- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a novel Prototype-Routed Flow Matching (PRFM) for IMVC. PRFM explicitly incorporates dynamically updated clustering prototypes into the velocity field, combining prototype-routed and residual velocities to model the generation of missing-view latent representations. The paper further introduce prototype-prioritized soft-pair supervision and jointly optimize completed representations and clustering structures in shared prototype space. Experiments on multiple IMVC benchmarks demonstrate competitive clustering performance and efficient generation.
Critical strengths
1.The key innovation of this paper is to explicitly incorporate clustering prototypes into the Flow Matching velocity field, rather than using them solely as conditioning inputs or generation targets. The prototype-routed velocity provides cluster-level guidance, while the residual velocity preserves sample- and view-specific information, allowing missing-view completion to be more directly aligned with the clustering objective. This design is well motivated and offers a new perspective on generative incomplete multi-view clustering.
2.The paper cleverly integrates online prototype learning, prototype-guided generation, soft-pair supervision, and clustering optimization into a unified framework. The ablation studies are comprehensive, particularly the comparisons with Standard FM and Prototype-Cond. FM, which help distinguish the contributions of standard flow matching, prototype conditioning, and explicit prototype routing.
3.The paper compares PRFM with seven state-of-the-art IMVC methods across multiple benchmark datasets, demonstrating competitive clustering performance. In addition, PRFM reduces generation costs through few-step ODE inference. The runtime experiments further show clear inference speed advantage over diffusion-based completion methods, demonstrating good balance between clustering performance and computational efficiency.
Critical weaknesses
1.This paper dynamically updates clustering prototypes using EMA and employs them to guide the Flow Matching velocity field. However, it unclear how much additional benefit dynamic prototype updates provide compared with fixed prototypes.
2.Although PRFM explicitly incorporates prototype-routed guidance into the velocity field, the residual velocity may potentially counteract this guidance. Lacks analysis of how these two velocity components interact during inference, making it unclear to what extent prototype guidance is preserved in the resulting velocity field.
3.The existing ablation studies without separately evaluating the contributions of the clustering-alignment loss and confidence-weighted fusion strategy.
Questions for authors
Q1. Could authors provide a comparison with fixed prototypes to assess the contribution of EMA dynamic prototype updates?
Q2. Could authors analyze the relative magnitudes and directional alignment of the prototype-routed and residual velocities at different integration times to clarify how prototype guidance influences the learned velocity field?
Q3. Could authors provide ablation studies without the clustering-alignment loss and confidence-weighted fusion to clarify the individual contributions of these two components?
We thank the reviewer for these suggestions. We provide additional ablations for online prototype updates, clustering alignment, and confidence-weighted fusion, together with an analysis of the two velocity components during generation.
Response: We compared Full PRFM with Frozen Prototypes, which keeps the initialized prototype bank fixed instead of updating it through EMA. Table R1 reports the results on HandWritten and YouTubeFace10 at a 70% missing rate, together with the ablations requested in Q3.
Table R1. Additional ablations at a 70% missing rate.
Freezing the prototypes reduces ACC by 2.19 and 2.08 percentage points on HandWritten and YouTubeFace10, respectively, with decreases in NMI and ARI as well. These results support updating the prototypes during learning rather than relying solely on their initial values.
Response: We measured the weighted velocity components along inference trajectories on HandWritten and MSRC-V1 at a 70% missing rate. Here, R(t) is the prototype-component norm divided by the sum of the two component norms; A(t) is the cosine similarity between the two components; and P(t) is the cosine similarity between the total velocity and the direction toward the assigned prototype. The table reports averages over evaluated missing sample-view pairs.
Table R2. Velocity interaction at different integration times.
The total velocity has strong positive alignment with the prototype direction early in generation. As integration progresses, the relative prototype magnitude decreases and the residual component becomes dominant. The negative values of A(t) and P(t) near the endpoint confirm that the residual can counteract and override the prototype direction.
Thus, prototype guidance is not preserved as a strict directional constraint throughout generation. Instead, the observed behavior is consistent with the time-decaying guidance in Eq. (6): an early prototype-directed bias followed by greater residual flexibility. This is also compatible with Proposition 1, which allows the residual field to compensate for the explicit prototype term.
Response: Table R1 separately removes Lcomp and replaces confidence-weighted fusion with uniform averaging of the observed and generated latents.
Removing Lcomp produces small decreases across all three metrics on both datasets, including ACC reductions of 0.82 and 0.50 percentage points. This indicates a modest additional benefit from clustering alignment in the evaluated settings.
Uniform Fusion leads to larger reductions: ACC decreases by 6.34 and 8.76 percentage points on HandWritten and YouTubeFace10, respectively, accompanied by lower NMI and ARI. These results support weighting the view contributions rather than treating observed and generated representations equally.
We have added the Frozen Prototypes comparison to Appendix H.1 and the velocity-component analysis to Appendix H.2 of the revised manuscript.