- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TRACE, a flow-matching-based framework for incomplete multi-view clustering. The method learns view-specific latent representations and compact semantic codes in a first stage, then trains a shared velocity field to transport representations from observed views toward pseudo-missing views. During inference, representations generated from multiple observed views are aggregated to recover missing views, while the original observed representations are preserved.
Critical strengths
The two-stage design is reasonable and helps separate representation learning from missing-view recovery. Excluding the target view's semantic code from the transport condition is also a sensible choice to reduce potential information leakage during training.
Critical weaknesses
-
The ablation study is limited to one dataset and one missing-view ratio. It is therefore difficult to determine whether the contribution of each component remains consistent under other settings.
-
The method combines several recovered representations during inference, but the effect of this aggregation strategy is not examined separately.
Questions for authors
-
Would the main conclusions of the ablation study remain the same under a different missing-view ratio?
-
How does the performance change when the method uses only one observed view to recover a missing view instead of combining multiple candidates?
Q1: Would the main conclusions of the ablation study remain the same under a different missing-view ratio?
A1: We thank the reviewer for this question on the robustness of the ablation. We repeated the HandWritten ablation at 10%, 30%, 50%, and 70% with the masks and seeds of the corresponding Table 1 entries, so the Full row equals Table 1 at every rate. Entries are ACC / NMI / ARI (%), averaged over five seeds.
The conclusions hold across rates: Full is best in all three metrics at every rate. The 70% results are in Table 2 and all four rates, with standard deviations, in Table 4 (Appendix B). This confirms that every component contributes at all missing rates.
Q2: How does the performance change when the method uses only one observed view to recover a missing view instead of combining multiple candidates?
A2: We compared TRACE's multi-source aggregation with a single-source variant that keeps one authentic observed source per missing target, chosen by a fixed rule (sample index, target view, and seed). Both keep the same target-excluded semantic condition built from all available views, so the comparison isolates candidate aggregation; encoders, velocity field, integration budget, fusion, and clustering are unchanged. Entries average the four missing rates and five seeds per rate, as in Table 1. R²_rec = 1 − MSE_rec / MSE_mean is measured on genuinely hidden views against mean imputation; hidden values are used only for evaluation.
Aggregation gives higher recovery R² on all five datasets. The comparison is reported in Table 7 (Appendix B). Multi-source aggregation therefore consistently improves recovery quality and never lowers the average ACC on any dataset, supporting the use of all authentic observed views.