that integrates smooth self-representation learning and tensorized graph learning, enabling mutual reinforcement between missing-view recovery and structural learning.
- The method achieves competitive clustering performance across eight datasets and three missing ratios, outperforming seven IMVC baselines in most settings. Ablation studies further support the effectiveness of the two main components.
Critical weaknesses
- The mathematical derivations contain several inconsistencies. For example, Eq. (22) does not generally follow from Eq. (19), while Eqs. (24)~(27) contain inconsistencies in the reconstruction loss and representation update, raising concerns about the correctness of the optimization procedure.
- The abstract claims monotonic convergence and parameter sensitivity analyses, but neither a convergence proof nor parameter sensitivity results are provided in the main paper.
- The effectiveness of representation-induced view recovery is not directly validated, as the experiments only report clustering metrics without evaluating the accuracy of recovered missing views.
- The novelty of the proposed framework relative to existing IMVC methods is not sufficiently established. In particular, the contribution of the iterative interaction between view recovery and tensorized graph learning is not clearly isolated or validated.
- The related work is incomplete, particularly regarding missing-view recovery methods. Additionally, the description of the two-step graph propagation method does not match the corresponding Zhang et al. (2024) reference, which concerns a different method.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors clarify the inconsistencies in Eqs. (19), (22), and (24)–(27)? Are these issues limited to the mathematical presentation, or do they also affect the implemented optimization algorithm and experimental results?
- Could the authors provide a theoretical justification for the claimed monotonic convergence and the parameter sensitivity results mentioned in the abstract?
- Could the authors directly evaluate the accuracy of representation-induced view recovery using reconstruction error metrics and comparisons with existing recovery methods? This would help verify whether the proposed mechanism improves missing-view recovery beyond the reported clustering performance.
- Could the authors clarify the specific novelty of the proposed joint framework compared with existing IMVC methods? In particular, can the benefits of joint optimization be demonstrated through comparisons with a two-stage approach that performs view recovery and graph learning separately?
- Could the authors expand the discussion of related work, particularly missing-view recovery methods, and clarify how the proposed approach differs from them? Additionally, please verify the Zhang et al. (2024) reference, which appears inconsistent with the description of the two-step graph propagation method.